savulescu Flashcards
east german scandal
women’s swimming team dominated the olympics, but took PEDs w/o consent
- sued the government
economics of cheating
athletes make millions
only 10-15% athletes tested
light punishments if caught i.e. 6 months ban
irresistible to athletes
modern drugs
hard to detect bcs natural substances i.e. EPO, growth hormones
prisoner’s dilemma in sports doping
game theory shows that athletes feel forced to cheat to stay competitive
when chance of being caught is 0, everyone cheats
only way to eliminate PEDs is if drug testing is 100% effective, or if reduce rewards for winning
WADA criteria for banning PEDs
- performance enhancement
- health risk
- violation of the spirit of sport
how do PEDs violate spirit of sport
spirit of sport: ethics, honesty, fair play, excellence, teamwork, etc.
musicians vs athletes
musicians use beta blockers to dec anxiety, not seen as PEDs
athletes are also artists
PEDs vs genetics
some athletes have natural advantages, PEDs may be evening the playfield
main takeaway is that PEDs shift focus from athletic ability to body’s response to a drug
economic discrimination and PEDs
the authors say PEDs can dec economic discrimination
- olympians wealthy families, access tech and strategies/coaches
high alt training —> PEDs
what restraint do the authors believe should be placed on PEDs
limits on drugs in sport and SAFETY
don’t test for drugs, rather for helath and safety
- i.e. whether natural or unnatural, excessively high blood viscosity shouldn’t compete
why allow PEDS
allow safe drugs to prevent use of unsafe ones
- makes illegal black market that’s dangerous vs safe, regulated drugs and quantities
body produces some drugs naturally
some drugs that inc perf as required i.e. heart medication
kids and PEDs
say kids should not be given PEDs, and should not TRAIN to become elite when young
don’t want to limits kids opps for the future
strict liability
rule that athletes are solely resp for what they consume
coach may be problem but not liable
coercion? lack informed consent