Real Property Flashcards
ownership
what are the ways to transfer a property?
- sale
- gift
- devise (will)
- intestate succession (dies without will)
ownership
when is a gift in a will effective?
when decedent dies
ownership
how do you divide up ownership interests in time?
present interests + future interests
key distinction is timing of the possession
ownership / present estates
what are the types of present estate interests?
- fee simple absolute
- fee simple determinable (defeasible)
- fee simple subject to a condition subsequent (defeasible)
- fee simple subject to an executory interest (defeasible)
- life estate
defeasible = may be terminated by the occurrence of an event, can last forever or terminate early
magic words - what type of interest is this?
” and her heirs”
fee simple absolute
magic words - what type of interest is this?
O conveys to CK while she uses it as a garden
fee simple determinable
magic words - what type of interest is this?
O conveys to CK, but if the land no longer is a garden, O may re-enter and re-take the property.
fee simple subject to condition subsequent
what is the default present estate?
fee simple absolute
ownership / present estates
fee simple absolute
- capable of lasting forever, no associated future interest
- inheritable
- transferable
- “my hope and wish” are not enough to show intent of FSA
ownership / present estates
fee simple determinable
- limited by durational language
- “so long as”
- “while”
- “during”
- “until it is no longer used as a basil garden”
determinable = durational
ownership / present estates
fee simple subject to condition subsequent
- limited by specific conditional language
- grantor must exercise a right in order to take possession (grantor holds)
- “but if”
- “provided that”
- “on the condition that”
if 3p has the future interest (not the grantor), then it’s FS subj to EI
ownership / future interests
what are the types of future interests?
- possibility of reverter (defeasible fees)
- right of entry (defeasible fees)
- reversion
- remainder
- executory interest
ownership / future interests
possibility of reverter
- future interest is held by grantor after fee simple determinable
- interest vests automatically after durational period
ownership / future interests
executory interest
- future interest that will terminate (divest) an earlier interest
- future interest is held by 3p following fee simple determinable
two types
* springing EI - divests the grantor
* shifting EI - divests a prior grantee
ownership / future interests
right of entry
- future interest held by the grantor following fee simple subject to condition subsequent
- doesn’t vest automatically, must be reclaimed
also called power of termination
ownership / future interests
fee simple subject to executory interest
- future interest is held by a transferee (3p) not grantor
- ends upon happening of an event + future interest vests in 3p
ownership / present estate
life estate
- possession by a life
- look for “for life”
- if ambiguous, look at grantor’s intent to create an estate that will end upon the death of the measuring life
- ends naturally when measuring life ends
- transferable (but still focus on measuring life)
- can’t pass the property by will
- no intestate succession
ownership / future interests
reversion
if possession goes back to grantor after life estate ends, grantor retains a reversion
if contingent remainder doesn’t vest becomes it becomes possessory, grantor has a reversion
ownership / future interests
remainder
- if possession goes back to a 3p after life estate ends, 3p has a reminder
- no reminder after vested fee simple
- can be vested or contingent (two types)
ownership
Doctrine of Waste
- more than one party has an interest in the same piece of property
- affirmative waste - waste caused by voluntary conduct which causes a decrease in value
- permissive waste - waste caused by neglect of property which causes decrease in value
- ameliorative waste - person in possession changes use of property and increases its value (ex. renovation, construction of dam, fixing a fence)
key situations:
- landlord / tenant
- co tenant out of possession / tenant in possession (concurrent state)
- mortgagee / mortgagor
tip
How do you spot a waste problem?
- do multiple parties have simultaneous interests?
- is there a change in value of the property due to actions/inactions of the party in possession?
- will the waste substantially change the interest taken but the party out of possession?
ownership / future interests
vested remainder vs. contingent remainder
interest that is
1. given to an ascertained grantee (you can ID them) AND
2. not subject to a condition precedent
if 1 + 2 met, vested remainder
if fails, contingent remainder
ownership / future interests
vested remainder subject to open
- class gift
- full class membership is unknown
- at least one person in the class must be vested for it to be vested subject to open; if not, contingent remainder
- class closes when all members of the class are identified
ownership / future interests + RAP
Rule of Convenience
way to close a class to avoid application of RAP to a class gift
if no express closing date, this rule closes the class when any member of the class becomes entitled to immediate possession
interpretative rule
ownership / future interests
Doctrine of Worthier Title
prevents remainders in a grantor’s heirs
creates a presumption of a reversion to the grantor
rebuttable by showing of contrary interest
A conveys “to B for life, remainder to A’s heirs.”
