Paper 3 Flashcards
Hazelwood (1980)
First made the distinction between organised and disorganised offenders
▪︎organised= planned, intelligent, removes weapon, married or family, charming
▪︎disorganised= unplanned, low intelligence, leaves evidence, poor employment, lives alone
Jackson (1997)
Top down approach
Criteria that enabled the FBI to make a profile
1) data assimilation
2) crime classification
3) crime reconstruction
4) profile generation
Canter et al (2004)
Top down profiling
Argued it was oversimplification to reduce crimibals to organised and disorganised
Canter etc al (2004)
Bottom up approach
Aim to produce offender profiles on objective data
1) interpersonal coherence
2) time and place
3) criminal career
4) forensic awareness
Canter and young (2000)
Geographical profiling
Identified the principles of geographical profiling
1) locatedness
2) crime location choice
3) centrality
4) comparative case analysis
John Duffy- railway rapist (case study)
Geographical profiling
Used David canters profile to identify killer. Produced and incorrect profile but Elements still helped to identify Duffy
Aims of custodial sentencing
1) incapacitating
2) rehabilitation
3) retribution
4) deterrence
》individual
》society
What is Free Will
The idea that we play an active role and have a choice how we behave.
We are self determined
What is determinism?
The view the free will is an illusion and our behaviour is governed by internal and external forces out of our control.
How do Twin Studies contradict free will
Monozygotic twins have an 80% similarity in intelligence and 40% in depression.
Suggests only 20% is other factors/ “free will”
Mobeley
limitation of determinism
Argued he was “born to kill, as his family had a disposition to violence.
so determinism provides and excuse for crime.
Libet et al
free will limitation
Argues free will is an illusion
Found motor regions become active before a person has conscious awareness
Biological determinism defintion
The idea that all behaviour is innate and determined by genes
Environmental determinism
Behaviour is caused by external forces and previous experience (link to mowrer conditioning)
Psychic Determinism
Behaviour is a result of childhood experiences and innate drives (links to Freud tripartite model)
Soft determinism
Behaviour is constrained by environment or genetics but only to a certain extent
Hard determinism
Incompatible with free will as forces shape our behaviour