Task 3.3 Flashcards
What is meant by introspection ?
- looking into our own minds and reporting what we discover there
- searching for a state of consciousness
1. It is a thought process /thinking about ones past primary conscious experiences = retrospection
2. Data comes from memory
What is the most well known tool to discover cosnciousness ?
- Introspection -> Since it is yet the best method to study consciousness
How do participants report there introspection ?(define the two types)
- Mostly informal = what ever comes up in your mind
- Formal = introspection in a systematic manner
How did introspection differ between past and current ?
- In the past it was thought that all mentall process are consciouss -> So you could report on them
- Cureently we know that some mental process are unconsciousness and some are consicious -> So not all mental procces can be reported via inrospection
What is the difference between introspection and introspective verbal report?
- introspective verbal report = is a verbal description of your conscious
experience - Introspection is = you oberving for yourself ur conscious experience
What are some major weakness regarding introspection ? (only if we accept reconstruction = intrrospection)
- recalling can lead to reconstruct prior events with filling the gaps
- we base a lot on prior beliefs
- introspection is limited via memory storage and retrieval process
- > basicall it is restricted by limitations of memory storage and retrieval processes
What are the 3 types of introspection ?
- Analytic
- Descriptive
- Interpretive
What is meant by Analytic introspection ?
- Describe experiences in terms of elementary constituents
- Those elements can be identified via introspection
- it is based on modern structualism
- Example: describing a table in 3D terms
What are some limitations regarding the analytic introspection ?
- Theoretical foundation “struturlism was exchanged by the Gestalt psychology = it is more about unified configurations rather then elemants
- unreliable (same condition = differnt reports)
- elementary bases are just to basic for complex thoughts
What is meant by descriptive phenomenal introspection?
- description of one’s conscious experience in natural language term
- What did I perceive/think/feel?
- try to report as closely as possible to the way we originally experienced them
- Usually connected to dreams
What is meant by interpretive introspection?
- intended to discover the causes of our thoughts, feelings, and actions.
- Asking yourself WHY you feel these things
- Try to identify antecedents (vorläufer) = relevant prior events and thoughts which make us think the way we do think
What are some limitations of the interpretive introspection?
- Some doubt that we know the causes of our own thoughts
What is issue between desrciptive and interpretive introspection?
- The distinction is quiet tricky
- Sometimes we can not really say if for example Love is what we feel or why we feel certain thinks
- Only way to distinluish those terms is via identifying the intentions of the particpant
What are some critiques on IVR ?
- Behaviourists: consciousness plays no role in causing people to behave the way they do -> thefore reporting them makes no sense
- Psychologist: IVR are inaccurate and unreliable
What are the major limitations of IVR ?
- Forgetting
- Reconstruction errors
- Verbal discription errors
- Distortion Through Observation
- Censorship
- Lack of Independent Verification
- Substitution of Inferences for Observations
- Experimental demands
What is meant by forgetting ?
- Based on multistore model
- You can only report memory in STM or if they have been tansferred to LTM and can be retrieved from STM
- everything which is not stored by the LTM is forgotten
Name 4 facts when verbal reports will be incomplete or inaccurate ? (regarding forgetting)
- Never attended to the event so not available in STM
- Info might be available for reporting but for some reason you don’t report it (Censorship protecting prvate information)
- Wasn’t transferred into LTM
- Cannot be retrieved from LTM
How can we assure that verbal reports are accurate ?
- Emotional attachment
- Rehersal
- Collecting the memory when still in STM
- Put awareness on the participant
- No pressure
What is meant by reconstruction errors ?
- recall is a combination of actuall recalling and partly on filling in the gaps with plausible details
- memory has a different order then actual event to create a coherent story line
- > errors done by patient
- mostly for LTM
What is meant by verbal description difficulties ?
- Conscious experiences cannot be adequately described in words or people report same stuff differently
- mostly strong emotions
How do you overcome the verbal description difficulty ?
- training to use special vocabulary !!
What is meant by Distortion through Observation ?
- when u observe someone while he knows that he will be observed his stream of memory does not reflect his every day memory stream
How to overcome the Distortion Through Observation ?
- do not give a head ups prior to the observation
- or make us of a double blind study
What is meant by a double blind study ?
- A double-blind study is one in which neither the participants nor the experimenters know who is receiving which particular treatment