paper 1 -2022 Flashcards

1
Q

define obedience

A

a form of social influence in which an individual follows a direct order.
the person issuing the order is usually a figure of authority, who had the power to punish when obedient behavior is not forthcoming

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

what did Milgram aim to study

A

obedience

to understand why such a high population obeyed hitler

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Milgrams baseline procedures

A

40 American men - volunteer sample -though they were randomly given a role
pair with a confederates who acted as the learner within the experiment
instructed by an experimenter (grey lab coat) - shock learner when they answer wrong
volts increased after each shock - 15volts to 450 volts
told the confederate had heart condition before beginning
confederate never shocked

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

what % did Milgram psychology student predict would go to 450volts

A

3% - 450volts

14 psychology students

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

what % of participants ended up going to 450volts

A

12.5% - 300volts (5 participants)

65% - 450 volts

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

what type of findings did Milgram find

A

65% - 450volts
qualitative date - interview + observation
observation = signs of extreme tension, sweating, biting lip, groaning (3 seizures)
interviews = 84% said they were glad they participated

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

what did Milgram conclude

A

German people in ww2 - weren’t different

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

a strength of Milgram’s study - research support

A

replicated in French documentary - made about reality tv
participants believed that were on a game show’s pilot episode
paid to give fake shocks to other participants who were actors
80% went to max shock of 450volts to an “unconscious” man
behavior identical to Milgram’s participants - sweating nail biting
therefore result are not due to special circumstances

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

weakness - Milgram - low internal validity

A

may not test what was intended
75% participants believed shocks were real (Milgram stated)
psychologists argue that participants believe they behaved that way as they were play acting
when listening to Milgram’s tapes - only half believed it was real and 2/3 of participants were disobedient
therefore participants were responding to demand characteristics

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

counterpoint to low internal validity - Milgram evaluation

A

a study conducted like Milgram’s - but puppies were shocked instead
gave real shocks
54% of male students 100% female students delivered the shock - when they though it was fatal
this suggests that Milgram’s finding are correct as people behave the same way when shocks are real

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

weakness - Milgram - ethical implications

A

deception - lied about it being a real shock, participant was a confederate, heart condition
participant harm - 3 seizures and clear signs of distress
social sensitivity

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

define situational variables

A

features of the immediate physical and social environment which may influence a person’s behavior.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

what situational variables did Milgram study

A

proximity
uniform
location

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

why did Milgram study situational variables

A

to see if they led to more or less obedience

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

situational variable - proximity results

A

teacher and learner in the same room = obedience dropped form 65% to 40%
touch proximity - move their hand onto the electric plate = dropped to 30%
remote instruction variation - experimenter in another room, instructed through telephone
= obedience dropped to 20.5% and participants pretended to give shocks

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

situational variable - proximity explanation

A

decreased proximity allows people to psychologically distance themselves from the consequences of their actions.
e.g. less aware of the harm they course the learner when they were separated

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

situational variable - location findings

A

obedience dropped to 47.5% from 65%

when the experiment was conducted in a rundown office building instead of at Yale university

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

situational variable - location explanation

A

prestigious university gave legitimacy and authority to Milgram’s study
so more likely to obey in this location as they saw the experimenter as sharing this legitimate and thought obedience was expected
however obedience in the office was still high in the office block because of the perceived scientific nature of the procedure

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

situational variable - uniform findings

A

baseline = experimenters wore a grey lab coat as a symbol of authority

experimenter called away because of an inconvenient telephone call at the start of the experiment - replaces with an ordinary member of the public (confederate in normal clothes)
obedience dropped to the lowest rate of 20%

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

situational variable - uniform explanation

A

uniforms encourage obedience - widely recognized as symbols of authority
we accept that someone in an uniform is entitled to obedience as their authority is legitimate
someone without an uniform is less right to expect our obedience

