Property 5: Grant of a Lease and Underlease Flashcards
Leases disadvantages for landlords
□ Tenant may be unreliable/not pay rent
□ Tenant might not take care of premises=depreciation of investment
□ Income/capital not guaranteed, dependent on state of property market
Leases disadvantages for tenants
□ Depreciating asset
□ No visible return
□ Landlord probs retain control and specify what tenant can do
□ Repairing obligations=expenditure
Leases advantages landlord?
□ Positive covs easily enforced against subsequent owners in freehold land
□ Retain interest in freehold (asset)
□ Retain control of management=ensure value preserved
□ Can recover all expenditure (service charge)
□ Steady income
Leases advantages tenant?
□ Flexible-short term
□ Can negotiate break clause to terminate before end of fixed term
□ No capital outlay (but may need to pay capital sum (premium) at start)
□ Business capital not tied up in premises
What do the prescribed clauses contain in a typical commercial lease?
Summary of important details in lease and info needed by LR to complete registration
What type of leases are the prescribed clauses contain in a typical commercial lease relevant to?
□ after 19 June 2006
□ Granted from registered land
□ Compulsorily registrable
What will the commencement of the lease detail in a typical commercial lease?
*Starts with ‘this lease’
*Date of grant
*Names/addresses of parties
*Registered: LR heading at top of 1st page
What are the ‘interpretations’ and ‘grant of lease’ for in a typical commercial lease?
Interpretation (definitions)
Grant of the Lease (operative part)
What are ancillary rights in a typical commercial lease?
Tenants rights over other land enabling them to use property better
eg. Lease of part will contain to use common reception areas
What are ‘Rights excepted and reserved’ in a typical commercial lease?
rights in favour of landlord
What will a typical commercial lease contain?
- Prescribed clauses
- Commencement
- Interpretation (definitions)
- Grant of the Lease (operative part)
- Ancillary rights
- Rights excepted and reserved
- Annual rent
- Rent review
- Tenants covenants
- Landlords right to enter on breach and repair covenant
- Re entry and forfeiture
What is a Self help/Jervis v Harris clause?
Allows landlord to recover cost of repairs as a debt NOT a damages claim so can avoid statutory limitation on pursuing damages claims:
1. LL can enter property to check compliance with tenants repair covenant
2. If breach, serve notice specifying works needed to remedy
3. If T fails to start work within specified period or is not proceeding diligently with works, landlord may enter, carry out works and recover costs from tenant
What are the options for term of a lease?
- Fixed term: lease automatically expires at end of fixed term (may have a break clause)
- Periodic tenancy: continues indefinatley from period to period until party gives notice
- Tenancy at will: Tenant occupies indefinitely with permission of landlord on terms that tenancy may be terminated by either party at any time
Notice length to end a periodic tenancy?
length of 1 period of lease EXCEPT yearly=6mo notice
Why are tenancy at wills not good for commercial tenants
uncertain
What are the types of leasehold covenant?
- Absolute: Tenant CANNOT do stated action according to lease
- Qualified: Tenant CAN with landlord consent
- Fully qualified: Tenant CAN with landlord consent which cannot be unreasonably witheld
What is a full Repairing and insuring lease (FRI)
Protect landlord from incurring any expenditure that cant be recovered from tenant =landlord gets clear rental stream
Repair: which parts of the building are tenants and landlords normally responsible for?
Tenant: non-structural parts of building
Landlord: structural parts and common areas
How do landlords normally pass the cost of repair to tenants in lease of part?
service charge
Must there be disrepair before a tenant has to repair?
Yes, physical condition deteriorated from previous physical condition
Repair covs: does the prop need to be kept in perfect repair?
No, just render it fit for occupation of a reasonably minded tenant of the class likely to take it
Is repair the same as renewal?
No, repair is restoration by renewal/replacement of parts/whole not renewal/replacement of whole
Q of fact-nature/age of prop at date of lease
Repair cov: does a tenant have to give back landlord a prop ‘wholly different’ from that leased to them
No but can oblige tenant to remedy an inherent defect in design/construction if the only way is repair
Repair covenants: What does ‘keep’ in repair also mean?
