Philosohy - Evil and Suffering Flashcards
Quote from Mackie rejecting the FWD
“…why could he not have made men such that they always freely choose the good”
The logical problem of evil
•Expressed by the inconsistent triad
Counter factual hypothesis
If God interferes , then humanity cannot develop
St Ireneaus
An early Church Father and apologist. His writings were formative in the early development of Christian theology
Platinga’s defence of the FWD
- MSR1- God cannot eliminate evil without eliminating free will
- MSR2 - God allowed evil into the world because of the original sin
What in Genesis indicates that God must create evil as well as good ?
“…I make peace, and create evil : I the Lord do all these things” (Isaiah 45:7)
Bible quotes that support predestination
“It was not that this man sinned , or his parents , but that the works of God might be mad at manifest in him “ (John 9:1-3)
Mackie quote in God making better humans
“…there was open to him the obviously better possibility of making beings who would act freely but always go right “
Weakness of Hick’s theodicy
1) Does not solve the problem of animal suffering
2) Ends do not justify the means
3) Does not solve the evidential problem of evil
4) Does not match up to Christian thinking ?
Epistemic Distance
God keeps a distance from humanity in order not to overwhelm it
Pantheism
The view that all is in God: in Process Theology , that God is in the soul of the universe, so does not transcend the universe
The Bible describing the apocalyptic war in heaven between Michael and his angels and the evil forces
“…the great dragon…that ancient serpent , who is called the Devil and Satan , the deceiver of the whole world”
Libertarianism
In the free will debate , this is the view that although some aspects of human existence are determined by biology , physics and chemistry , humans nevertheless have a degree of free will and so can be held morally responsible for their own actions
Strengths of the FWD
1) Platinga’s MSR 1+2 are logically possible
2) Logically impossible to create a world where people had free will but never made morally bad choices
3) A world with free creatures is more valuable than a world without
4) For some there is no enjoyment without risk
Free will
The idea that human beings are free to make their own choices in life
Natural evil
Problems in the natural world, which lead to tsunamis , earthquakes and famine
What would Hick say about the evils in this world ?
“I cannot imagine that I would ever conclude that the evils of life have been so treat that it would have been better if life had never emerged …”
Moral evil
The result of human action , such as murder or theft
What does Augustine say about evil?
It is a privation of good
What is Mackies’ rejection of FWD?
- It must have been logically possible for God to create the human race so everyone chose good
- God is either not omnipotent or does not exist
- The FWD is logically incoherent