Family Law (Essay Only) Flashcards
What is the standard for child custody, support, and other issues relating to the child?
best interest of the child
OR
best interest and welfare of the child
what is a marriage?
civil contract between two people
divorce
what are the grounds for a no-fault divorce?
irretrievably broken / irreconcilable differences
divorce
what does an equitable division of marital property at divorce require?
“just and fair” division NOT equal 50/50 division
what is required for modification or termination of a marriage contract?
state intervention
marriage
what is required for marriage (all types)?
- both parties must have capacity to give consent
- exchange of consideration –>
mutual exchange of promises + impositions of rights and obligations that come with the marriage relationship
marriage
what are the two major types of marriages?
ceremonial marriage + common law marriage
marriage / ceremonial
what are the two major requirements of ceremonial marriages?
license + solemnization
marriage / ceremonial
with ceremonial marriages, what s the age restriction (including an exception if any)?
most states: 18 years old
but can marry if under 18 with parental consent
marriage / ceremonial
with ceremonial marriages, is there a waiting period?
yes, most states require one b/t when license is issued and marriage ceremony
marriage / ceremonial
with ceremonial marriages, what is the rule for premarital medical testing?
some states require it
but results cannot be a condition for issuance of a marriage license
marriage / ceremonial
with ceremonial marriages, when does a marriage license expire?
10 to 30 days after issuance
marriage / ceremonial
with ceremonial marriages, when will a license NOT be issued? (4 ex)
- party is already married to someone else
- parties are too closely related
- marriage is a sham
- parties are incapcable of understanding the act of marriage (e.g., drugs, alc)
marriage / ceremonial
with ceremonial marriages, what are the requirements for soleminzation?
- at least 2 witnesses to the ceremony
- officiant (e.g., judge, religious leader, political official)
- marriage license must be filed with govt office
marriage / ceremonial
what is a proxy marriage?
party has a stand-in at the ceremony b/c they can’t physically attend
marriage / common law
what is a common law marriage?
- estabished by custom and cohabitation
- no license or solemization required
- most states have abolished (some have grandfathered)
marriage / common law
with common law marraiges, what are the requirements?
4 C’s
- capacity to marry
- consent
- cohabitation
- conduct
marriage / common law
what is the requisite time period for a common law marriage?
trick! there isn’t one
cts will consider evidence like common children, joint debt, joint assets, bank accounts, etc.
marriage / common law
do states have to recognize common law marriages from other states?
yes, Full Faith and Credit Clause
Exception: state has strong PBPL against it
some states have minimum time period to be domiciled to establish common law marriage
marriage / common law
what are the intent and capacity requirements for a common law marriage?
- both parties need legal and mental capacity to enter into the common law marriage
- parties must produce evidence of their present intent to enter the marraige
what is a heartbalm action?
historical, no longer recognized
civil tort actions for money damages based on broken engagements or infidelity
what is included in a heartbalm action?
- breach of promise to marry
- alientation of affection
- seduction
- criminal conversation
what is invovled in the marriage relationship?
many duties and benefits
provides a right to privacy for the marital or family relationship under the Cons
what is solmnization?
ceremony
what are the three ways to terminate a valid marriage?
- annulment
- divorce (dissolution)
- death
annulment
what is an annulment?
voids a marriage and declares it as having never been valid
annulment
what are the two ways to annul a marriage?
- void marriage
- voidable marriage
annulment
what is a void marriage?
“as if it never happened”
ANY party can seek it (parent, guardian, 3p)
annulment
what is a voidable marriage?
marriage is valid until a judicial decree dissolves the marriage
annulment
what are the grounds for a void marriage?
- prior existing marriage (bigamy)
- incest
- mental capacity (must be lucid at the moment of the marriage contract)
annulment / void marriage
with a void marriage annulment, what happens if there is bigamy?
later marriage is void
burden is on the person trying to prove the first marriage
EXCEPTION: some states allow marriage to become valid if one party had a good faith belief that the marriage was valid and the impediment is removed (punative spouse doctrine!)
what are the grounds for a voidable marriage?
- age
- impotence (EXCEPTION: other party knew about the impotence prior to the marriage)
- intoxication (EXCEPTION: parties continue to cohabitate after the marriage –> ratification)
- fraud, misrepresentation, duress, coercion, force
fraud must go to the “essence of the marriage” and be at the time of the marriage, not about future facts
must cease living together once the fraud is discovered - lack of intent (like a sham marriage), but can’t be annulled if consummated
impotence = helplessness
what is the difference between a void marriage and voidable marriage?
void marriage - doesn’t require judicial degree, will not be legally recognized for any purpose, any party (incl. 3p) can seek it
voidable marriage - requires judicial decree, valid until one of the parties seeks annulment
what is the effect of annulment?
next steps after annulment
- either party can seek spousal support
- can still seek equitable distribution of marital property
- can seek child support if child born within that marriage
- cts try to put parties in the same position as before the marriage
what is the effect of the annulment on the children?
they are considered marital children (legitimate)
annulment / void marriage
what are the defenses to annulment for a void marriage?
only defense is deny the impediment that makes the marriage void
annulment / voidable marriage
what are the defenses to annulment for a voidable marriage?
equitable defenses of unclean hands, laches, estoppel
what is the putative marriage / putative spouse doctrine?
equitable remedy
party who participated in a ceremonial marriage and believes in good faith that the marriage is valid may use a state’s divorce provisions even if the marriage is later found to be void
what is the definition of divorce?
legal dissolvement of a marriage
with divorce, what is the residency requirement in most states?
