14. CP Flashcards

1
Q

What does JCT stand for? What are the basic principles of JCT?

A

Joint Contracts Tribunal

Used in the UK building sector.
It’s contracts help facilitate the responsibilities and obligations of parties, to mitigate risks.
It has 3 main contracts (Traditional, D&B, Minor Works Contract).

It has 8 contact options, e.g. lump sum, measurement, cost reimbursement, management (similar to NEC), although usually lump sum.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Differences between NEC and JCT?

A
  • NEC major civils, JCT UK building sector.
  • JCT has variations. NEC has CEs.
  • JCT is QS / CA. NEC is PM.
  • JCT is most commonly used as a lump sum contract, either with or without quantities. The NEC goes further with 6 pricing options, e.g. These include target cost & cost reimbursable.
  • NEC written in laymen/simple terms that is easy to understand. NEC also tries to be more collaborative ‘Mutual trust and understanding’.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

JCT Change Notes. Differences to NEC?

A
  • Variation (D&B it’s called change).
  • CA issues instructions.
  • No timeframes for responding etc.
  • JCT allows instructions to be issued verbally as long as a Confirmation of Verbal Instruction) in writing is done after.
  • Time and money dealt separately.
  • Subcontractor gets paid for time taken to do the quotation.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

What does FIDIC stand for? What are the basic principles of FIDIC?

A

International Federation of Consulting Engineers (commonly known as FIDIC, acronym for its French name)

Used overseas.
Was aimed at the Civil Engineering sector.
It has different coloured books, each allocating responsibility/risk.
- Red book (Traditional) - majority of the design is with the Employer.
- Yellow book (D&B) - majority of the design is with the Contractor.
- Silver - majority of the design is with the Contractor. Also significant risks on the Contractor.
- Gold (D&B & Operate).
- Green (Short)
It also has 5 golden principles that must be observed. e.g. Amendments must be clear and unambiguous.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

FIDIC change notes. Differences to NEC?

A
  • Variation.
  • CA or Engineer issues instructions.
  • No timeframes for responding etc.
  • Little guidance on instructing a variation, other than in it must be in writing, some forms e.g. Red Book accept an informal email.
  • Contractor cannot notify a variation under some books, e.g. Red Book.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What differences / change differences are there in the NEC compared to JCT/FIDIC that make the NEC contract so unique?

A

Generally, written in laymen terms and looks for greater collaboration between parties.

The NEC change process is good because it sets timeframes for change to be agreed upfront before the work has been carried out. This provides clarity for parties.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

What is a contract?

A

A legally binding agreement between parties.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What are the key elements required to make a binding contract?

A

Offer
Acceptance
Consideration
Intent to create legal relations
Capacity

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

In terms of contract execution, what is the difference between an under hand contract and a deed?

A

Under hand - contract that is executed by 1 person who is authorised by the company’s directors.

Deed - contract that must be signed by 2 directors registered by Companies House.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

What is a letter of intent?

A

Letter outlining intention to enter into contract.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

What are delay damages?

A

Costs payable to the Client for late completion of the project. They are stated in the contract and are a.k.a liquidated damages.

X7 = delay damages.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Define express terms.

Define implied terms.

A

Express terms: are clauses that are expressly agreed/stated by the parties.

Implied terms: terms not agreed upon by both parties in a contract, but are still legally binding.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What is the HGCRA? What is it also known as?

A

Housing Grants Construction and Regeneration Act.

Also known as the Construction Act 1996.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Talk about the HGCRA and it’s aim.

A

Payment & Adjudication: It relates to payment provisions and the process for determining a dispute by way of adjudication.

HGCRA is intended to ensure that payments are made fairly and promptly throughout the supply chain. Projects over 45 days must have periodic interim payments.

It also aims to ensure disputes are resolved swiftly by way of adjudication.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What happens if the payment / adjudication requirements in a contract didn’t comply with the HGCRA (Construction Act)?

A

Disputes can arise because of this.

The Scheme for Construction Contracts Regulations 1998 states that where a construction contract does not comply with certain sections of the Construction Act, the provisions in Part I & Part II of the Schedule to these Regulations shall apply.

Part I = Adjudication
Part II = Payment

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Give examples of different contract documentation.

A

Specifications, drawings, WI, BOQ.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

What are the NEC payment options?

A

A to F

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

What is a BOQ?

A

Bill of Quantities.

List of items with detailed descriptions, and quantities of the work.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Talk about pay less notices.

A

The HGCRA requires a pay less notice to be made if the previously agreed payment isn’t going to be paid.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

What is the privity of contract rule?

A

Law that states only the 2 parties of a contract have the right to sue or be sued.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

What do you know about the Contract (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999?

A

The privity of contract rule stated that only the parties in the contract could enforce terms, however the Contract Act 1999 changed this. It enabled third parties to enforce terms in contracts.

It is stated in the NEC contract under Y3.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

What are collateral warranties?

A

They create a contract between the main parties of a contract with an external third party! e.g. UKPN.

The contract would not otherwise exist with the third party due to privity of contract (only the parties who signed).

They are to provide remedies for interested third parties.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

What is W1 and W2 in the NEC contract?