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

strength of situational variables - research support

A

other studies have demonstrated the influence of situational variable on obedience.
field experiment in NYC - had 3 confederate dress up 1 milkman 1 in suit and 1 security guard
all 3 confederates stood in street and ask individual to pick up litter/ put a coin in parking meters.
people x2 likely to help the security guard than the one in the suit
therefore support situational variables, such as uniform, effect obedience

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

strength of situational explanation - cross-cultural replications

A

other psychologists create a more realistic version of Milgram’s experiment on Dutch participants. - participant ordered to say stressful things to (confederate) someone desperate for a job.
90% of participants obeyed and also replicated Milgram’s findings concerning proximity. - obedience decreased when the person giving instructions wasn’t present
this suggest that the findings are not limited to American males, but is valid across cultures and genders

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

limitation of situational variables - low internal validity

A

participants may have been aware that the procedures were fake.
psychologists have criticized Milgram’s baseline procedures - but suggest that it is even more likely in the variables because of the extra manipulation of variables e.g. when a member of the public replaced the experimenter.
and even Milgram recognized that this situation is so contrived that some participants may have worked out the truth.
therefore in all of Milgram’s studies it is unclear if the findings are because of obedience or demand characteristics and play acting

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

define agentic state

A

a mental state where we feel no personal responsibility for our behavior because we believe ourselves to be acting for an authority figure. this frees us from the demands of our conscience and allows us to obey even a destructive authority figure.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
what is an agent
is someone who acts for or in place of another. experience high levels of anxiety / moral strain when they realize what they are doing is wrong feel powerless to disobey
26
what is the autonomous state
is a state when an individual is independent or free | behave according to their own principles and feel a sense of responsibility their own actions
27
what is the agentic shift
the shift from autonomy to agency | when an authority figure has greater power or higher position in the social hierarchy instructs them - course shift
28
what are binding factors and how do they effect the agentic shift
Milgram observed how participant want to stop but didn't, so suggested binding factors. an aspect of a situation that allows the individual to ignore the damaging effects of their behavior and reduce moral strain . for example, shift the responsibility onto the victim or deny the damage coursed to the victim
29
strength of agentic state theory - research support
studies support that the agentic state has a role in obedience most of Milgram's participants resisted giving shocks at some point but asked questions to the experimenter about the procedures p="who is responsible if he is hurt" E= "I'm responsible" after participants often went through the procedure quickly with no further objections. this shows that once the participant is no longer responsible for their actions they acted more easily as the experimenter agent, as Milgram suggests
30
weakness of the agentic state - limited explanation
the agentic state doesn't explain many research findings about obedience for example, one study found that 16 out of 18 nurses disobeyed orders from a doctor when told to administer an excessive drug dose to a patient. the doctor was an authority figure but all nurses stayed in an autonomous state. therefore the agentic shift can only account for certain situations of obedience.
31
define legitimacy of authority
an explanation for obedience which suggests that we are more likely to obey people who we perceive to have authority over us. this authority justified by the individual's position of power within a social hierarchy.
32
legitimacy of authority
society is structure with a social hierarchy- so people in certain position hold authority over us. authority weighs legitimacy as it is agreed upon within society. accepted that authority figures are allowed to excessive power over other as it allow society to run smoothly.
33
what is a consequence of legitimacy of authority
some people are granted the power to punish others | this can led to destructive authority
34
what is a destructive authority
a powerful leader that uses their legitimate authority for destructive purposes, ordering people to behave in cruel and dangerous ways e.g. hitler, stalin or pol pot this type of leader is clear in Milgram's experiment, as participant behavior went against their consciences
35
strength of legitimacy of authority - explains cultural differences