‘put’ into repair
What does ‘keep in good condition’ mean
may have to do work even if no disrepair
When the landlord is ensured, what should the tenant check?
that they’re not responsible for repairing damage arising as a result of insured risks
Who is normally responsible for insuring the property?
*Letting of whole-tenant could be solely responsibly
*BUT more common to use Multi occupation method -where landlord insures with cost passed to tenant as separate insurance rent
Insurance: what are ‘insured risks’?
Inclusive list of risks landlord must insure against
What is it common to end a list of insured risks with?
‘such other risks as the landlord may reasonably require’ (as may insure against unlikely/expensive risks and new ones aren’t covered )
What value should a property be insured to?
‘full reinstatement value’ (will inc cost of demolition, site clearance, professional fees, allowance for inflation)
What covenants will ususally be in insurance for commercial property?
*Covenant by the tenant to pay for the insurance policy (usually as sum reserved as rent for policy and loss of rent if tenant unable to use)
*Covenant by landlord to use insurance proceeds to reinstate the property
What is a rent suspension provision in insurance of commercial property?
Suspends rent during period prop cant be occupied following insured risks (or would continue to be payable)
Why will a landlord normally be happy to include a rent suspension clause
Because they ensure against loss of rent (however, this is normally limited to 3y so landlord may try to limit rent suspension accordingly)
Insurance: Why may a termination provision be included?
Because otherwise, lease will only be frustrated in exceptional circumstances=lease will often give landlord right to terminate lease if reinstatmenet impossible
Tenant should try and insure they have the same right
What is the interplay between the landlord’s insurance covenants and the tenant’s repair covenant?
*Landlord should be able to use insurance proceeds to reinstate property, the premium having already been recovered from the tenant as rent.
*Wont receive rent whilst reinstatement taking palce but will get equivelent sum under loss of rent insurance policy also paid for by T
Why will a landlord want an alterations covenant in the lease?
Because in the absence of alterations covenant, tenant can make any changes it wants
What are absolute covenants against alterations commonly used for?
structural and exterior alterations
Does an absolute covenant against alterations mean the tenant cant do absolutely anything?
No, s3 LTA: tenant of business premises can carry out ‘improvements’ even if lease contains absolute prohibition:
1. serve notice on LL w proposals
2. LL has 3mo to object and if they do court can authorise improvements if:
*add to letting value
*reasonable and suitable for character
*dont diminish value of LL other props
OR Landlord can offer to carry out works for reasonable increase in rent
Under s3 LTA if the landlord offers to carry out the work in a reasonable time, is the tenant obliged to accept?
No, may withdraw notice BUT then court cant give tenant authority to do the work itself
Why may a landlord include a qualified/fully qualified covenant against alterations?
Do they can retain control by imposing conditions about how works are done and if they’ll need to be removed and prop reinstated at end of term
Where are qualified/fully qualified covenant against alterations normally set out and who drafts and pays for it?
Seperate doc called a licence to alter (doc setting out consent/conditions to consent)
Normally drafted by landlords solicitors at tenants cost
Will landlord normally allow demountable partitioning without their consent?
Yes
What improvements can a tenant usually claim compensation for and how?
*Tenant using s3 can claim compensation for improvements at and of term that ‘add to letting value of holding’
*Must claim within statutory time limits
Why are landlords unlikely to restrict user to a single use and what will they do instead?
Might put off tenant and depress rent on rent review
SO may use qualified cov to keep use within 1 use category
Are there statutory implication that landlords consent cannot be unreasonably withheld for user covenants
No
Can a landlord charge fine or increase rent as condition of giving consent for change of use?
No (provided no structural alteration involved)
What is alienation?
Generic term inc diff ways of creating an interest in the prop for benefit of a 3rd party
Why will a landlord usually insist on restrictions in lease against tenants dealing with leasehold interest?
Because in the absence of restriction in lease, tenant can dispose of interest in anyway they like
What type of covenant regarding alienation is contained within most leases?
absolute covenant against all types of alienation but permit certain types of alienation on controlled terms
What does alienation include/types of alienation?
- Assignment
- Underletting
- Charging (mortgaging)
- Sharing occupation (eg. licence)
- Parting with possession