With Doctrine: B has life estate, A has reversion (unless contrary intent is established)
W/o Doctrine: B has life estate, A’s heirs have contingent remainder
ownership / future interests
Rule of Shelley’s Case
prevents reminders in a grantee’s heirs
uses doctrine of merger to create a fee simple
changes the remainder of heirs from fee simple absolute to contingent remainder
A conveys “to B for life, remainder to B’s heirs.”
With Shelley’s Case: B has life estate, heirs have FSA
Without: B has life estate, heirs have contingent remainder
tip
what’s an easy (not perfect) way to tell if springing or shifting executory interest?
two parties (grantor + grantee) –> likely springing b/c grantee will divest the grantor
three parties (grantor + two grantees) –> likely shifting b/c a grantee will divest another grantee
RAP
what is the context for RAP?
- prevents remote vesting
- testing for certainty
inter vivios transfer
interests created at time of the grant
devise
will
interests created at testator’s death NOT when will is drafted
RAP
what are the steps to a RAP analysis?
- when - ID when interests are created
inter vivos - time of transfer
devise - testator’s death - what - are the interests subject to RAP; RAP applies to these
contingent remainders
executory interests
class gifts subject to open (only vested remainders subject to open not closed ones) - who - ID relevant and validating lives
validating lives - look at whether interest vests within lifetime + 21 years
if no validating life, interest is bad so get to stick
if validating life, interest is okay - strike out the violating interest as if it was never created
relevant life
person who affects vesting, usually mentioned or implied by the grant
validating life
person who tells us whether or not the interest vests within the perpetuities period (lifetime + 21 years)
must have been alive when interests were created
can validate her own interest
RAP
what is the special rule for RAP and class gifts?
if gift to any member of the class is void under RAP, THEN the gift is void to all members of the class
all or nothing rule
RAP
what are exceptions to the class gift rule
all or nothing doesn’t apply
- transfers of a specific dollar amount to each class member
- transfers to a subclass that vests at a specific time
RAP
exceptions to RAP
- charities - doesn’t apply to a gift from one charity to another charity
- options - doesn’t apply to option held by a current tenant to purchase a fee interest in a leasehold property
- options - doesn’t apply to option or right of first refusal in a commercial transaction
RAP
what is the modern approach to traditional RAP?
- Uniform Statutory Rule Against Perpetuities
- wait and see approach
- wait and see if an interest is subject to RAP within the perpetuities period
- some states use vesting period of 90 years
cy pres
equitable doctrine that allows a court to reform a transfer to avoid RAP
trusts
concurrent estates
what are concurrent estates - definition + basic rule
ownership or possession of real property by 2+ people simultaneously
concurrent owners each have right to use/possess the entire property
BUT can contract out of the basic rule
concurrent estates
types of concurrent estates / concurrent ownership
which one is the default?
- tenancy in common (default)
- joint tenancy
- tenancy by the entirety
concurrent estates / tenancy in common
tenancy in common
- default
- concurrent owners have separate but undivided interests in the property
- no right of survivorship
- each co-tenant can transfer the property freely during life or at death
concurrent estates / joint tenancy
joint tenancy - definition / key characteristic
right of survivorship - surviving joint tenant(s) automatically take the deceased tenant’s interest
concurrent estates / joint tenancy
how do you create a joint tenancy?
- grantor must make clear expression of intent AND
- must be survivorship language (“as joint tenants with a right of survivorship”)
- four unities
concurrent estates / joint tenancy
what are the four unites?
PITT
- possession - each JT has an equal right to possess the whole of the property
- interest - JTs must have an equal share of the same type of interest
- time - must receive their interests at the same time
- title - must receive their interests in the same instrument of title
concurrent estates / joint tenancy
how do you sever a joint tenancy?
- if one of the four unities is lost, JT is severed and becomes tenancy in common
- inter vivos transfers - transfer during life will sever the right of survivorship and convert to tenancy in common
- mortgages (see other flashcard)
- leases (see other flashcard)
concurrent estates / joint tenancy
does a lien against a joint tenant’s interest sever the joint tenancy?
no b/c the lien terminates upon tenant’s death so surviving tenants’ interests are not encumbered
concurrent estates / joint tenancy
does a mortgage sever a joint tenancy?
JT grants a mortgage interest in the JT to a creditor
majority: lien theory –> mortgage is treated as a lien, doesn’t destroy JT
minority: title theory –> mortgage severs title, tenancy b/c JT and creditor is converted to tenancy in common
concurrent estates / joint tenancy
does a lease sever a joint tenancy?
