SOC200 - Conceptualization (Chapters 4+5) Flashcards
UNITS OF ANALYSIS
- what/who being studied
- Identifying can difficult
- Periodically diff betw who/what we observe to get info we need + who/what generalizing about based on info
- what characteristics interested in observing
UNITS OF ANALYSIS
•info from individuals + pooling info to find patterns
•Individuals unit of observation, but aggregates units of analysis
•Derive characteristic of social groups from those of individual members - Couples, cities, gangs, churches
Social artifacts: Concrete items – books, paintings, buildings/Social interactions – Weddings, friendship
UNITS OF ANALYSIS AND FAULTY REASONING: ECOLOGICAL FALLACY
assume observations at broader unit of analysis say something about indivs comprising unit/equally distributed to individuals in that group
Eg: Neighbourhoods with lots Protestants higher suicide rate than lots of Catholics
•couldn’t infer from aggregate level data because you don’t have individual data
•individualistic fallacy: bias, racism, prejudice
•can’t generalize characteristic of one person to whole groups
CONCEPTUALIZATION
process of agreement about what concepts mean
•Indicators & Dimensions: Sign of presence/absence of concept
•Definitions: Real, Nominal + Operational
•Conceptual Order
•If common images changes over time, then concept means something else
OPERATIONALIZATION
Specifying exact procedures involved in measuring variables represent concepts (the operational definition)
•Operationalization Choices
•Levels of Measurement
MEASUREMENT
measures use depend on operational definition + way available data collected
•Accuracy vs. Precision
•Reliability vs. Validity
•Indexes vs. Scales
CONCEPTUALIZATION: Interchangeability of Indicators
doesn’t matter if researchers disagree on specific indicators only matters if all indicators used do not behave same way in testing
CONCEPTUALIZATION: Interchangeability of Indicators
If some indicators behave differently, then possible they represent diff dimension of the concept/don’t represent that concept at all.
•Example: all indicators measure level of reckless driving, if you dropped, one you can still measure it
CONCEPTUALIZATION: Real Definitions
statement of essential nature of some entity
IMPOSSIBLE – mistakes construct for a real entity + produces vague definitions
•only exists in theory
CONCEPTUALIZATION: Nominal Definitions
arbitrary definition
based on conventions of how term commonly used everyday conceptual understanding
CONCEPTUALIZATION: Operational Definitions
specifies exactly how a concept will be measured
high clarity by limiting definition - how it is measured only means that thing
CONCEPTUALIZATION: Conceptual Order
need to refine/expand meaning, their increased understanding of the concept necessitates it
may divide up concept into diff dimensions + subdimensions
•Hermeneutic circle: cyclical process of ever deeper understanding
OPERATIONALIZATION: Range of Variation
what distance betw highest + lowest points in data
•Example from HBSC Survey: frequency distribution, maybe decide $100+
oHow much variation do you need?
OPERATIONALIZATION: Degree of Precision
degree of precision at the time of data collection will affect what you can and cannot do with the data later
you can always break it down into less precise units
•If you don’t need to know exactly how much they smoke, then put it into categories
Degree of Precision is Important
cannot collect more general data then break it down to specific later
•More precise data has more informative models
•General data limits types of models you can use
•If possible more detail, can aggreagate later
•More precise – more measurement validity
•Collapsing data is more vague, and less measurement power
LEVELS OF MEASUREMENT: Nominal Measure
Variables with attributes merely categorical, no rank, no numeric value
different from each other and have no order
Yes No
LEVELS OF MEASUREMENT: Ordinal Measure
Variables with attributes rank ordered
can’t really pin down range/distance between attributes
Never, Occasionally, Regularly, Frequently, All the time, or 0-10, 11-20, etc.
•Ordinal - percentage
LEVELS OF MEASUREMENT: Interval Measure
Variables with attributes can rank + equal distances, no true 0
IQ Score 60,70,80,90,100,110,120,130