Juries Flashcards
torts
civil cases claims of harm
civil vs criminal juries
criminal - 12 ppl
civil - 6-8, unanimous decision not needed
types of offenses in canada
- summary offenses
- >6 months in prison and fine >$2000
- max 18 months
- tried by judge alone - no right to jury - indictable offenses
a. less serious… theft, obtaining $/property under false pretenses, failure to comply with probation order
- Judge
b. highly serious -treason, murder, piracy
- judge and jury unless both attorney general and accused agree can be judge alone
c. arson, sexual assault with a weapon, etc.
- tried by provincial judge without jury and preliminary inquiry
- preliminary inquiry and judge only
- preliminary inquiry and judge and jury - hybrid offenses
- crown choices if summary offense or indictable (max 5 years)
Juries act
Provincial and territorial legislation that outlines the eligibility criteria for jury service and how prospective jurors must be selected
- no criminal record, lawyers/ judges, BC used to be no dentists
Jury summons
court order stating time and location for jury duty
Potential juror challenges
peremptory
- crown or defense 12 each (20 for murder)
- do not need to provide reason for rejection
- now banned in Canada
For Cause
- lawyer must give reason
R v. Sherratt
jury characteristics
- representativeness
- represents community where committed crime
- r v. Nepoose - Impartiality
- unbiased
- ignore non admissible evidence like media etc
- R. v. Guess
R v. Nepoose
defendant was woman and aboriginal and not enough women on jury = representativeness
R v. Guess
one of 12 jurors and defendant started sexual relationship- charged with obstruction of justice = impartiality
Improve impartiality
threats from pre- trial publicity (more negative = more guilty verdicts and vice versa)
- media ban
- change of venue (same province) ex Andrew Berry trial
- adjournment - delay till sometime in future - risks witness memory and jorden legislature - timeline
- challenge for cause
Aboriginal jurors
under represented
if living on reserves not part of municipal assessment lists of potential jurors in Ontario
- increase by using heath record databases, and allowing them to volunteer
R v. Brown
racially biased jury with 2 white defendants raping aboriginal girl
- all white jury = not guilty
R v. Find
judge rejected proposal for challenge for cause
R v. Davey
jury panel released early and both crown and defense asked police officers opinions
- no requirement for info from police to be disclosed
- early jury panel release list had no impact on fairness
- privacy of prospective jurors not breached
- no change in jury had the comments been disclosed
Andrew Berry
change of venue from small town after murdering his children