A

Dispute Resolution

Option W1 - for use on projects that are NOT subject to the HGCRA 1996 (Construction Act 1996)

Option W2 - for use on projects where the parties ARE subject to the HGCRA.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

Explain choosing the X6 clause over the X20 clause.

A

Both are incentivisation secondary clauses.

The difference being X20 details are contained in an appendix to the Subcontract Data Part 1. You’d therefore have to cross check CONTRACT MAIN TERMS, SUBCONTRACT DATA & THE APPENDIX in the administration of that clause. X6 kept that incentivisation in the main/core clauses/contract.

The benefit is that this should be easier to administer.

25
Q

What are the X4, X6, X13 & X20 secondary clauses?

A

X4 Parent Company Guarantee (PCG)
X6 Bonus for early Completion
X13 Performance bond
X20 KPIs

26
Q

‘We also had no Key Dates so X6 was a more straightforward means of introducing an incentive against Completion.’ Why is this?

A

There were no KDs in the package itself. The most important thing was the completion of it. X20 tracks performance throughout the package as a KPI, but this wasn’t too necessary. The package just needed to be complete by a date and therefore X6 Bonus for early Completion sufficed.

27
Q

What is retention?

A

The practice of withholding a part of the money owed to a contractor or subcontractor until the project is substantially completed.

The retention is usually a percentage of the construction value, usually around 3-5%, but can be a fixed sum.

28
Q

Differences between NEC3 & NEC4?

A

NEC4 looked to improve clarity and ease of administration.

NEC4 has better clarity in guidance and language. e.g. WI now scope. Employer now client.
NEC4 states a ‘dividing date’ for actual cost and forecast cost.
NEC4 has more contract types available e.g. D&B&Operate.
NEC4 adds 2 secondary X clauses:
- X21 WLC - relates to sustainability competency
- X22 ECI (for Options C & E)

29
Q

Name some contractual provisions in the NEC contract.

A

Insurances, bonds, payments.

30
Q

Difference between Completion Date and planned completion?

A

Planned Completion = when you plan to finish

Completion Date = the date in Contract Data part 1, or the date changed as a result of implemented CEs. Only when a CE is implemented does the Completion Date move.

They are different bullet requirements under clause 31.2, so by default must be different things.

31
Q

How is the NEC form of contract typically structured?

A

Core clauses (9 sections, which are the same in every form)
Main options (A-F)
Dispute Resolution (W1 or W2)
Secondary options (X & Y clauses)
Additional clauses (Z)
Contract Data Parts 1 and 2

32
Q

Name the core clauses.

A

1 – General
16 – Early Warnings
2 – Sub/Contractor’s main responsibilities
3 – Time
4 – Testing & Defects
5 – Payment
6 – Compensation events
7 – Title
8 - Risks & Insurance
9 - Termination

33
Q

What is Completion?

A

Completion is when the Subcontractor has:

done all the work which the Subcontract Works Information states he is to do by the Subcontract Completion Date

and corrected notified Defects

34
Q

How have you assessed CEs? What is the difference between ‘actual’ and ‘forecast’ defined cost?

A

Clause 63

Clause 63.1 states actual Defined Cost of the work already done, and forecast Defined Cost of the work not yet done.

There is a dividing date, which is now used in NEC4, which is the date the Project Manager gives an instruction to change the Scope.

Extra notes & example… the majority of CEs will be based upon forecast Defined Cost. This protects the Client when they believe the Contractor may have gone a lot slower than they needed to do. If the client/PM believes a reasonable forecast was six days and the Contractor took ten days, the client/PM could still assess it based on six days.

35
Q

How have you issued instructions?

A

Cl 14 - The Contractor my give an instruction changing the WI.

36
Q

You mention ‘change must be issued and managed in line with the contract’. What do you mean by this?
/
Explain the change process.

A

14.3 The Contractor may give an instruction to the Subcontractor which changes
the Subcontract Works Information.

60.1 What CEs are. ‘‘The Contractor gives an instruction changing the Subcontract WI’’, so making sure I issue the instruction, and follow the steps through to Clause 65 where I implement the CE.
61 Notifying CEs, PM’s response.
62 Quotations.
63 Assessing CEs.
64 PM’s assessment.
65 Implementing CEs (also changes the Completion Date, which was previously only shown as planned completion on the programme).

37
Q

Can you give examples of what can be a CE?

A

60.1

Contractor gives an instruction changing the WI.
Contractor instructs to stop or not start.
Site access issues.
Encounters physical conditions, e.g. not in the GBR.
Force majeure (unforeseen event e.g. COVID or War).

38
Q

Talk about Clause 3/30.

A

Clause 31 – The programme

(If a programme is not identified in the Subcontract Data, the Subcontractor submits a first programme to the Contractor for acceptance, within the period stated in the Subcontract Data)

Clause 32 – Revising the programme

Clause 34 - Instructions to stop or not to start work

39
Q

Talk about Clause 16.

A

16.1 - Notification of EWN
16.2 & 16.3 - RRM
16.4 - EWN Register
16.6 - states the WI may include the need for a risk register.

