Youth Crime (FINAL) Flashcards
Measuring issues around youth is complicated
What is the age range for youth?
based on when brain is fully developed, financially independent, age of majority 18+, etc?
Youth behaviours are on a continuum from risky to deviant to criminal behaviour
Defining these categories or moving from one to another is complicated
Vast majority of youth engage in behaviour that is considered risky.
The perception of youth crime outweighs the actual prevalence of youth crime due to
moral panics
What are status offences?
Behaviours that are criminal only due to age (underage drinking, driving, etc.)
Youth are always seen as a problem and need
tools/help to become an adult, are also considered deficient in many categories
Transition from childhood to adulthood
This transition is arbitrarily determined in our society with no “rite of passage”
Social structures do not always adhere to the widening responsibilities placed on youth as they transition
Young people are framed as both
at risk and as a risk
Development of Modern Youth Justice: Philippe Aries
How children were viewed and treated by adults in earlier times and how this has changed over time
- Concept of childhood was discovered in 17th century in Western Europe
- High mortality rate = lack of emotional investment by parents
- Less status ambiguity and intergenerational conflict prior to concept of childhood
- Claimed children were happier prior to 17th century
Development of Modern Youth Justice: Beatrice Gottlieb
There has always been ambiguity around childhood and adolescence
The Child Savers Movement
Goal of movement: socialize kids
- Around the industrial revolution era
- Prior to this movement, children were convicted and sentenced the same as adults
Wanted to see and recognize children as just that and having their own rights, rather than only seeing them as future adults
- Raises questions around the links between social control and delinquency
- Represented middle class women who were seen as best suited to socialize children
- Delinquency was linked to improper socialization
- Children were no longer needed for labour at this time
- Children were stated to be seen as innocent and to be protected rather than being used
The Social Construction of Adolescence
Social and cultural transitional period, ages 15-24
Fasick’s 5 demographic transitions that led to current social construction of adolescence:
- Population increase/urbanization
- Emergence of the small family system (parents can invest more into their children when they have less)
- Development of mandatory education laws (children no longer seen as a means for money, more is being invested into them. Also ensured that children were prohibited from entering the workforce bc schooling is mandatory, usually until 16)
- Cultural practices based around “parental dependence” (parents must house and provide for children until their mandatory education is completed)
- Onset of “youth culture”
Understanding youth and deviance: fundamental concerns with critical youth studies centre around
Why youth are portrayed as a threat to society, which must be fixed or controlled
Mainstream criminological theories focus on youth as a problem
Mainstream critical theories of youth crime that problematize youth:
- Social control theory (Crime is a learnt behaviour through socialization, a person with strong social bonds is less likely to commit a crime. Delinquency and crime result when an individual’s bond to conventional society is weakened or destroyed)
- Social disorganization theory (Crime is most likely to occur in communities with weak social ties and the absence of social control. Youth are in transitional zone = prone to crime/deviance bc not connected/assimilated to “adult world”?)
- Matza’s techniques of neutralization (denying youth are victims or denying harm was done??)
- Strain theory (negative emotions that result in strain = anomie, or structural inequalities in access to legitimate opportunities. Crime and deviance is a result of a person’s failure to achieve socially valued goals by legitimate means.)
Early Child-Welfare Model of Youth Justice
An Act for the more Speedy Trial and Punishment of Juvenile Offenders (1857):
- introduced the ideas of proportionality
- person under 16 who had committed an offence
- sentencing was imprisonment or confinement house - no longer than 3months and with no hard labour
Parens partiae:
idea that the state has a duty to assume the role of a parent in the case of delinquent or dependent children with no parents
What are the 3 different legislative regimes that have evolved for administering juvenile justice in Canada?
- Juvenile Delinquents Act (JDA) of 1908
- The Young Offenders Act (YOA) of 1984
- Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA) 2003
Juvenile Delinquents Act (JDA) of 1908
- Canada’s 1st juvenile delinquency legislation, in force from 1908-1984, which allowed provinces to set their own maximum ages of jurisdiction
- Maximum ages ranged from 7-14 and could be different for males and females
The Young Offenders Act (YOA) of 1984
Increased discussions over the rights and responsibilities of individuals in society
- The right to fair and equitable treatment for young people (with respect to their inexperience in life/lack of knowledge about life -»> diminished responsibility)
- The addition of due process and status offences for young offenders (informing them of their rights in a way youth can comprehend and understand)
- Young people were given the right to retain counsel, remain silent, and consult with parent or lawyer
Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA) ushered Canada into a new era in administration of youth justice
- Introduced in 2003 to replace YOA
- Pushes the idea that youth should be diverted from formal CJS as much as possible and diverted to extra judicial sanctions
- Involves youth justice committees that hear cases of potential young offenders and give them sanctions in the community
- go-to response for youth crime, especially for younger offenders and first offenders
Critical Perspectives on Adolescence: Exploitation and Medicalization
Young people are being portrayed as increasingly adult = trying to gain more of a consumer base for adult products (ie makeup being advertised to younger and younger kids), youth wanting to appear as more adult
YET, older individuals want to appear younger
Youth becomes the front and center of our consumer industry
3 institutions that focus on what it means to be youth “at risk” and contributing to moral panic:
- Economic exploitation
- Medicalization
- Media
Economic Exploitation of Youth
- Pressure to find employment and engage in hyper-consumption
- Identity can only be reinforced through product consumption
Medicalization of Youth
Increasingly behaviours that are considered specific to young people being medicalized and “over-diagnosed and overprescribing” (i.e ADHD meds) and these behaviours are “normal” for children in their development
- Adolescent-specific disorders
- ADHD, oppositional defiance disorder