Unit 2 AC2.1 AC3.2 Describe/evaluate biological theories of criminality Flashcards
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals - Key ideas
Criminals are physically different from non-criminals.
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals - Study
Measured many criminals’ heads and faces.
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals - Findings
Criminals more likely to have large jaws, long arms, aquiline noses.
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals - Atavism
Criminals are throwbacks to primitive stage of evolution – pre-social, impulsive, reduced sensitivity to pain.
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals - Further work
Insane criminals, epileptic criminals. Criminaloids – product of environment.
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals -Strength
First person to study crime scientifically.
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals -Strength
Shows imoportance of clinical and historical records of criminals.
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals -Strength
Helps to focus on how prevention not punishment.
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals -Limitation
No further evidence to link facial features and criminality.
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals -Limitation
Did not compare with control group of non-criminals.
Physiological theories - Lombroso: Born Criminals -Limitation
Racist. Equates criminals with savages/ non-western society.
Physiological theories - Sheldon: Somatotypes theory - Key idea
Somatype (body type) is related to criminality.
Physiological theories - Sheldon: Somatotypes theory -Study
Looked at body types and compared with likelihood of criminality.
Physiological theories - Sheldon: Somatotypes theory -Findings
Mesomorphic somatype most likely to be criminal.
Physiological theories - Sheldon: Somatotypes theory -Reason?
Attracted by risk-taking and their physique and assertiveness are important assets in crime.
Physiological theories - Sheldon: Somatotypes theory -Strength
Other studies replicate findings.
Physiological theories - Sheldon: Somatotypes theory -Strength
Most serious delinquents had most mesomorphic bodies.
Physiological theories - Sheldon: Somatotypes theory -Limitation
Criminality likely to be a combination of biology and environment.
Physiological theories - Sheldon: Somatotypes theory -Limitation
Mesomorphic build may be result of criminality.
Physiological theories - Sheldon: Somatotypes theory -Limitation
Social class might be true cause of offending and mesomorphy.
Physiological theories - Sheldon: Somatotypes theory -Limitation
Mesomorphs more likely to be labelled.
Atavism
The idea that criminals are ‘throwbacks’ to more primitive stage of evolution.
Endomorph
Rounded, soft bodied, lacking muscle. Sociable, relaxed, outgoing.
Ectomorph
Thin, fragile, lacking fat and muscle. Flat chested, narrow hips and shoulders, thin face. Self conscious, emotionally restrained, thoughtful.
Mesomorph
Muscular, hard-bodied, little fat, strong limbs, broad shoulder, narrow waist. Adventurous, sensation-seeking, assertive, domineering.
Physiological theories
These biological theories claim that the physical features of criminals differ from non-criminals.
Biological theories
Criminals are biologically different from non-criminals and this difference causes them to commit crime.
Genetic theories - Twin and Adoption Studies - Key idea: Twins
If crime is genetic – identical (Mz) twins should have identical criminality
Genetic theories - Twin and Adoption Studies -Twin study findings
Christiansen: Concordance in criminality Mz = 52% vs Dz = 22%
Genetic theories - Twin and Adoption Studies -Key idea: Adoption
Adoptees share environment of adoptive parents/genes of biological parents. If genetic, criminality will match biological parents more.
Genetic theories - Twin and Adoption Studies -Adoption Study findings
Mednick et al: birth parent concordance = 20% vs. adopted parent concordance = 14.7%
Genetic theories - Twin and Adoption Studies -Strength
Twin & adoption studies give some support to genetic explanations
Genetic theories - Twin and Adoption Studies -Strength
Adoption studies overcome the problem of isolating genes and environment