Forensics Flashcards
What is smallest space analysis?
Stats technique by Canter - how likely features of crimes are to exist with another feature at a certain crime scene.
Scientific.
What is the top down approach?
Start with established typology (from interviews with 36 sexually motived serial killers). Assign to category - organised/not.
US approach - data assimilation, crime reconstruction.
What is the difference between an organised and disorganised criminal?
Organised: preplanned, body moved/posed, trophies, higher IQ, socially competent
Disorganised: messy, left evidence, impulsive, lower IQ, drugs/alcohol sometimes
What are evaluation points for the top down approach?
- some less successful
- less systematic
- self report of criminals
- ecological validity
- real life applications
- nomothetic
- Holmes: FBI data, profile only helps 17% of cases
What is the bottom up approach?
Investigative psychology - patterns across crime scenes. Interpersonal coherence, sig. of time and place, forensic awareness.
By Canter - quantitative data and 3 themes:
1. instrumental opportunism
2. instrumental cognitive
3. expressive compulsive
What are evaluation points for the bottom up approach?
- only with caught criminals
- generalisable
- no longitudinal studies
- little consistency
- low validity
- individual differences of crimes
What is geographical profiling?
Make inferences from location and timing of crimes. Circle theory - will contain base. Canter + Larkin.
What are the 2 types of geographical profiles?
Marauder - close to base
Commuter - travel away from base
eg. Suffolk strangler - Canter created v accurate profile.
What are studies relating to geographical profiling?
Copson - in survey, 75% of UK police found profiles useful but 3% actually found criminal.
Fox and Farrington - new trends in categorisation and increasing accuracy.
What is the atavistic form?
Sees criminals as having primitive features. Lombroso in 1870s.
eg. heavy brow, strong jaw, big ears.
Not to blame for actions as behaviour determined by physiology. Based 4000 criminals and skulls of 400 dead ones.
What is the genetic explanation for crime?
Inherit gene/combo - predispose to crime. No study with 100% concordance, so not the only influence.
What effect does the MAOA gene and serotonin have on criminality?
MAOA associated with aggressive behaviour. People 13x more likely to have violent history. Mitigating factors?
Serotonin inhibiting amygdala activity - aggression.
What does the diathesis stress model say about criminality?
Can be predisposed but moderated by environment. Brunner said genetic transmission of abnormal chromosome –> neural influence.
What is the neural explanation for crime?
Noradrenaline - extreme levels liked with violence. Serotonin - low levels + impulse aggression, dopamine hyperactivity can increase effects.
Raine meta analysis of 71 studies with murderers etc. Decreased functioning in prefrontal cortex.
What are evaluation points of biological explanations?
- not all crime types are violent
- correlational
- biological determinism
- reductionism
- daily application
- no causality
- not predictive
How are mirror neurones and head injuries relevant?
60% of US prison population had a head injury.
Mirror neurones allow for empathy, so criminals with APD experience it more sporadically - only activated when asked.
What is Eysenck’s theory?
EPI questionnaire measured personality types. Criminals high in:
Psychoticism
Extraversion
Neuroticism
Assessed over 2070 male prisoners and a control group - prisoners had higher PEN scores.