Moral development Flashcards
Freudian theory
according to Freud, boys have unconscious wishes to compete with the father for mother’s love which leads to castration anxiety . The anxiety leads to repression of such desire and leads to identification with one’s father from whom the superego morality is incorporated
-thus moral development is achieved via the development of the superego
Piaget
- moral development is 2 years behind cognitive development
- older children have social perspective, younger children do not
- roughly split into 5-9 years and older than 10 years
Piaget moral development- 5-9 years
- unilateral respect for external law
- external responsibility holds for crime- severity of outcome or loss decides the degree of punishment warranted
- moral realism- strong penalty should be paid for any crime
- imminent justice: World is just- misfortune will punish the deserved for a misdeed
- heteronomous morality- subject to rules written by others
Unilateral respect for the external law
- 5-9 years old
- seniors make rules; they are sacred and should not be broken but get violated periodically for pleasure
- Piaget
External responsibility holds for crime
- 5-9 years old
- severity of outcome or loss decides the degree of punishment warranted
- Piaget
Moral realism
- 5-9 years old
- strong penalty should be paid for any crime
- can accept collective punishment to deliver justice (punishing the wrongdoer is more important than not hurting the innocent)
- Piaget
Imminent justice
- 5-9 years old
- the world is just
- misfortune will punish the deserved for a misdeed#-Piaget
Heteronomous morality
- 5-9 years old
- subject to rules written by others
- Piaget
Piaget’s moral development -older than 10 years
- mutual respect for self-invented law
- internal responsibility holds for crime; the intent or motivation decides the degree of punishment warranted
- moral relativism: punishment should match the crime, does not accept collective punishment
- no imminent justice
- autonomous morality; rules can be self made
Mutual respect for self-invented law
- 10 years +
- self invented laws can be changed by consensus and for fairness
- Piaget
Internal responsibility holds for crime
- 10 years +
- intent or motivation decides the degree of punishment warranted
- Piaget
Moral relativism
- 10 years +
- punishment should match the crime
- does not accept collective punishment
- Piaget
Autonomous morality
- 10 years +
- rules can be self-made
- Piaget
Kohlberg’s theory of moral development
-stagewise process wheere reasons for making a jusgement in a hypothetical experiment (Heinz Dilemma( are studied in children; reasons are more important than the actual judgement made
-on this basis Kohlberg identified 3 levels and 6 stages
Level 1: Pre-conventional morality
Level 2 Conventional morality
Level 3 Post conventional morality
Level 1 Pre-conventional morality
- Kohlberg
- 7-12 years to middle childhood
- in this stage the child must decide on what is right or wrong according to consequences
- if action leads to punishment then it must be bad and if it leads to reward it must be good
1. Punishment and obedience orientation: obedience to rules to avoid punishment
2. Reward orientation/instrumental relativism: what brings rewards is right- ‘tit for tat’ approach seen