many studies have shown that different countries differ in the degree to which people obey authority. - Milgram-style studies 16% of Australian participants went to 450volts 85% of German participants went to 450volts this shows that in some cultures authority is more likely to be legitimate and entitled to demand obedience from individuals. this also reflects how differ cultures raise children to perceive authority figures.
36
weakness of legitimacy of authority - cannot explain all disobedience
cannot explain disobedience within the hierarchy when authority is clear and accepted rank and Jacobson's -16/18 nurses refused to give a lethal dose to patients when instructed to do so by a doctor, a clear authority figure. also a minority of Milgram's participants (5) disobeyed despite recognizing the experiencers scientific authority. this suggest that some people are less/ more likely to obey and it is possible that innate tendency may greater influence on behavior than legitimacy of authority.
37
define authoritarian personality
a type of personal that Adorno argues was especially susceptible to obeying people in authority . such individuals are also thought to be submissive to those of higher status and dismissive of inferiors
38
define dispositional explanation
any explanation of behavior that highlights the importance of the individual's personality.
39
what dispositional explanation tries to explain obedience
authoritarian personality
40
who suggest the authoritarian personality explanation to obedience
Adorno et al
41
why did Adorno what to study obedience
to understand anti-Semitism
42
authoritarian personality characteristics
extreme respect for authority view society as weaker than it was - so need strong leaders to enforce traditional values likely to follow orders from an external source of authority show contempt for weaker members of society fueled by an inflexible view of the world - no grey area
43
origins of the authoritarian personality
forms in childhood as a result of harsh parenting parenting style = strict disciplines, expectation of absolute loyalty, impossibly high standards and severe criticism of perceived failing. conditional love - depends solely on how they behave childhood experience of resentment and hostility that they cant express to parents due to a fear of punishment. - displace fear onto weaker people (scapegoating) psychodynamic explanation
44
Adorno's research - procedures
2000 - middle class white Americans participants studied their unconscious attitudes to racial groups developed serval measures scales - including the potential-for-fascism scale (F-scale) example Q's of the F-scale - obedience and respect for authority are the most important virtues for children to learn.
45
Adorno's research - findings
people with authoritarian leanings identified with strong people and were generally contemptuous of the weak ( scored high on the scale) very conscious of status and showed extreme respect for people in high status had a certain cognitive style - no crossovers between categories of people and distinctive stereotypes about other groups found a positive correlation between authoritarian personality and prejudice
46
strength of the authoritarian personality - research support
elms and Milgram interviewed a small sample of people who had participated in the ordinal obedience studies who had been fully obedient - completed the f-scale these 20 participants scored significantly high on the overall f-scale than a comparative 20 disobedient group of participants 2 groups clearly different in terms of authoritarianism support Adorno's view that obedient people have very similar characteristics to people with authoritarian personalities
47
counterpoint to research support - Adorno's research
researchers analyzed the individual subscales of the f-scale found that the obedient participants had a number of characteristics that were unusual for authoritarians e.g. didn't usually glorify their fathers, didn't experience high levels of punishment in childhood and didn't have hostile emotions towards their mothers this means that the link between obedience and authoritarianism is complex. - participants not authoritarian - unlikely to be a useful predictor of obedience
48
weakness of the authoritarian personality - limited explanation
authoritarianism cannot explain obedience behavior in the majority of a country's population. e.g. prewar Germany million of people showed obedience to racist and anti-Semitic despite them all having different personalities seems unlikely that they could all possess an authoritarian personality an alternative view is that they could identified with the anti-Semitic Nazi state and scapegoated the outgroup of Jews, a social identity theory approach therefore limited and alternative explanation is much more realistic
49
define resistance to social influence
refers to the ability of people to withstand the social pressure to conform to the majority or to obey authority. this ability to withstand social pressure is influenced by both situational and dispositional factors
50
define social support
the presence of people who resist pressures to conform or obey can help others to do the same. these people act as models to show others that resistance to social influence is possible
51
define locus of control
refers to the sense we each have about what directs events in our lives.
52
social support - resistance to conformity
