Unit 2 AC2.3 AC3.2 Describe/evaluate sociological theories of criminality Flashcards
Functionalist theories - Durkheim’s functionalist theory - Key idea
Crime is the inevitable result of inadequate socialisation/anomie
Functionalist theories - Durkheim’s functionalist theory - Boundary maintenance
Crime unites society’s members against wrongdoers, reinforcing the boundary between right and wrong
Functionalist theories - Durkheim’s functionalist theory - Social change
For society to progress, individuals with new ideas must challenge existing norms and values – this is deviance at first
Functionalist theories - Durkheim’s functionalist theory - Safety Valve: Davis
For example prostitution acts to release men’s sexual frustrations without threatening the nuclear family.
Functionalist theories - Durkheim’s functionalist theory - Warning light
Deviance indicates that a society isn’t functioning properly so action can be taken to fix it.
Functionalist theories - Durkheim’s functionalist theory - Strength
First to recognise that crime can have positive functions for society
Functionalist theories - Durkheim’s functionalist theory - Limitation
Does not suggest what the right amount of crime is for society to function properly
Functionalist theories - Durkheim’s functionalist theory - Limitation
Crime is not functional for all – e.g. vicitims
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory - Key idea
Crime is the result of unequal access to society’s goal of wealth
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory -Blocked opportunities
Not all have equal chance to achieve wealth – this creates strain for working class people who cannot access wealth legitimately
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory -Innovation
Accept the goal but find illegal ways to achieve it - utilitarian crimes
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory -Ritualism
Give up striving for success. Plod along in dead-end job
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory -Retreatism
Reject goal and means to achieve. Drop-outs e.g. drunks, vagrants
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory -Rebellion
Reject goal and means, replacing them with new ones in order to change society – political radicals and alternative cultures e.g. hippies
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory -Strength
Shows how normal and deviant behaviour arise from the same goals
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory -Strength
Explains why most crime in statistics is property crime and why working class crime rates are higher.
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory -Limitation
Ignores crimes of wealthy
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory -Limitation
Only sees deviance as an individual response
Functionalist theories - Merton’s Strain theory -Limitation
Focuses on utilitarian crime only
Function
Functionalists argue that everything has a positive role to play in helping society to run smoothly
Structural theory
An explanation that focuses on the way in which society is organised
Socialisation
Process of learning norms and values
Social solidarity / integration
All members of society feel like they belong to the same harmonious unit and most do not deviate from it’s shared norms.
Anomie
‘Normlessness’ Society has multiple sets of norms and values that are often conflicting.
Strain
Conflict between the pressure to conform to society’s norms in but still achieve it’s main goals of monetary success
Utilitarian crime
Crimes committed for financial gain
Subcultural theories - Cohen: Status Frustration -Key idea
Crime is a group response to unequal access to society’s goal of wealth.
Subcultural theories - Cohen: Status Frustration - Status frustration
Working class boys end up at the bottom of school’s official status hierarchy and feel frustrated and worthless
Subcultural theories - Cohen: Status Frustration -Subcultures
Subcultures offer a solution by providing an alternate status hierarchy in which society’s values are inverted – they gain status by being deviant
Subcultural theories - Cloward and Ohlin 3 Subcultures -Key idea
Different neighbourhoods give rise to different types of deviant subcultures
Subcultural theories - Cloward and Ohlin 3 Subcultures - Criminal subcultures
Arise in areas where there is a longstanding professional criminal network. They select youths for an ‘apprenticeship’ in utilitarian crime and future criminal career
Subcultural theories - Cloward and Ohlin 3 Subcultures - Conflict subcultures
Arise where the only criminal opportunities are within street gangs. Violence is a release for frustration and a source of status earned by winning territory from rival gangs.
Retreatist subcultures
Made up of dropouts who have failed in both the legitimate and illegitimate opportunity structures. Often based on drug use.
Subcultural theories - Strength
These theories show how subcultures perform a function for their members by offering solutions to the problem of failing to achieve goals legitimately
Subcultural theories -Strength
Cloward and Ohlin show how different types of neighbourhood give rise to different illegitimate opportunities and subcultures
Subcultural theories -Limitation
Ignore crimes of wealthy and over-predicts working class crime
Subcultural theories -Limitation
Assume everyone starts with mainstream goals and turns to a subculture when they fail to achieve them, but some people don’t share those goals in the first place and may be attracted to crime for other reasons.
Subcultural theories -Limitation
Actual subcultures are not a clear-cut as Cloward and Ohlin claim. Some show characteristics of all three types.
Subculture
A group within society that has it’s own set of norms and values that differ from the mainstream
Status hierarchy
System of stratification based on social prestige. This can be linked to occupation, lifestyle etc.
Inverted values
Turning society’s values upside down so what is bad becomes good and vice versa
Non-utilitarian crime
Crimes committed without financial gain
Legitimate opportunity structure
A way to work your way up in society while staying within the confines of the law.
Illegitimate opportunity structure
A way to work your way up in society within a criminal or deviant network
Interactionism and labellign theories - Interactionism
Sees our interactions with each other as based on meanings or labels. Crime and criminals are social constructions.
Interactionism and labellign theories - Labelling theory
No act is deviant or criminal in itself – it only becomes so when others label it as such
Interactionism and labellign theories - Differential enforcement
Social control agencies use typifications to label some groups as criminal more than others
Interactionism and labellign theories - Primary and secondary deviance
Lemert argues that labelling is a cause of crime, He explains this by distinguishing between primary and secondary deviance
Interactionism and labellign theories - Self-fulfilling prophecy
When an offender is labelled, society’s reaction pushes them into further deviance. They have lived up to their label.
Interactionism and labellign theories - The deviance amplification spiral
An attempt to control deviance through a crackdown leads to it increasing rather than decreasing. This leads to greater attempts to control and even more deviance
Interactionism and labellign theories - Interactionism and crime statistics
Interactionists reject the use of statistics complied by the police because they believe they only measure what the police do (who they arrest) rather than what criminals do (how much crime there actually is).
Interactionism and labellign theories - Young: The Hippies
A study in which police attention and labelling led hippies to retreat into closed groups where drug use took over
The Mods and Rockers - The study
Cohen uses the Mods and Rockers study to explain the amplification spiral
The Mods and Rockers - Media exaggeration
Media exaggeration caused growing public concern
The Mods and Rockers - Moral entrepreneurs
Moral entrepreneurs called for a crackdown leading to more arrests, and more concern
The Mods and Rockers - Negative labelling
Negative labelling of mods and rockers as folk devils
Evaluating interactionism and labelling theories - Strength
Shows that the law is not a fixed set of rules but socially constructed
Evaluating interactionism and labelling theories -Strength
Shifts focus onto how police create crime by applying labels – may explain why some groups are overrepresented in crime statistics
Evaluating interactionism and labelling theories -Strength
Shows how attempts to control can create more deviance
Evaluating interactionism and labelling theories -Limitation
Deterministic – assumes we have no choice but to live up to labels
Evaluating interactionism and labelling theories -Limitation
Gives offenders a victim status
Evaluating interactionism and labelling theories -Limitation
Fails to explain primary deviance