The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang Flashcards
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Aim of paper
- aim of paper: analyse impact of IT on two important attributes of firm –
1) firm size
2) allocation of decision making authority among actors in firm
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
AGENCY THEORY View of firm:
set of agency contracts (nexus of contracts) under which a principal (entrepreneur) employs agents (employees) to perform some service on his behalf
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Agency theory
: agent has his/her objective in mind & pays no regard to welfare of principal or other virtues such as honour, team spirit, integrity, pride of achievement
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Agency costs:
costs incurred as result of discrepancies between objectives of principal & those of agents; sum of
a) monitoring cots b) bonding costs c) residual loss
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Agency costs: Monitoring costs
principal can hire another person to monitor agent & another person to monitor the monitor etc (monitoring costs)
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Agency costs: bonding costs
agent needs to report to principle often (=time consuming)
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Agency costs: (residual loss)
but despite monitoring & bonding activities, principal may still experience partial loss of welfare
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
shareholder-manager conflict
as result of separation of ownership and management agents who act in own interest at expense of shareholders
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Empire building:
common to shareholder-manager relationship – manager makes big investment eg information system (with big office etc) as it shows power, perks, high salary + sign of career success
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
manager-employee conflict:
employees may shirk, receive bribes, abuse decision rights + conflicting interests between departmental managers (eg manufacturing & marketing)
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
how to solve manager-employee conflict:
- direct monitoring
- contracts available to control agents’ activities: employee compensation linked to performance, profit centres, cost allocation
- outside labour markets proxy fights & takeover risks discipline managers
- institutions help reduce agency costs due to monitoring: banks, auditing firms etc
- cultures & norms nurtured within firm play crucial role in mitigating agency costs: Japan – trust
- human nature is not as evil as agency theories depict it to be
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Decision information costs:
costs of (mis-)communication, opportunity costs due to delay + suboptimal decisions; increases as decision right is moved higher
* if all decision made by employees, agency costs would be very high
increase when right is pushed down
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Internal coordination costs:
combination of agency & decision information costs; decision rights should be located where these are minimised
* cost structure varies from situation to situation
* both components from internal coordination costs stem from acquisition of information
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Transaction cost theory:
there are costs in using a market as coordination mechanism & firm is alternative mechanism that facilitates economising on market transaction costs
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
THE MARVELS OF MARKETS
- markets collect & transmit knowledge of particular circumstances of time & place that may be costly for central authority to capture market itself is an information system which serves economy
- through price systems, markets provide coordination mechanism which induces individuals to pursue self-interest that benefit society as a whole
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
various kinds of transactions costs associated with using markets
ex ante costs
costs of acquiring market information & negotiating deal
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
various kinds of transactions costs associated with using markets
ex post costs
associated with preventing and dealing with contract default
The Impact of Information Systems on Organisations & Markets – Gurbaxani & Whang
Market transaction costs/external transaction costs:
coordination costs involved in using an outside market (eg costs of writing a contract and enforcing it);
must be incurred without adding intrinsic value to the software/product or service in general