JT leases her share in the property to a tenant
some juris: lease severs the JT
other juris: treat the lease as temporary suspension of JT
concurrent estates / tenancy by the entirety
tenancy by the entirety
- JT b/t married people (marriage is the fifth unity)
- right of survivorship
- can’t alienate or encumber their shares without consent of spouse
- need clear expression like “as tenants by the entity, with a right of survivorship”
- if grant is ambiguous, cts presume it’s JT or tenancy in common
concurrent estates / rights and obligations
what is the tenant’s right to possess the property?
each co-tenant has right to possess all of the property, regardless of their share and type of co-tenancy
EXCEPT if co-tenants entered into an agreement to contrary
concurrent estates / rights and obligations
what is ouster?
co-tenant in possession denies another co-tenant access to the property
concurrent estates / rights and obligations
what remedies are available for ouster? (for the ousted tenant)
- injunction granting access to the property
- recover damages for value of use while they were unable to access the property
concurrent estates / rights and obligations
how is rent from a 3p divided?
subtract operating expenses
divided based on ownership interests of each co-tenant
concurrent estates / rights and obligations
how are operating expenses divided?
necessary charges are divided based on ownership interests
can collect contribution from other co-tenants for payments in excess of their share
concurrent estates / rights and obligations
how are the costs of repairs and improvements divided?
no right to reimbursement for necessary repairs or improvements
BUT can get credit in a partition action
concurrent estates / rights and obligations
what is partition? what type of holders is it available to?
- equitable remedy
- available to tenancy in common OR joint tenancy (NOT tenancy by the entirety)
- unilateral right
concurrent estates / rights and obligations
what is the effect of partition?
court will divide the property into distinct portions
- physical partition / partition in kind (preferred)
- partition by sale - if physical partition is not practical OR not fair to all parties
concurrent estates / rights and obligations
how are the proceeds from a partition divided?
divided among co-tenants based on ownership interests
concurrent estates / rights and obligations
can you agree not to partition a property?
yes, can agree not to partition
it is enforceable IF (1) agreement is clear AND (2) time limitation is reasonable
discrimination / FHA
Fair Housing Act (FHA)
FHA prohibits discrimination in the sale, rental, and financing of dwellings
prohibits advertising that states a discriminatory purpose
discrimination / FHA
what is covered and not covered by FHA?
(types of housing)
- includes multi-family residential housing
exemptions:
- single-family housing without a broker
- owner-occupied buildings with 4 or fewer living units
- religious organizations and private clubs
discrimination / FHA
what traits are protected?
- race, color, religion, national origin, sex (sexual orientation + gender identity), disability, familial status
- families with children under 18 + pregnant
special exemptions for senior living
reasonable accommodations for people with disabilities
discrimination / FHA
what actions are prohibited?
- refusing to rent, sell, or finance a dwelling
- requiring different rents
- falsely denying that a unit is available
- providing different services to facilities (except making reasonable accommodations for disability)
- stating a discriminatory preference in an ad (doesn’t apply to single-fam w/o broker + boarding house unless shared living areas and restriction is sex-based)
discrimination / FHA
what intent is required?
disparate treatment (intent) + disparate impact (effect)
discrimination / FHA
what causation is required?
prohibited behavior must be linked to the protected basis
conflict of laws
for property, what is the controlling law (baseline rule)?
based upon where the property is located (law of the situs)
applies to these cases:
- foreclosure
- land contract dispute
- equitable interests
- intestate succession
- interpretating conveyances
conflict of laws
what are the exceptions to the baseline rule (law of situs)?
- choice of law provision
- cases involving marriage, especially classifying property as marital or separate –> domicile of party may override law of the situs
- mortgages: mortgage docs may require repayment to be made in another state
landlord + tenant
what does a lease create?
contract interest + property interest
landlord + tenant / tenancies
what are the four tenancies that govern the landlord-tenant relationship?
- tenancy for years
- periodic tenancy
- tenancy at will
- tenancy at sufferance
how is each created? how is each terminated?
landlord + tenant / tenancies
tenancy in years
- measured by a fixed and ascertainable amount of time
- created by agreement by landlord and tenant
- need to demonstrate intent to create the leasehold
- if longer than 1 year, needs to be in writing (SOF)
- automatically ends at expiration of term (no notice require)
- can end early if tenant surrenders the lease OR if tenant or landlord commits a material breach
landlord + tenant / tenancies
periodic tenancy
- estate that is repetitive and ongoing for a set period of time
- renews automatically at end of each period until one party gives proper notice of termination
- must intend to create this
- intent can be express (signed lease) or implied (payment of rent)
- old approach to termination: must give 6 month notice for year-to-year lease
- new approach to termination: shorter notice requirements
- proper notice = gives notice before start of last term (generally written)
landlord + tenant / tenancies
tenancy at will
- may be terminated by either landlord or tenant at any time for any reason
- created by express agreement or implication
- can be terminated by either party without notice
- if agreement gives ONLY landlord right to terminate at will, tenant gets right too by implication
- if agreement gives ONLY tenant right to terminate, landlord does NOT get the right too
- terminates at death of landlord or tenant
landlord + tenant / tenancies
what is the only tenancy that ends automatically when landlord or tenant dies?
