lecture 1 - garlands culture of control Flashcards
when was penal welfarism most prominent?
early 1800s to 1970s
what are they key themes in garlands chapter ‘a history of the present’?
- penal welfarism
- transformation to a ‘culture of control’
key themes in penal welfarism (1800s to 1970s)?
- rehabilitation of offenders the core principle of penal system
- political consensus
- the role of penal experts
what underpinned penal welfarism?
- low crime rates
- community cohesion
- full employment
what was the role of penal experts in penal welfarism instead of? 1800s-1970s
the role of penal experts rather than politicians of the public
key themes in the transformation to a ‘culture of control’?
- high levels of crime and insecurity
- loss of faith in penal experts and rehabilitation
- a policy predicament
- paradoxical/ contrasting responses of populism and managerialism
what underpinned the transformation to a culture of control?
- all underpinned by a shift in deeper social/ economic structures and cultural sensibilities about crime and punishment
- high crime rates
- community breakdown
- individualism
- unemployment
- inequality
when was the era of penal welfarism?
1945-1970
what were the key characteristiccs of the era of penal welfarism?
- the rehabilitative ideal as core principle of the penal system
- faith in criminal justice experts
- limited influence for politicians and public opinion on penal policy
- political consensus on crime and punishment
- general belief in the efficacy of state crime control
what are the 3 foundational conditions of penal welfarism?
- political-economic conditions
- social conditions
- theoretical conditions (dominant ways of thinking about crime)
what are the political-economic conditions of penal welfarism?
- welfare-capitalism
- economic management and social policy to attack major problems of inequality (poverty, bad health, poor education, poor housing etc)
what is welfare capitalism?
is a business favoured policy that believes the private sector can provide social welfare programs more effectively than the federal government
social conditions for penal welfarism?
-stable/ falling crime rates
- full employment
- stable family structures
- cohesive communities
- informal social controls
what are the theoretical conditions for penal welfarism?
- positivist theories of crime causation
e.g. - strain theory
- social disorganisation theory
- psychological theories
what is garlands first indices of change?
the decline of the rehabilitative ideal
what is g second indices of change?
the re-emmergence of punitive sanctions and expressive justice
what is g third indices of change?
changes in the emotional tone of crime policy