Attachment Flashcards
What were Schaffers stages of attachment
- Asocial
- Indiscrimate
- Specific
- Multiple
What happens in the Asocial stage of attachment?
behaviour is the same towards humans and objects with a slight preference towards humans
What happens in the Indiscriminate attachment stage?
Babies prefer humans to objects and show no stranger anxiety so can be comforted by anyone
What happens in the specific attachment stage?
Attachment is formed to primary caregiver, infant shows stranger and seperation anxiety
What happens in the multiple attachment stage?
29% of children developed a secondary attachment within one month of primary attachment, usually towards father
What are the issues with Schaffers stage of attachment?
Limited, simple characteristics
Problems studying asocial stage
Conflicting evidence on multiple attachment
Measuring multiple attachments
What are the strengths of Schaffers stages of attachment?
HIgh external validity
Longitudinal design
What was the method used for Schaffers stages of attachment?
60 babies
skilled working class families in Glasgow
Visited every month for the first year and again at 18 months
What were Schaffers findings?
25-32 weeks - 50% of babies showed separation anxiety towards primary caregiver
40 weeks - 80% specific attachment, 30% - multiple attachments
What did Lorenze theorise?
all organisms have a biological predisposition to form an attachment to one single object
What did Lorenz do?
Hatched Goslings either with mother or in an incubator
They proceeded to follow the first moving object they saw within 13-16 hours of hatching
What did Harlow emphasise?
The importance of contact comfort as newborn monkeys kept alone in a cage would usually die but would survive if given something like a cloth
What was the procedure Harlow followed?
Findings?
16 baby monkeys with 2 wire model mother, one of which was covered in cloth, milk dispensed by both
Preference for cloth-covered model and seeked for comfort when frightened
Critocal period - 90 days
What are the issues with Lorenz study?
lack of generalisability to humans
Counter evidence
What are the strengths of Harlows study on rhesus monkeys?
Theoretical value
- the importance of early relationships
Practical Value
- social workers understand risk factors in child neglect
- breeding programmes
What is Learning Therory of attachment?
Cupboard - Love - caregiver as a provider of fod and baby learns to love whoever feeds them?
What are the primary and secondary drives of cupboard-love theory?
Primary - need to satisfy hunder
Secondary - attachment to caregiver who feeds them
What is Bowlby’s monotropic theory?
infants require a qualitatively unique relationship to develop an internal working model
What is the internal working model?
Mental representation of our relationship with our primary caregiver which acts as a template for all other relationships - continuity hypotheses
What is the critical period?
A primary attachment must be made between 6 months - 2.5 years, otherwise an attachment will never be made and the child will suffer behavioural and emotional problems
What is the cross cultural support for Bowlbys monotropic theory?
Ganda tribe - one primary attachment, even when reared by multiple caregivers
Israeli Communal Farms - children raised by nurses (metaplets), spent 3 hours a day with parents. primary attachment was still towards biological mum
How how is the importance of a primary attachment over-emphasised?
uniqueness vs strength?
Thomas - a network of attachments may be more beneficial
Van Iijzendoon - a stable network of adults provides better care
What supporting research is there for the internal working model?
the continuity hypotheses suggests that internal working models should be passed through generations
Bailey
- 99 mothers with 1 year olds
- standard interview mother-grandmother
- observation mother-infant
results showed attachment type was generational
4 criteria for Ainsworths SS
separation anxiety
stranger anxiety
reunion behaviour
willingness to explore room
Ainsworth SS method
lab experiment
set routine
time sampling
100 middle class american women & their infants
Ainsworth SS findings
70% secure
15% insecure-avoidant
15% insecure-resistant
How is the SS replicable?
high inter-observer reliability
highly operationalised
4 specific criteria
What is the supporting research to show reliability of classification for Ainsworths SS?
Waters
50 infants 12, 18 months
Greatest consistency in reunion behaviour
48/50 in same category at 18 months
what are the issues of Ainsworths SS?
Low population validity
Categories not always applicable
Low internal validity
- objectivity
- quality of attachment rather than child
Secure attachment
comfortable with social interaction and intimacy
healthy cognitive and emotional development
mother consistently sensitive and responds to babies needs
Insecure-resistant
both seek and reject emotional intimacy
parents are inconsistent
What is Bowlbys theory of maternal deprivation?
if a primary attachment is not formed within the critical period, one will never be formed and the child will be at risk for behavioural and emotional disorders
Separation anxiety behaviours
Protest
Despair
Detachment
Affectionless Psychopathy
an individual with no sense of shame or guilt
44 thieves method
88 children referred to a guidance clinic
44 were thieves - 16 of which deemed affectionless psychopaths
other 44 - control group
Children and families interviewd to create a record of early childhood experiences
Quasi experiment
44 thieves findings
86% of affectionless psychopaths Experienced prolonged separation
17% of the other thieves had experienced such separation
4% of control group experienced frequent early separation
What are the issues with the interviews used in 44 thieves?
Self-report - social desirability bias
Retrospective data
How was there researcher bias in the 44 thieves study?
Bowlby worked in the childrens home and knew who was in each group
Conducted psychiatric experiments himself, created the affectionless psychopathy diagnosis
44 thieves - privation vs deprivation
children moved around a lot and may have been suffering privation rather than deprivation