MODULE 10 Flashcards
is the extent to which the measurements used, often questionnaires, actually test the hypothesis or theory they are measuring.
Construct Validity
Threats to construct validity
- reactivity to the study situation
- researcher expectancies
- Noveity effects
- Compensatory effects
- Treatment diffusion or contamination
When people’s responses reflect, in part, their perceptions become part of the treatment construct under study There are several ways to reduce this problem, including blinding, using outcome measures not susceptible to reactivity (e.g. data from hospital records) and using pre-intervention strategies to satisfy participants’ desire to look competent or please the researcher.
Reactivity to the study situation
A similar threat stems from the researcher’s influence on participant responses through subtle (or not so-subtle) communication about desired outcomes. When this happens, the researcher’s expectations become part of the treatment (or nonmanipulated independent variable) construct that is being tested. Blinding is a strategy to reduce this threat, but strategy is to use observations during course of the study to detect verbal or behavioral signs or expectations
Researcher expectancies
When a treatment is new, participants and research agents alike might aller their behavior. People may be either enthusiastic or skeptical about new methods of doing things. Results may reflect reactions to the novelty rather than
to the intrinsic nature of an intervention, so the intervention construct is clouded by ____
Novelty effects
In intervention studies, _______ can occur if health care staff or family members try to compensate for the control group members’ failure to receive a perceived beneficial treatment. The compensatory goods or services must then be part of the construct description of the treatment conditions
compensatory equalization
is a related threat arising from the control group members’ desire to demonstrate that they can do as well as those receiving a special treatment.
Compensatory rivalry
Sometimes alternative treatment conditions can get blurred, which can impede good construct descriptions of the independents variable. This may occur when participants in a control group condition receive services similar to those available in the treatment condition.
Treatment diffusion or contamination
Threats to Statistical Conclusion Validity
Low statistical power
Restriction of range
Unreliable implementation of a treatment
are used to support inferences about whether relationships exist
Statistical Methods
refers to the ability to detect true relationships among variables. Adequate _____ can be achieved by using a sufficiently large sample. When small samples are used, statistical power tends to be low, and the analysis may fail to show that the independent and dependent variables are related, even when they are.
Statistical power
Another aspect of statistical power is _____. This is achieved through accurate measuring tools, controls over confounding variables, and powerful statistical methods.
precision
relationship between key research variables, it can be risky. Not only does this approach limit the generalizability of study findings, but it can also sometimes undermine statistical conclusion validity. When the use of homogeneity restricts the range of values on the outcome variable, relationship between the outcome and the independent variable will be attenuated, and may, therefore, lead to an erroneous inference that the variables are unrelated.
Restriction of Range
When the use of homogeneity restricts the range of values on the outcome variable, relationship between the outcome and the independent variable will be ______, and may, therefore, lead to an erroneous inference that the variables are unrelated.
attenuated
concerns the extent to which the implementation of an intervention is faithful to its plan. Interventions can be weakened by various factors, which researchers can often influence. One issue concerns the extent to which the intervention is similar from one person to the next. Usually, researchers strive for constancy of conditions in implementing a treatment because lack of standardization adds extraneous variation and can diminish the intervention’s full force.
Intervention fidelity, (or treatment fidelity)