lecture 5 social influence Flashcards
define social influence
allport 1954
effortfull manipulation and change of attitude/beliefs and values due to the actual or implied presence of others
define conformity
change in behaviour/attitude/values due to real or imagined pressure from others/members of group
based on the subjective validity of social norms
ie descriptive - what people do, or injunctive - what should be done
define compliance
change in response to implied or explicit request
- difficult to know when compliant beh reflects internalisation
define coercive compliance
superficial public and transitory change in behaviour and expressed attitude that is not internalized
define obedience
change in response to order from percieved authority figure
define norms
explicit or implicit rules that define a group membership and regulates the behaviour of its members
can be descriptive ie what most do
or injunctive ie what must be done
deutsch and gerard informational influence
ambiguous situation - unsure of how to respond then look to others based on the belief that others are better informed and will know how to act appropriately
deutsch and gerard normative influence
conform so as to avoid punishment or to receive rewards - even if dont believe correct to conform
asch 1956 normative influence study
conformity reflects a rational process of constructing a norm from others beh
given visual perception test - which line is longer A B or C
75% give incorrect answer at least once when confederate also give wrong answer - knew correct but purposefully gave wrong (norm)
33% average conformity and expected to be higher amongst salient groups
asch 1956 when do people conform
group size
unamity
individual diferences
sex/gender influence on conformity
eagly 1978
often use tasks unfamiliar to woman so more likely to conform ie woman dont know how to do the task and therefore follow mens lead and conform more - occurs vise versa in men
cultural norms on conformity
bond and smith 1996
meta of asch paradigm across countries
collectivist countries ie norway have high score on hofstede (1980) collectivism scale than individualist countries ie france
USA - decline since 50s
what determines perception of an authority figure
coercive - can punish or remove good reward - provide good or take away bad expert - provide knowledge not widely available legitimate - influencial social role referent - want to identify/be like
reducing obedience
milgram exp
- increase distance from authority
-increase no of disobredient peers
visualise learner in pain
minority influence
moscovici 1980
social psych conformity bias - focus on minority conformity to majority
majority influence exerts compliance - publically accept but not private in motivation to not appear deviant
a viewpoint that is consistent overtime can lead to conversion towards the attitude, that is more cognitive and privately accepted - rigid
types of social influence
conformity
compliance
obedience
deutsch and gerard rational normative influence
dual process dependency
influenced by others because they are dependent on them for info to remove ambiguity or for approval/acceptance
but also for ‘group belongingness’ - pressure to conform to group when define self as member
asch 1956 reasons for conformity
experience initial uncertainty and self doub
evolve to self consciousness- fear of disaproval, anxiety and lonliness
most respond because did not want to stand out
asch group size and conformity
low conformity when 1-2 confederates but high when 3-5 and plateau if larger
size may alter dependent on the judgement and motivation of the individual - when no objective right answer then more likely to want to fit in and conform
group unanimity and conformity
allen 1975
when majority unanimous - conformity 33%
BUT sig reduce when not unanimous
1 member of majority agree with naive participant then conformity reduce to 5.5%