Unit 2 AC2.2 AC3.2 Describe/evaluate individualistic theories of criminality Flashcards
Psychodynamic theories - Freud: Psychoanalysis - Key idea
Our early childhood experiences determine our personality and future behaviour including criminality
Psychodynamic theories - Freud: Psychoanalysis -Personality
3 conflicting elements of unconscious mind – id, ego and superego
Psychodynamic theories - Freud: Psychoanalysis -Link to crime
Anti-social behaviour caused by abnormal relationship with parents (neglect or excessively harsh or lax parenting). Conflicts between id, ego, and supergo are unresolved., which leads a to weak, over-harsh or deviant superego.
Psychodynamic theories - Freud: Psychoanalysis -Strength
Points to importance of socialisation and early family relationships in understanding criminal behaviour
Psychodynamic theories - Freud: Psychoanalysis -Strength
Some influence on policies for dealing with crime and deviance.
Psychodynamic theories - Freud: Psychoanalysis -Strength
Critics doubt the existence of the unconscious mind
Psychodynamic theories - Freud: Psychoanalysis -
Unscientific and subjective – relies on accepting claims of a psychoanalyst about the unconscious mind of someone else. No way to tell if they’re correct!
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -Key idea
There is a link between maternal deprivation and deviant or anti-social behaviour
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -Attachment
A child needs a close, continuous relationship with a primary carer from birth to 5 to develop normally.
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -Separation
If attachment is broken, even for a short time, it can lead to affectionless psychopathy and criminal behaviour
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -Evidence
Study of 44 juvenile thieves referred to child guidance clinic. 39% suffered maternal deprivation before the age of 5 compared with 5% of control group of non-delinquents
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -Strength
Backed up with evidence from the 44 thieves study
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -Strength
Shows the importance of parent-child relationships in criminality
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -Limitation
Retrospective studies rely on memory
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -Limitation
Doesn’t explain why 61% were not delinquent
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -Limitation
No evidence of affectionless psychopathy in further studies
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -
Overestimates how far early childhood affects later behaviour
Psychodynamic theories -Bowlby: Maternal deprivation -
Sammons and Putwain: maternal deprivation not linked to criminality
Id
Instinctive ‘animal’ part of mind – selfish, pleasure-seeking.
Superego
Conscience or moral part of mind – acting against it leads to guilt and anxiety
Ego
Referees the urges of id and superego. Tries to satisfy the id’s urges in a socially acceptable way
Weak superego
Less guilt feelings and more likely to act on id’s urges
Harsh superego
Craves punishment to release guilt feelings
Deviant superego
Successful socialisation but into deviant moral code
Primary Carer
The main person who looks after the child.
Attachment
Describes the relationship between child and primary carer
Affectionless psychopathy
Inability to form meaningful relationships as a result of broken attachment before the age of 5
Socialisation
Process of learning norms and values
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory - Key idea
Criminality is the result of a highly neurotic and highly extroverted personality type.
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory - Personality dimensions
Extraversion vs introversions (E)Neuroticsm vs emotional stability (N) and later added psychoticism (P)
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory - Link to crime: Extraverts
Have a nervous system with a high need for stimulation so constantly seek excitement through rule-breaking and impulsive behaviour
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory - Link to crime: Neurotics
Are harder to condition into following society’s rules because high anxiety levels prevent them from learning from punishment
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory - Link to crime: Psychotics
People with high P score tend to be solitary misfits who are more likely to be criminal and may have serious mental illness e.g. schizophrenia
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory - Strength
Describes how some measurable tendencies may lead to criminality
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory - trength
Studies suggest that offenders to tend towards high E, P and N scores.
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory - Limitation: Farrington
Studies show that prisoners are not often extraverted
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory - Limitation
E measures two separate things – impulsiveness and sociability. These things don’t always correspond
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory -Limitation
Personality type and criminality are correlated, but this doesn’t prove personality types causes criminality
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory -Limitation
Convicted offenders may not be typical of offenders on the whole.
Eyesenck’s Personality Theory -Limitation
Eysenck used self-report questionnaires – people may lie making the results invalid.