nature culture readings and case studies Flashcards
botanical ontologies: author, year, aims
2016; laura rival
aim: bring appreciation and awareness to plants in human nature study
1. plant world not confused with nature
2. dismissal of plants as passive resources despite chemical awareness
sharon mcivor
canada 2019: ‘canadian indigenosu women fight for equality’
- mcIvor not recognize by state as a native due to gender discrimiation (as part of Niaka’pamux tribe in british colombia)
Indian act 1876
defines first nations members as: ‘a male indian, the wife of a mal indian, or the child of a male indian’
issues with indian act
- 4000 indigenous women in canada are missing or murdered
McIvor 1985
law change; she can pass native blood onto children but not grandchildren
- she can’t reserve land
- is exclused from thungin, fisihing and traditional marriage/funeral/healing cereomines
quote of McIvor
’ what i lost was my community, and what i lost was my ability to feel like i belonged’
interamerican commusion on human rights
2016; indian act is a factor which enables the persistence of unequal treatement and stereotyping of indigenosu women
casey 1996
for anthropologists; SPACE first, ativities of human behaviour in nature
for local; PLACE significance as speicfic remains and cultural elements retained
eva mackey 2005 aim
‘universal rights in conflict’
aim; how aboriginal and oppostents frame their land claims
- examines conflict in 3 year ethnography in ny state and western ontario
- how authority and rights are framed as universal human rights
‘claims for indigenous rights by aboridingal people dont have the same basis or meaning as non indigenous due to historical positions’
cayuga nation and their oppositino
- in NY
- opposes the ‘upstate citizens for equality’
caldwell nation and their opposition
- in canada
- opposes the ‘chatham-kent community network’
UN draft declaration on rights of indigenosu people
un convnetion 169: states have responsability of maniging, establishing and protecting rights of nature
- ‘national states seek to create national citizens’
mackeys points
- indigenous group have become the ‘other’ and outsiders as competitors for an ‘authentic nation’
; results in tensions around authority for national and local spaces - groups draw on nationalist imagery to feel empowered
- settlement/progressed imposed onto everyone despite histoical based claims
working group on indigenous people definition
1986; defines indigenous groups as:
- priority in the terriroitry and occuptation
- voluntary perpetuation of cultural distinction
- self identification and recoginition of other groups and authorities
- experiences of discrimination/dispossesion and exclusion
cayuga nation case
- in NY; want 64,000 acres recompensation
UCE: challenges this by saying ‘america is united and for all’ claim it under antional loyalty, euqality and citizenship
frame the cayuga as ‘disolayal’ as they want special/unequal status; stress ‘once culture’
e. g. helen; you cant have 596 diffferent groups in america; debates nature of america
e. g. Robert (UCE membere) ‘the cayuga were conquered’; historical authority
–> creaiton of boundaries by excluding aboriginal history and people
caldwell nation case
- ontario, canada; want CA$23.4 milllion to buy 4500 acres of land
CKCN: ‘not for sale’ anti-campaign; assert their OWN local community
e.g. ‘one cultural heritigate should not be sacrified for another’ local community seperate form first nations
CKCN: legitamizes news (sees its authoirty) by deep relationships to land; equate settler and inidgenous people rights
e.g. john (farmer); ‘blames governments as true antagonists’
use of benevolt’understanding of the other technique; reserve HOWEVER is vital for ECONOMIC health
mohawks
first nation people; excerize their right to identity
- land goverened by geopolitical states in usecanada border
this disrputes identity
old treaty: gives them free right to cross border as long as they trade with other nations
are portrayed as; traidtional (in past), illegal and smuggles
self portray; as part of first nation; refuse national american or canadian identity
melanisan women?
suckle pigs to breast; cultural taboos of west not there?
animality= assosiacaiton with bad manners
durkiheim
animal society is governed by instict
human soceity government by intention
nature is free and sponteaous
culture is boluntary
tree burials
in cree culture (westeman 2013);
deceased are returned to the earth
cree; shaminism and animsim
- pentecoastlism is causing internal conflicts;
painting of wildlife is prohibited but shaminisc acts are not
juruna and tupi people
lima 1996:
relationship between ahuminaty and animliaty as condition for their difference
categoriges of life;
- humans
- animals
- spirits
eduardo vivieros da castro
‘amerindians dont see strangers as person; personhood is aschieved my interaction’
- amerindian cosmologies in amazon and perspectival multinaturalism
humasna re humans, animal asn spirits as humns; agency in all
audra simpson; focus and date
2014: mohawk interuptus; ethnography with ‘richard’ mohwak members of the Kahnawa:ke
kahnawa:ke
history: different natives were dumped together (primary mohawk; refugee community) in Mohawk valley NY/some moved to south montreal
- have a ‘vanishin past’ and problems in determining ‘membership
kin vs family vs land as spatial deminsion to claim cultural identity
‘are in and out of place’
- claim identity and personhood to historical and cultural PLACE; mistrust of Kahwanwa:ke to Quebec and others
- MEMORIES; structured day to day realtionships and social lifes; historical members and histotlity to foreigns
Irroqouis democracy; life in a community a political process
mohawk law on membership
1954:
- is tradittionally matrillineal (mothers blood) or of 4 mohwak great grandparents
- qomen are primary caregivers; teach child traditiosn and advise men politically
- political vs identity in membersip; MIXING as a ‘cultural loss’; also linked to LANDless (membership vs nationhood vs identity therefore)
indian act effect
- changed matrinlineal membership to patrinliean
- women lost status in exogamic marriage
- tensions between white men and women
- race/sex determine membership
- race consciousness on sex; defining kinship and communtiy relations difficulty
effect of st lawrence sea canal in 1957
- candian national waterway; aimed to be constructed on Kahnawwake land
- they are annoed; see it as a destruction of HISTORICAL memory; attachmenet of fishing, site of ememory, swimming; self perception by state perception