pressure to conform can be resisted if there people present not conforming. Asch - confederate not conforming this person provides social support enabling the naïve participant to follow their own consciousness confederate - acts as a model of independent behavior there dissent leds to more - as shows the majority is not longer unanimous
53
social support - resisting obedience
pressure to obey can be resisted if another person disobeys Milgram - 65% to 10% when there was a disobedient confederate don't follow the disobedient behavior but the disobedient person acts as a model of dissent to copy and this allows him to act on his consciousness disobedient model challenges the legitimacy of the authority - make it easy for more to disobey
54
strength of social support - real world research support
research support for the positive effect of social support teen fresh start USA - an 8 week program to help pregnant adolescents (14-19) resist the pressure to smoke social support provided through a buddy/mentor at the end of the study those with a buddy were significantly less likely to smoke than the control group without a buddy this show that social support can help young people resist social influence as part of an intervention in the real world
55
strength of social support - research support for dissenting peers
evidence support the role of dissenting peers in resisting obedience Gamson et al - participants tole to produce evidence that would be used to help an oil company run a smear campaign. found higher levels of resistance than in Milgram's study -88% rebelled against their orders this could be because participants were in a group so could discuss this shows that peer support can led to disobedience by undermining the legitimacy of an authority figure.
56
locus of control
internal control vs external control. | psychologist = Rotter et al
57
locus of control continuum
people are not just either external or internal LOC is scale and people vary where they are positioned on it high internal LOC one end and high external LOC on the other
58
resistance to social influence - LOC
people with high internal LOC are more able pressure to conform and obey. take responsibility for there actions and experiences - also tend base their decision on their own beliefs another explanation - people with high internal LOC are more self confidence, more achievement orientated and have higher intelligence these trait led to greater resistance to social influence theses are also traits of leaders who need much less social approval.
59
strength of LOC - research support
research evidence to support the link between LOC and resistance to obedience Holland - repeated Milgram's baseline study and measures if participants had internal or external LOC. found = 37% of internal didn't continue to 450 volts whereas only 23% of externals didn't. this shows that internal have a greater resistance to authority in this situation. therefore, resistance is partly linked to LOC and increases the validity of LOC as an explanation.
60
Weakness of LOC - contradictory research
evidence that challenges the link between LOC and resistance. analyzed data from American LOC studies conducted over 40 years period the data showed that people came more resistant to obedience but also more external over this time period. this show that resistance may not be linked to LOC as people should have become more internal. this suggests that locus of control is not a valid explanation of how people resist social influence
61
define minority influence
a form of social influence in which a minority of people persuades others to adopt their beliefs, attitudes or behaviors. leads to internalization or conversion, in which private attitudes are changed as well as public behavior.
62
what are the 3 factors course minority influence
consistency commitment flexibility
63
consistency - minority influence
when the minority keeps the same believe both over time and between all the individuals that form the minority. is effective as it draws attention to the minority view. synchronic consistency = between people diachronic consistency = overtime start to make people rethink their own beliefs
64
commitment - minority influence
minority demonstrates dedication to their position by making personal sacrifices this is effective as it show the minority is not acting out of self-interest augmentation principle = majority members pay more attention because of the risks they take
65
flexibility - minority influence
relentless consistency counter-productive as it can be seen as unreasonable and unbending. therefore minority influence is more effective if they show flexibility through the possibility of compromise. key is to strict balance between consistency and flexibility by changing when presented with a valid counterargument
66
explaining the process of change - minority influence
3 factors led to people thinking about the minorities views or cause hear something new = think deeply about especially with the 3 factors deeper process which is important in the process conversion - converted when they switch to the minority view. faster rate of conversion is the snowball effect. - leading the minority view slowly becoming the majority.
67
strength of minority influence - research evidence for consistency