tenancy at will
landlord + tenant / tenancies
tenancy at sufferance
- created when tenant holds over after lease ends
- temporary tenancy exists before landlord evicts the prior tenant OR re-rents the property to the tenant (creates a new tenancy with holdover tenant)
- tenant owes landlord reasonable value of their daily use + reasonably foreseeable special damages
- created by actions of tenant alone
- termination if (1) tenant voluntarily leaves, (2) landlord evicts tenant, or (3) landlord re-rents to tenant
landlord + tenant / tenant duties
what are the tenant’s two basic duties?
- pay rent
- avoid waste
landlord + tenant / tenant duties
in what situations is the duty to pay rent suspended?
- premises are damages (as long as tenant didn’t cause the damage)
- landlord completely or partially evicts the tenant
- landlord materially breaches the lease
partial eviction is when they’re removed from part of the property
landlord + tenant / tenant duties
implied covenant of quiet enjoyment
tenant can withhold rent when landlord takes actions that makes the premises wholly or substantially unstable for their intended purposes + tenant is constructively evicted
landlord + tenant / tenant duties
constructive eviction
- premises were unstable for their intended purposes (breach of covenant of quiet enjoyment)
- tenant notifies landlord of the problem
- landlord doesn’t correct the problem AND
- tenant vacates the premises after a reasonable amount of time has passed
landlord + tenant / tenant duties
implied warranty of habitability
- landlord has an obligation to maintain the property such that it is suitable for residential use
- conditions that threaten tenant’s heath and safety
- can’t waive
- residential only, not commercial
- if premises are not habitable, tenant may (1) refuse to pay rent, (2) remedy the defect and deduct costs from rent, or (3) defend against eviction
- can use offensively or defensively
- does not require tenant to move out
landlord + tenant / tenant duties
what is the major different between implied warranty of habitability vs. quiet enjoyment and constructive eviction?
habitability does NOT require tenant to move out
landlord + tenant / tenant duties
duty to avoid waste
- background rule, doesn’t need to be expressed in lease
- tenant has duty not to commit affirmative (voluntary) or permissive (neglectful) waste
landlord + tenant / tenant duties
duty to repair
in residential lease: landlord is presumed to be responsible for repairs
tenant must notify landlord of any needed repairs
landlord + tenant / landlord duties
duty to mitigate damages
if tenant abandons property early or is evicted, does the landlord have an obligation to mitigate damages by re-renting the property?
majority rule:
- landlord must make reasonable efforts to re-rent the property
- must treat property as if it were vacant stock
- tenant is relieved from obligation to continue paying rent if landlord doesn’t make diligent efforts to mitigate
- landlord gets different between original rent vs. rent received from replacement tenant
minority rule:
- landlord doesn’t have to mitigate damages
- more common in commercial leases
landlord + tenant / landlord duties
how can the landlord deal with a holdover tenant?
- evict them
- continue the relationship by treating them as a periodic tenant (accept rent)
rent is amount under old lease UNLESS landlord notified tenant of increased rent before expiration of old lease
landlord + tenant / landlord duties
duty to deliver possession
majority:
landlord must deliver actual (physical) possession of leasehold premises
minority:
landlord is only required to deliver legal possession (right of possession)
landlord + tenant / landlord duties
how does quiet enjoyment apply?
landlord can’t deny the tenant quiet enjoyment –> violated when landlord (or agent) renders the premises unstable for intended purpose
landlord + tenant / landlord duties
what does the landlord control on the leased premises?
common areas and nuisance-like behaviors of other tenants
does NOT control
- off-premises actions of 3p beyond landlord’s control
- in residential lease, landlord must provide habitable premises
can’t retaliate by evicting tenant if tenant complains
landlord + tenant / tort liability
what duty does the tenant owe?
duty of care
extends to invitees, licensees, and foreseeable trespassers
landlord + tenant / tort liability
who does landlord owe duty to?
