subjective explanation of deviance Flashcards
what do subjective theories focus on?
-perceptions of the act (why do some people perceive certain things as deviant and some not)
-reactions to the act (people had different reactions in the past as compared to today)
-influence of power in perceptions and reactions
what are some questions we ask from a subjectivist standpoint?
who decides what is deviant? who ‘wins’ and who ‘loses’ when someone is defined as deviant?
what is an example of a subjectivist view?
during war, we don’t classify soldiers and ‘murders’
what are the two categories of subjectivist theories?
critical theory
interpretive theory / symbolic interaction theory
what is the objective - subjective continuum by howard becker?
who makes and enforces the rules?
- understand the straddling position between subjectivist and objectivist theories
what are the kinds of critical theories?
- conflict / marxist theories
- steven spitzer
- instrumental and structural marxism
- plural, cultural, and group theories - feminist theories
- power-reflective theories:
- michel foucault
what was the basic principle of the marxist theory of deviance by steven spitzer?
capitalism causes deviance
what are the characteristics of a capitalist system? (marxist)
- bourgeoisie (factory owners) and proletariat (workers)
- benefits from superfluous populations (if you own a factory, the ideal is that there are a whole lot of people who want to work for you)
_____________ labour groups are a threat to capitalism and the factory owners. what does it mean? (marxist)
superfluous: more than what is needed !!
- don’t want too many or too few superfluous people
when do problem populations deem to be in need of control? (marxist)
when they…
-steal
-unable / refuse to perform wage labor (who cares i’ll just grow my own carrots, want them to come in and work)
-use drugs for non-productive reasons (drug use is not a problem if it allows you to function and motivates you to go, such as advil, but drugs such as alcohol and marijuana)
-refuse schooling (no jobs for you, but you can go to school for this and this, but people can say no because they need money, and school takes money)
-challenge the functioning of a capitalist society (riot, protests)
capitalists are charged with ______ _______, and they make them through? (marxist)
making profits
-decreasing costs (monopoly: workers become redundant)
-increasing production (intro of technology: workers become redundant)
what is an example of a monopoly where workers become redundant? (marxist)
companies and buy the other one out:
sobeys ended up purchasing safeway to prevent competition, but this required a bunch of safeway workers to be laid off (then they become superfluous labor)
what is an example of technology where workers become redundant?
technology often results in people losing their jobs:
self-checkout and ATMs prevented the need for workers
how is labor changing as society advances? (marxist)
increasing specialization
-only someone who is directly trained with honda materials and technology can fix your car, making you have to go see them in order to get your car fixed
what is lumpenproletariat? (marxist)
the superfluous labor class has no movement and becomes permanently redundant
-increased size of this group requires more resources to control them
what is instrumental marxism?
- government is a puppet! no interest and the corporations could crush them
- our government is a mere tool of the institutions.
- state is the direct servant of ruling class
what are some examples of instrumental marxism?
- insurance companies, pharmaceutical industries, oil and gas industry all would lobby about the amount they can control about their environmental impact (win over government)
- known for forever smoking is bad for us, but why is it legal / then permitted the marketing of e-cigarettes ? tobacco corporations knew they were so big and so powerful, that they then have control over the government
what is structural marxism?
– believe government is definitely at play and also has interest
- state institutions function in the long-term interests of capitalism
- not a puppet, they too are interested, but they want to focus on how they are going to grow jobs and keep highly educated and skilled people here
what is an example of structural marxism?
pharmaceuticals want us to have interest in their medications and marketing, government then has to think about what happens if they say no and the pharmaceuticals pull out ? government realizes they lose control, lose jobs, lose smart people / scientist
what is pluralist conflict theory?
not quite just capitalism, it is sometimes between certain social groups
- indigenous canadians are much more likely to be unemployed than white native canadians