40
Q

What NEC clauses relate to risk reduction meetings?

A

16.2 & 16.3

41
Q

What is a letter of intent? What’s the advantage of it?

A

Letter outlining intention to enter into contract.

Allows work to commence before the contract is finally agreed, so programme benefits. Also provides contractor more confidence.

42
Q

Why is it beneficial to be back-to-back with MWCC?

A

For all options, most of the ‘core clauses’ are the same. However, there are a few specific ‘main option clauses’ which differ.

If you have a Client contract and a subcontract with the same Option, these clauses can be passed down. This improves ease of contract creation and administration.

E.g. Option C - Activity Schedule used and payment being Defined Cost plus fee.

43
Q

What is a CE?

A

An event which does not arise from a fault of the Contractor, that entitles the Contractor to be compensated for any effect to Prices, Key Dates and the Completion Date. Essentially time and money.

44
Q

What is a Parent Company Guarantee (PCG)?

A

A parent company guarantee (PCG) is a performance and financial guarantee to the client, in the event of a default on the contract by a contractor who is controlled by a Parent Company. i.e. a Group.

45
Q

Why did you advise X4 over X13?

A

X4 PCG
X13 Performance Bond

So, they both offer security if the Subcontractor defaults under the contract.

However, bond is just a financial guarantee. The PCG is a financial and performance guarantee. It is also free, and had been used on other subcontract packages across the project.

46
Q

How have you selected a suitable contract based on the procurement route?

A

The procurement route on HS2 is D&B, the ECC/ECS/ECSC/ECSS are all well suited as they have an element of design. The ECC was used due to high project complexity / design. The short forms would be used where the project complexity and design is lower, e.g. WP26.1A Trial Holes.

WP26.1B - I selected a ECS for this package.

This Q is repeated in PT.

47
Q

How did you manage insurances on the project?

A

Clause 84 states information regarding insurance cover. There is an insurance table which states the Subcontractor’s insurances.

l requested they send us their PII, Employer’s liability and public liability insurances.

There are also insurance checks carried out for their proposed sub-subs.

On WP26.1A, I noticed their PII was about to expire, so advised them to obtain and issue to us.

48
Q

What is statute law?

What is tort & tort law?

A

Statute: written law passed by a legislative body.

Tort: is a civil wrong, which causes loss or injury. Tort law relates to remedy for losses or injury, from negligence of another party, by providing monetary compensation.

49
Q

CPD - What did you learn from GN Fluctuations, 1st edition?

A

Learnt about fluctuations in different types of contracts.

NEC has a Secondary Option X1.

NEC examples:
Option C Target Cost – The target cost is agreed and can be adjusted for inflation.
Option E Reimbursable – The Contractor is paid on actual cost. Actual costs can change, e.g. quantities and rates, and therefore the cost can be adjusted.

JCT incudes this in the Contract Details.

50
Q

What is a performance bond?

What is a default bond?

A

A performance bond is a financial guarantee to the client if there was a failure of the Contractor to meet its obligations.

A default bond is the most commonly used form of performance bond in the UK construction industry.

51
Q

What is an Extension of time?

A

Subcontractor entitled to time extension to Completion Date via a CE.

52
Q

Where is termination in NEC?

A

Clause 90 and 91. Client can terminate if Contractor fails to meet obligations and not put default right within 4 weeks of the notification.

53
Q

Name some of the NEC Contracts (Suites / Family).

A

NEC ECC
NEC ECS
NEC ECSC
NEC ECSS (used on Trial Hole package)
PSC (has short too)
TSC (has short too)

54
Q

What are the Y options?

A

They are secondary options.

Y1 - Project Bank Account
Y2 - The HGCRA 1996
Y3 - The Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999

55
Q

What are liquidated damages and unliquidated damages?

A

LDs - Sum of money agreed in the contract that would be payable to the client if there was a breach of contract (i.e. late completion). Usually based on the forecasted loss the client is likely to incur, and is set as a daily or weekly sum.

UDs - Not agreed in the contract. The sum is said to be ‘at large’ and will be determined by the court.

56
Q

HGCRA payment timescales?

A

Payee submits an AFP on the assessment date.
Payer notifies payment on the payment notice date (about 2 weeks later)
If the payer changes their mind, they must issue a pay less notice no later 1 week (5 days) before the final date for payment.

The HGCRA 1996 states that the payee is entitled to periodic payments. It also provides that a construction contract must contain an adequate mechanism for:
- ‘due date’
- ‘final date’

57
Q

You mentioned ‘named’ subcontract. What is this?

A

I meant just the subcontract I named above.

However, named is when a client will advise that they want to use a Subbie. You don’t have to though.

Nominated subcontractors are those selected by the client and imposed on the main contractor. The Client is therefore liable for agreeing the subcontract terms and the performance.

58
Q

WP26.1B - Did you have X7 delay damages?

Why did you have X6 & X7?

A

Yes. £1.5k a day.

Extra incentivisation to achieve the Completion Date.

59
Q

PWDD?

A

A - activity schedule items completed (free of Defects)

B - quantity completed x rate (free of Defects)

C, D & E - Defined Cost plus fee - Disallowed Cost.