liability to invitees, licensees, and foreseeable trespassers
common law:
responsible for negligent for latent (hidden) defects in which tenant hasn’t been warned
responsible for faulty repairs completed by landlord negligently
responsible for negligence that causes injuries in common areas (NOT inside your apt)
modern trend:
landlords have general duty of reasonable care
tip
if conveyance is ambiguous, discuss fee simple determinable + fee simple subject to condition subsequent
:)
landlord and tenant / subleases and assignments
what is an assignment
complete transfer of the tenant’s remaining term
landlord and tenant / subleases and assignments
what is a sublease
transfer for less than the entire duration of the lease
tenant retains a reversionary interest in the leasehold
landlord and tenant / subleases and assignments
in an assignment, who can landlord collect rent from?
tenant (b/c of privity of contract) OR subsequent tenant (b/c of privity of estate)
landlord and tenant / subleases and assignments
in a sublease, who can the landlord collect rent from?
only the tenant (they have privity of contract + privity of estate)
landlord and tenant / subleases and assignments
if a lease is silent on assignment and subleases, what is the default rule?
may assign or sublet freely
landlord and tenant / subleases and assignments
if lease requires landlord’s permission to transfer but doesn’t provide a standard, what is the default standard?
majority: landlord may deny only for a commercially reasonable reason
minority: landlord may deny at their discretion, reason isn’t required
land sale contracts
what are the two stages of land sale contracts?
- contract stage - negotiate terms
- deed stage - transfer property
covenants under contract are merged into the deed and any remedy flows from the deed
land sale contracts
what is liability based on in the two stages?
- contract sage - any liability must be based on a contract provision
- deed stage - . . . deed warranty
land sale contracts
what is the statute of frauds for land sale contracts?
they are subject to SOF
- must be in writing
- must be signed by party to be charged
- must include essential terms - parties (seller + buyer), description of the property, price and payment info
land sale contracts
what are the two main exceptions to SOF?
- part performance by either buyer or seller
basically need 2/3
(a) payment of all or part of purchase price
(b) possession by purchaser
(c) improvements by purchaser - detrimental reliance / estoppel
party has reasonably relied on the contract and would suffer hardship if the contract were not enforced
tip
“FP orally agrees to purchase CK’s home for $1.6mm”
what is this a flag for?
SOF for land sale contracts
land sale contracts
what does every land sale contract include?
implied covenant of marketable title
land sale contracts
what is the implied covenant of marketable title?
marketable title –> title is free from an unreasonable risk of litigation
- title acquired by adverse possession that hasn’t been quieted
- private encumbrances (mortgage, convent, easement)
- violation of zoning ordinance
applies to quit claim deeds too (PQs Set 1)
land sale contracts
when does a defect in the marketable title need to be cured by?
needs to be cured or fixed before closing
closing is when deed and contract merge and deed controls
land sale contracts
what is the standard to determine whether title is unmarketable? what is the remedy?
standard is of a reasonable buyer
if seller cant’ deliver marketable title, buyer’s ready is rescission of the contract
land sale contracts
what is the basic rule for delays?
unless the contact or parties notify, time is NOT of the essence (rip)
failure to close on the closing date may be a breach, but NOT grounds for rescission
specific performance is still available
land sale contracts
implied warranty of fitness or suitability
applies to defects in new construction
most jurisdictions: both initial homeowner/purchaser and subsequent purchasers may recover damages
minority: only OG buyer can enforce
suit must be brought within reasonable time after discovery of the defect
land sale contracts
duty to disclose defects
duty on the seller to disclose to the buyer all known, physical and material defects
materially defect must substantially affect the value of the home, health and safety of occupants, or desirability
general disclaimers (“as is”) don’t satisfy seller’s duty
land sale contracts
seller’s remedy if buyer breaches
- damages - difference b/t contract price and market price
- rescission - seller can sell to someone else
- specific performance
land sale contracts
buyer’s remedy if seller breaches
- damages - difference b/t contract price and market price on date of breach
- if seller breaches and acted in good faith, can only recover out of pocket expenses
- rescission - return payments to buyer and cancel contract
- specific performance
land sale contracts
who bears the risk of loss if there is damage to or destruction of the property?
majority:
buyer holds equitable title b/t execution of contract and closing/delivery of deed
buyer is responsible for damage during that period
seller has right to possess the property (they hold legal title)
minority:
risk of loss on seller until closing and delivery of deed
adverse possession
what are the basic rationales for adverse possession?
- punish true owner for sleeping on their rights
- reward adverse possessor for earring good title
when they get the property via AP, new title relates back to date of the person’s entry on the property
property owned by govt can’t be AP