the scrutiny function of parliament Flashcards
PMQs
explanation
a weekly 30 minute session in which the prime minster faces questions from the opposition and from backbenchers
PMQs
example
in 2022 Liz Truss faced difficult questions from Keir Starmer following the dropping of her economic plan and a 40 year high inflation rate
PMQs
issues
can often be more theatrical than in depth questioning with MPs looking for a media headline rater then scrutiny
ministerial question time
explanation
held for 1 hour on monday-thursday each day a different government department faces oral questions from the House of Commons
ministerial question time
example
in 2022 Priti Patel faced questions including a request to disclose the cost of the plan to deport asylum seekers to Rwanda for processing
ministerial question time
issues
any minster from a department can be sent to answer questions not necessarily the cabinet minsters
select committess
explanation
made up of backbench MPs select committees shadow the work of a government department including calling witnesses and producing reports on the work of the government
select committess
example
in 2017 David Davis said to the Brexit select committee that parliament would get a vote on Brexit but it might be after the Uk had left. this led to his department issuing a clarification that palriament would get a vote
select committess
issues
the government has 2 months to reply to select committee reports but does not have to take on board their suggestions
the legislative process
explanation
all MPs can take part in debates committees and voting on the legislative process
the legislative process
example
in 2022 all conservative MPs voted for then police crime sentencing and court bills (third reading) and all labour MPs voted against it
the legislative process
issues
party whips can limit the amount of scrutiny that takes place
opposition days
explanation
there are 20 days in the parliamentary calendar in which the opposition can choose the subjects for discussion
opposition days
example
in 2022 labour used all opposition days to bring a vote on fracking which was one of the leading factors leading to liz truss’ resignation
opposition days
issues
votes taken on opposition days are usually not binding and the opposition doesn’t not choose when then days take place
humble address
explanation
this is a request from the HOC for the release of documents named in the address if passed this is binding
humble address
example
in 2017 labour used a humble address to get government to release its Brexit impact assessments
humble address
issues
this requires a vote in favour and as the government has a majority in the HOC that can be difficult to achieve
backbench business committee
explanation
committee is given 35 hard days per parliamentary session to choose what subjects will be discussed
backbench business committee
example
in 2011 a backbench business committee debate passed a motion to give all government documents to the inquiry into the Hillsborough disaster
backbench business committee
issues
the impact had been relatively limited with few identifiable successes
petitions committee
explanation
the petitions committee considers e petitions on the HOC website those with 10,000 signature get a government response and those with 100,000 are elegible for debate
petitions committee
example
during the 2017-19 parliamentary session the petition to revoke article 50 and remain in he EU gained over 6 million signatures
petitions committee
issues
while the government will respond to petitions with over 10,000 signatures it is to bound to accept the requests they make