Stress - Methods of Modifying Flashcards
What are the Methods of Modifying Stress?
- Beta Blockers
2. Stress Inoculation Training
Why are Beta Blockers Needed?
Explanation
- Key aspect of body’s response to stress arousal of sympathetic nervous system - match physical symptoms use experience- increased blood pressure/heart rate - symptoms can cause long-term negative health effects (e.g. cardiovascular disorder)
How do Beta Blockers Work?
- BBs have a antagonist action - work by reducing activity in sympathetic nervous system + reducing subsequent symptoms
- Beta Adrenoceptor Blocking Agents = block receptor sits for the hormones adrenaline + noradrenaline
- Adrenaline binds with target receptors stimulates associated muscles (causing heart to beat faster) - usual physical reaction to stress is dampened - breathing + heart rate doesn’t increase + person feels calmer + less anxious
- Beta blockers don’t completely stop anxiety but mask outward signs
- Useful for acute stress
What are the Types of Beta Blockers?
- Non-Selective
2. Selective
Describe Non-Selective Beta Blockers
- Propanlol
- Block adrenaline + nurodrenaline
- Block beta 1 (B1) + beta 2 (B2
- Affects heart/kidneys/liver/etc
Describe Selective Beta Blockers
- Atenolol
- Affects mostly the heart + therefore has less effect on the rest of the body
- Only blocks Beta 1 (B1) - cause reduced cardiac output
Describe the Off-Label Use of Beta Blockers
- Primarily prescribed + approved for high blood pressure + angina
- Prescribed off-label for anxiety conditions
- Manufacturer has not applied for licence for Beta Blockers to be used to treat anxiety - drug will not have gone under clinical Trial
- Doctors feels prescribing Beta Blockers for anxiety has benefits outweigh any risk
- Prescribed as a lower dose than that used for cardiac conditions
How Do Some Musicians use Beta Blockers?
- Use to overcome stage fright + more able to perform under pressure
- Lockwood (1989) = 2000 musicians in major Us orchestra - 27% use Beta Blockers for performance + 19% used it everyday
How are Beta Blockers Used in Sport?
- Since 2010 all Beta Blockers have been banned by the World Anti-Doping Agency for all Olympic sports
- In Golf 2015 Christian Bezuidenhout tested positive for BBs + faced a 2 year ban from golf - appealed as he was taking them for anxiety - ban was reduced to 9 months
What are Benzodiazepines?
- Increase activity of gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) - increases serotonin - reduces arousal
- BZs only used to help those suffering from severe stress in a short term crisis - HIGHLY ADDICTIVE
- Causes drowsiness/impaired judgement - individuals need to be weaned off
Beta Blockers Evaluation
Effectiveness
Benefits On Performance + Self-Reported Levels of Stress
- Positive
- Neftel (1982) = gave string players atenolol (BBs) or placebo 6 1/2 hours before performing - atenolol group had lower heart rates + were more able yo play complex parts of the music accurately - also reported less stage fright after performance compared with placebo
HOWEVER - Schweizer (1991) = compared effects of different types of BBs in maths test - all BBs had expected physical effects there were differences in subjective ratings of stress amougst groups
Beta Blockers Evaluation
Effectiveness
Benefits for Other Aspects of Stress
- Schwabe 2011 study
- Negative effects of stress is stressed people falling into bad habits (e.g. addiction) rather than focusing on important goals
- Lab experiment concerning food rewards - 3 groups
1. No Stress
2. Stressed + BB
3. Stressed + placebo - Findings - stress + placebo continued with habits formed
- Stress + BBs just as goal directed as those that had received no stress - BBs prevented the stress induced bias towards habit behavior
- Although research was in an artificial environment - potentially useful application of BBs for dealing with psychological effects of stress
Beta Blockers Evaluation
Effectiveness
Long Term Effectiveness
- NEGATIVE
- BBs criticised for their long term effectiness
- BBs don’t address the psychological + emotinal side
- Root cause of stress + individual’s reaction to it may not be addressed
- SIT may be more appropriate in giving individuals long term coping strategies to use across a range of situations
- BBs may only be useful for specific performance based scenarios + may not work for chronic stress
Beta Blockers Evaluation
Ethical Issues
Side Effectiveness
- NEGATIVE
- Side effects tend to be mild + temporary (e.g. dizziness/diarrhoea/nausea/blurred vision/cold feet/cold hands/issues with sleep/shortness of breath)
- Compared with BZs effects are minimal
- Stopping taking BBs suddenly could cause problems (e.g. heart palpitations/higher blood pressure) as body will be so used to drug’s effects in slowing down sympathetic response - individual may become psychological dependent, feeling as they cannot cope without it
Beta Blockers Evaluation
Ethical Issues
Use of Beta Blockers to Enhance Performance
- NEGATIVE
- Ethical question
- BBs are banned in most sports- suggesting that its unethical
- Key parts of high level performance in sport is the ability to perform under pressure - providing an unfair advantage
- BBs specifically don’t enhance performance - simply stop any anxiety interfering with performance