Chapter 12: Problem Solving Flashcards
Problem-solving
a cognitive process that involves recognizing there is a problem, analyzing it, and solving it, then verifying the effectiveness of the solution
problem
occurs when there is an obstacle between an initial state and a goal state where you do not know the solution right away
size of problems
Problems can be small or large
what type of processing is involved in problem-solving?
involves taking bottom-up and top-down information into account
what kind of process is problem-solving?
a cyclical, recursive, and applicable process
recursive
its steps are repeated as many times as necessary
cyclical
once you arrive at a solution, you discover a new or similar problem and have to use information gained in the past to work on a solution for the next problem
problem-solving cycle
- Define the problem
- Brainstorm solutions
- Pick a solution
- Implement solution
- Review the results
initial state
the initial situation or starting point of a problem
goal state
the desired final state or ending situation
problem space theory
states that problem-solving is a search with problem space, which includes an initial state, a goal state, and intermediate states, which one moves through using operators
who developed problem space theory?
Newell & Simon, 1972
intermediate states
all the possible states in between each step in moving from an initial state to a goal state
operators
actions that transform the current problem state into another problem state
two types of problems
well-defined & ill-defined
well-defined problems
have correct answers and certain procedures that lead us to solve them
example of a well-defined problem
math problem
algorithms
a step-by-step procedure that should always produce a correct solution
what types of problems are easily solvable by algorithms?
well-defined problems
ill-defined problems
a problem that does not have clear goal states, solutions paths, or expected solutions
can ill-defined problems be solved by computers?
Computers don’t solve these problems very well because they don’t have a clear correct answer
Thorndike on problem-solving
problem-solving is a reproductive process
Thorndike was a ___
behaviourist
reproductive process
involves solving a problem by using knowledge from previous experiences and a trial-and-error strategy
trial-and-error
an approach to problem-solving that involves trying many different solutions and ruling out those that don’t work
The law of effect
states that of several responses made to the same situation, those that are accompanied or closely followed by satisfaction are more firmly connected with the situation, while those that are accompanied or closely followed by discomfort are weakened
Thorndike, 1911 trial-and-error experiment
with each trial, cats were able to escape a box faster, demonstrating their ability to learn through trial-and-error
Gestalt psychologists on behaviourism
Criticized behaviourists for their rigid approach to problem-solving that doesn’t account for phenomena like insight
insight
the phenomenon where the solution to a problem suddenly comes into consciousness
Wertheimer, 1959 on problem-solving
viewed problem-solving as a productive process
Wertheimer was a ____
gestalt psychologist
Productive process
the process of problem-solving that occurs when thinking is characterized by the restructuring of information in such a way as to provide a solution.
what type of process accounts for insight
productive process
restructuring
the process of actively manipulating information to change its representation in your mind
heuristics
Mental shortcuts for drawing inferences based on limited information without slow deliberation
The likelihood of using heuristics increases when:
- One is faced with too much information
- The time to make a decision is limited
- The decision to be made is unimportant
- There is access to very little information to use in making the decision
- An appropriate heuristic happens to come to mind at the moment
working backwards
a heuristic in which you begin the problem by focusing on the end result
means-end analysis
a heuristic in which you create sub-goals as you move closer to your final goal state. Includes forward and backward movements and constantly evaluating the difference between current and goal states
what heuristic is often involved in AI?
means-end analysis
2 barriers to solving problem
- Being unable to ignore irrelevant information
- Functional fixedness
the ability to filter out irrelevant information throughout life
Ignoring irrelevant information develops in children and declines with old age
when is filtering out irrelevant information most difficult?
when you are dealing with an ill-defined problem
functional fiixedness
the tendency to view objects for their intended purposes because of prior experience with that object
fixations
a specific characteristic of a problem
insight problem
a problem in which the solution occurs suddenly into your consciousness
non-insight problem
a problem distinguished by the process of consciously working through each step of a problem to arrive at a solution
Metcalfe and Wiebem 1987 predictions and insight vs. non-insight problems
gave participants either an insight problem or a non-insight problem. Found that while solving non-insight problems, participants were able to predict with some accuracy how close they were to solving the problem, but those solving the insight problem were very poor at estimating how close they were
the two-string problem
provided participants with useful and useless hints to solve a two-string problem. Some of the participants who correctly solved the problems mentioned the useless cues as helping them, demonstrating the lack of consciousness in the nature of insight
divergent thinking
a thought process that can generate many solutions to a problem to determine one that works well enough to solve the problem