The Evidence Base for Vision Therapy Flashcards
T/F you must discount the validity and importance of qualitative and clinical research
false, some conditions cannot be studied with double-blind, placebo-controlled methods
Why is it hard to get double-blind research for VT?
funding is difficult to obtain or completely unavailable
What form of study are many of the VT papers?
anecdotal/case-based evidence
What was the convergence insufficiency treatment trial?
a randomized clinical trial of treatments for symptomatic convergence insufficiency in children 2008
What are commonly prescribed therapies for CI?
pencil push-up, home computer-based therapy, office-based therapy
What are the CITT methods?
9 centers throughout the US, children 9-17, randomized into 4 treatment groups
What was the CITT inclusion criteria?
near exo at 4 prism diopters greater than distance (or more), receded NPC, insufficient PFV at near, symptomatic on CISS (>16)
What were the 4 treatments groups of the CITT?
1) home-based pencil push-ups 2) home-based computer-based vergence/accommodative therapy and pencil push-ups 3) office-based vergence/accommodative therapy with home reinforcement 4)office-based placebo therapy (monocular)
What were the primary outcomes of CITT?
improvement/elimination of symptoms, statistically significant improvement of symptoms for office-based VT group vs other groups, no difference between other three groups
What were the secondary outcomes of CITT?
improvement in clinical signs, statistically significant improvement in clinical signs for office-based VT groups vs. the other three groups
What does success mean in CITT?
improvement or normal findings for symptoms, NPC, AND PFV
What does improved mean in CITT?
improvement or normal findings for symptoms and NPC OR PFV
What statement describes the overall improvement of CITT?
statistically significant number of successful and improved patients in the office-based VT groups vs. other 3 groups
What are the main discussion points of CITT?
OBVT showed greatest improvements compared to other 3 groups, there was not a no treatment group, results are applicable to 9-17 need further study for adults, 12 weeks chosen b/c likely to show improvements without significant dropout rate
T/F all CITT groups showed some improvements in symptoms and signs
true
Were the CITT results based on placebo effect?
no, although there was no “no treatment” group, the placebo effect should have affected all groups similarly
Would having the trial run more than 12 weeks effect the CITT findings?
maybe, it is possible that more therapy may show more improvement (may become statistically significant for other groups)
What was the treatment of accommodative dysfunction study?
data from CITT with the same cohorts analyzed for accommodation results, 2011
What are the most common accommodative disorders in children?
AI and Acc infacility
What are common treatments for accommodative dysfunction?
plus lenses at near or VT/orthoptics
What were the treatment of accommodative dysfunction study methods?
same as CITT because it was analysis of CITT study data
What were the four randomized groups for the treatment of accommodative dysfunction study?
same as CITT 1)HBPP 2)HBCVAT+ 3)OBVAT and 4) OBPT
What were the accommodative amplitude results for the treatment of accommodative dysfunction study?
all treatment groups showed improvement at 4 weeks, OBVT showed the greatest increase, also showed improvements at 8 and 12 weeks
Which VT skill improves first?
accommodation, at about 4 weeks
What were the accommodative facility results in the treatment of accommodative dysfunction study?
all treatment groups showed improvement, OBVT and HBVT showed improvement at 4 and 8 weeks visits, pencil push-ups showed improvement at 8 weeks visit
What group showed the only statistically significant increased compared to placebo in the treatment of accommodative dysfunction study?
office based VT
What is the treatment of accommodative dysfunction study discussion main points?
OBVT showed the most effective treatment of accommodation, changes in accommodation should be noted at a 4 week VT progress evaluation, some changes were noted in the placebo group
What was the progression of therapy in the OBVT group that proved to be an effect treatment of accommodation?
monocular –> bi-ocular –> binocular
What should you do if no improvement in accommodation is seen by 4 weeks?
consider consistency of therapy or other conditions
Why were some changes noted in the placebo group?
may be placebo effect or regression to mean