research demonstrating the importance of consistency Moscovici's blue/green slide study - showed that a consistent minority had greater effect on changing views than an inconsistent option. meta-analysis conducted of almost 100 similar studies and found that minority that were consistent were most influential this suggests that presenting a consistent view is a minimum requirement for a minority trying to influence the majority.
68
strength of minority influence - research support for deeper processing
evidence showing that a change in the majority's position does involve deeper processing of the minority's ideas. study = presented a message supporting a particular viewpoint and measured participants agreement. one group heard minority agree and second heard a minority agree, then both exposed to a conflicting view and there agreement was measured again. found people were less likely to change their view if they heard the minority groups view. this suggests that the minority view had been deeper processed and had more enduring effects, supporting the view of the central argument about minority influence
69
short term memory - capacity, coding and duration
``` capacity = 7 +/- 2 coding = acoustically duration = around 18 seconds ```
70
long term memory - capacity, coding, duration
``` capacity = unlimited coding = semantically duration = up to a lifetime ```
71
define coding
the format in which information is stored in the various memory stores
72
define capacity
the amount of information that can be held in a memory store
73
define duration
the length of time information can be held in memory
74
multi store model diagram
``` stimulus from environment sensory resistor - store attention STM - store prolonged rehearsal (+response) LTM maintenance rehearsal (+ retrieval) ```
75
define the multi - store model of memory
a representation how memory works in terms of three stores called the sensory register, short term memory and long term memory. it also describes how information is transferred from one store to another and what makes some memories disappear.
76
sensory register store
any stimulus in the environment passes information into the SR comprised of the 5 senses making coding in this store modality - specific coded = visual = iconic memory acoustically - echoic memory capacity = very high duration = less than half a second
77
short term memory store
once attention is given to something in the sensory resistor it is passed into the STM coded = acoustically duration = 18 seconds (unless rehearsed) capacity = 7 +/- 2 information can be moved from LTM to STM store with retrieval
78
maintenance rehearsal
occurs when we repeat material to ourselves multiple times by repeating it we can keep information in the short term memory or if repeated enough information is passed to LTM store
79
long-term memory
information moves to LTM store with prolonged rehearsal coded = semantically duration = up to a lifetime capacity = unlimited
80
strength of MSM - research support
support from studies showing that the STM and LTM are different e.g. Baddeley - mix up words that are acoustically similar when using our STM but mix up words that are semantically similar if using our LTM this led to the conclusion that they are separate stores as they are encoded differently further studies show that STM and LTM also have different capacity and duration Therefore, studies also highlight that STM and LTM are separate stores
81
weakness of MSM - more than one STM store
evidence of more than one store for STM psychologists studied a client referred as KF who had a clinical memory disorder called amnesia they found KF's STM for digits was very poor when they read them aloud to him but had much better recall when reading digits for himself. further studies on KF found that there may even be a STM store for non-verbal sounds therefore evidence suggest the MSM is incorrect when it states there is one STM store processing different types of information
82
weakness of MSM - elaborative rehearsal
prolonged rehearsal is not needed for transfer to LTM MSM suggest that the more you rehearse something the more likely it is to transfer into the LTM. however, studies have found that the type of rehearsal is more important than the amount. Elaborate rehearsal is needed for LT storage - this occurs when we link new information to existing knowledge. this means that information can be transferred to LTM without prolonged rehearsal. this means that the MSM doesn't fully explain how long term storage is achieved
83
define episodic memory
a long term memory store for personal events. it includes memories of when the events occurred and of the people, objects, places and behavior involved. memories in this store have to be retrieved consciously and with effort
84
define sematic memory
a long term memory store for our knowledge of the world. This includes facts and our knowledge of what words and concepts mean. these memories usually also need to be recalled deliberately.
85
define procedural memory
a long term memory store for our knowledge of how to do things. this includes our memories of learned skills. we usually recall these memories without making a conscious or deliberate effort.
86
define working memory model
a representation of short term memory. it suggests that STM is a dynamic processor of different types of information using subunits coordinated by a central decision - making system