- at least one party must be a resident of that state
- length of residency may vary based on whether hte couple married in that state and/or grounds for divorce happened in that state
what are the two grounds for divorce?
no-fault and fault divorce
most states recognize only no-fault divorce
what is the standard for no-fault divorce?
marriage is “irretrievably broken”
also called irreconcilable differences
no prospect of reconciliation
some states require parties to be separated for a period of time before seeking
one spouse can’t prevent hte dissolution b/c they want to reconcile
why would someone file a fault-based divorce instead of no-fault?
fault divorces can be used to determine support (alimony)
what are the grounds for fault-based divorce?
- adultery
- cruelty / inhumane treatment
- desertion / abandoment
- habitual drunkenness (some states)
- bigamy
- imprisonment
- indignity (most states do NOT recognize)
- insitutionalization for insanity
in a fault-based divorce, what is adultery?
charging spouse had opportunity + inclination by the other spouse
in a fault-based divorce, what is cruelty?
requires course of conduct, not one-time incident
only some states allow emotional abuse, physical harm only generally
must make cohabitaiton unsafe or improper
in a fault-based divorce, what is desertion?
one spouse (1) voluntarily leaves the home (2) without cause or consent from other spouse (3) with intent to remain away permanently
constructive desertion: some states also include when one spouse forces the other one out and there is fear of harm if they return
in a fault-based divorce, what is habitual drunkenness?
frequent habit of getting drunk causes impairment in the marriage
alcoholism is not a requirement
in a fault-based divorce, what is bigamy?
one party knowingly entered into a prior legal and existing marriage before entering into the current marriage
in most jurisdictions, its grounds for annulment + grounds for divorce
in a fault-based divorce, what is imprisonment?
if for a specified period of time
in a fault-based divorce, what is indignity?
one spouse exhibits negative behavior to the other that renders that spouse’s condition intolerable and their life burdensome
most states do NOT recognize as basis for at-fault divorce
in a fault-based divorce, what is institutionalization?
spouse’s insanity or serious mental condition results in spouse being (1) confined to a mental institution for a specified time (2) prior to the commencement of the divorce (3) with no reasonable prospect of discharge or rehab
what is the difference between annulment and divorce?
annulment - voids a marriage as if it had never been valid
divorce - dissolvement of a marriage
what are the defenses to a fault-based divorce?
must be affirmatively plead
- recrimination - both spouses commit a marital wrongful act of like conduct
- unclean hands - common when plaintiff’s own behavior is in question
- connivance - complaining spouse has given consent to participate in the marital wrong
- condonation - party forgives, must have knowledge of the wrongful act and resume martial relations after that knowledge
at common law, once misconduct is forgiven, it can’t be used as grounds for at-fault divorce - collusion - both parites conspired to fabricate grounds for divorce
- provocation - misconduct is due to something the other spouse is doing
- insanity
- consent - consent to desertion or adultery
- justificiation
- religion - FAILS in all jurisidctions
what are the requirements for mediation?
(1) neutral court-appointed mediator who is unbiased
(2) mediator cannot be connected with either party
can assist with child support, custody, visitation, parenting time, etc.
parties submit settlement agreement to court
once a dissolution is granted, what happens next?
most states require a certain period of time to lapse before the divorce is finalized
what are the two ways to divide property?
community property
equitable distribution (most states)
what is a community property division?
presumes equal distribution of marital property
what is an equitable distribution?
focus on fair and just distribution of marital property, not necessarily in equal division
most states
in general, what property is considered martial property?
- all property acquired during the marriage
- NOT prop acquired before marriage
- NOT gifts and inheritance (except gifts b/t spouses)
- NOT prop acquired after separation
- NOT prop excluded via valid agreement
- NOT any award/settlement payment from a cause of action before the marriage, regardless of when payment was received
when separating property, who has the burden of proof?
party asserting property is non marital
are gifts between spouses marital property?
yes
are increases in the value of separate property considered marital property?
yes - resulting from either spouse’s efforts
improvement due to marital property funds is also marital property
is property acquired before the marriage martial property?
no
are professional licenses/degrees martial property?
not a property interest that can be distributed
may affect spousal support or distribution of asserts
is property that a party has sold or granted or conveyed for value martial property?
no, if in good faith before date of final separation
what factors are considered for distribution of marital property?
- length of marriage
- whether any prior marriages
- economic circumstances of each spouse
- health, earnings, age, earning potentail, liabilites, needs
- contirbutions to education or career advancement of other spouse
- needs for future acquisitions
- value of any separate property
- custodianship of any minor children
- standard of living
are retirement or pension benefits considered marital property?
yes if acquired during the marriage
looks at present value not FV of pension
for pensions, part that accrued prior to the marriage is nonmarital, but part during the marriage is marital
what are the two approaches for determining if personal injury claim proceeds are marital property?
- marital property approach - if cause of action occurred during marriage, it’s marital property even if proceeds received later
- separate and marital allocation - depends on nature of award
pain and suffering, disability award –> separate, prop of injured spouse
lost wages, income, med expenses –> marital property
are consortium claims marital property?
separate property of the non-injured spouse
compensates spouse for decline of marriage from personal injury claim
is the goodwill of a business considered marital property?
yes if developed during the marriage
must be part of the biz and independent of the idv
are accumulated sick and vacay days marital property?
split juris, depends on how/when accrued
are social security benefits marital property?
not subject to equitable distribution
are unexercised stock options marital property?
if acquired during the marriage, yes even if exercised after divorce