87
working memory model
Baddeley and Hitch explanation of how STM is organized and how it functions is concerned with that mental space is active when we are temporality storing and manipulating information the model has 4 main components each qualitatively different - especially in terms of coding and capacity
88
central executive
supervisory role focus and divided our limited attention allocates slave systems to tasks capacity = very limited and doesn't store any information
89
phonological loop
1 of the slave systems - in charge of acoustic information preserves the order in which the information arrives in subdivided into the phonological store and articulatory process
90
phonological store
a component of the phonological store which acts as an inner ear by storing words you hear
91
articulatory process
allows maintenance rehearsal by repeating words or sound in a loop to keep them in the working memory whilst they are needed capacity of the loop is 2 seconds worth what you can say
92
visuo-spatail sketchpad
second slave system stores visual and/ or spatial information when required e.g. how many window are on your house - visualize it capacity = Baddeley suggest 3 to 4 objects Logie subdivided the VSS into visual cache and inner scribe
93
visual cache
stores visual information, such as the arrangement of objects
94
inner scribe
records the arrangement of objects in the visual field
95
episodic buffer
temporary stores information, integrating the visual spatial and verbal information processed by other stores and maintaining the sense of time sequencing basically the record of events storage component of the central executive and has a limited capacity of 4 chunks (Baddeley's research) links the WMM to LTM and other cognitive processes
96
strength of WMM - clinical evidence
support from a case studied conducted on patient KF who suffered from Amnesia. after his brain injury - poor STM ability to store auditory information but could process visual information normally. example - immediate recall of letter and digits he read himself was better than when other read them to him. this suggest that KF's phonological loop was damage but his visuo- spatial sketchpad was intact support the existing of separate visual and acoustic memory stores
97
counterpoint to clinical evidence - WMM
unclear is KF had other cognitive impairments which might have affected his performance on memory. for example, his injury was caused by a motorcycle accident, so the trauma may have effected the performance of other cognitive processes apart from brain injury. this challenges evidence that comes from clinical studies of people with brain injuries that may have be affected many different systems
98
strength of WMM - Dual task performance
studies of dual- task performance support the separate existence of the visuo - spatial sketchpad Baddeley = participants carried out visual and verbal tasks at the same time, their performance of both task was similar to when they carried them out separately however when both task were visual or verbal the performance on both declined substantially. this could be because both visual task was using the same slave subsystem whereas there was no competition when visual and verbal tasks where competed together this shows there may be separate slave systems that processes visual input and one for verbal processes
99
Weakness of WMM - nature of the central executive
lack of clarity over the nature if the central executive Baddeley - recognized this and stated that the central executive is the most important but least understood component of the WMM CE needs to be more clearly specified than just being simply attention, for example some psychologist that it may have subcomponents this means that the CE is an unsatisfactory component and this challenges the integrity of the WMM
100
define cognitive interview
a method of interviewing eyewitnesses to help them retrieve more accurate memories.
101
the cognitive interview - development / beginning
fisher and Geiselman argued that eyewitness testimony could be improved if the police used better techniques when interviewing thus developed cognitive interviews
102
report everything
witnesses are encouraged to state every detail they remember of the event even if they see it as irrelevant or they don't feel confident about it gain trivial detail that may become important and help trigger over memories
103
reinstate the content
witness return to the original crime scene in their mind by imagining the environment and their emotions this relates to context - dependent forgetting
104
content related forgetting
recall depends on external cues e.g. weather or a place | Tulving - retrieval failure due to the absent of cues
105
reverse the order
events recalled in a different order from the original sequence - end at beginning or start in the middle help prevent people reporting their expectations of how the event must have happened rather than reporting actual events - prevents dishonesty
106
change perspective
witnesses should recall events the incident from other peoples perspective e.g. other witnesses or the perpetrator's done to disrupt the effect of expectations and the effect of schema on recall schema you have for a particular setting generate expectations of what would have happened and it is the schema that is recalled rather than what actually happened
107
the enhanced cognitive interview
Fisher et al additional elements of the CI to focus on the social dynamic of the interaction interviews need to know when to establish eye contact and when to remove it included ideas on - eyewitness anxiety, minimizing distractions, getting witnessed to speak slowly, and asking open-ended questions
108
strength of CI - support for the effectiveness
evidence that it works meta-analysis combined data from 55 studies comparing CI and standard police interviews CI gave an average 41% increase in accurate information compared to standard interviews only 4 studies showed no difference between the interview techniques this show that CI is an effective technique in helping witnesses to recall information that is stored in memory but is not immediately accessible
109
counterpoint for support of effectiveness of the CI
however same psychologist also found an increase in the amount of inaccurate information recalled by participants particular an issue with ECI which produced more inaccurate detail than CI CI and ECI may sacrifice quality in favor for quantity this means that police officers should treat eyewitness evidence from CI / ECI with caution
110
weakness of CI - some elements may be more useful
in original CI not all elements are equally effective or useful was found that each of the 4 techniques used alone produced more information than the standard police interview. but also found only using only resistant context and report everything produced better recall than any other combination of the 4 techniques this confirmed police officers suspicions that some aspects of CI are more useful than others this also casts doubt on the creditability of the overall CI
111
weakness of CI - time consuming
police officers may be reluctant to use CI because it takes more time and needs more specialist training than standard police interviews e.g. need time to establish a rapport with the witness and allow them to relax CI also requires specialist training that some forces may not have the resources or time to provide towards it. this suggests that the complete CI as it exists is not a realistic method for police officers to use and it might be better to focus on just a few key elements
112
define reciprocity
a description of how two people interact. caregiver - infant interaction is reciprocal in that both caregiver and baby respond to each other's signals and each elicits a response from the other
113
define interactional synchrony
caregiver and baby reflect both the actions and emotions of the other and do this in a coordinated way
114
Lorenz - procedures
aim to research imprinting randomly divided a large clutch of goose eggs - half hatched with the mother goose and the other half hatched in an incubator and the first moving thing they saw was Lorenz
115
Lorenz - findings
incubator group followed Lorenz everywhere whereas the control group followed the mother goose. when the groups where mixed the experimental group continue to follow Lorenz. imprinting = birds that are mobile from birth attach to and follow the first moving object they see this led to Lorenz identify the critical period - time period where imprinting need to take place in. critical period - 4 to 25 hours after hatching - if it doesn't take place the chicks didn't attach themselves to a mother figure
116
Lorenz - conclusion
imprinting is a form of attachment that is exhibited in birds that typically leave the nest early, whereby they imprint on the first moving thing they see
117
Harlow's research - Aim
to examine the extent to which contact comfort and food influence attachment behavior in baby rhesus monkeys
118
Harlow's research - procedures
place to surrogate mothers in the monkey cage - 1. harsh wired mother and a second soft toweling mother 16 monkeys + 4 caged conductions 1. wire mother with milk and soft mother without 2. wire mother no milk and soft mother with milk 3. wire mother dispensing milk 4. soft mother dispensing milk timed how long they feed at each one and tested mother preference during a period of stress by making loud noises large cage was also used to observe the degree of exploration
119
Harlow's research - findings
baby monkey's preferred to make contact with the soft toweling mother irrespective of whether if she dispensed milk - stretch across from clinging to the soft mother to feed the wire mother showed signs of distress if only had wire mother - diarrhoea when startled the monkey would cling to the soft mother when she was available. greater levels of exploration with a toweling mother when in the bigger cage - this indicates better emotional security
120
Harlow's research - conclusion
baby rhesus monkeys appear to have an innate drive to seek contact comfort from their parents this suggests that attachment id formed through an emotional need for security rather than food. this contact comfort provided by the mother is associated by a higher willingness to explore their surroundings and lower levels of stress
121
strength of Lorenz research - research support
existence of support for the concept of imprinting chicks were exposed to simple shapes combinations that moved e.g. a triangle in front of a rectangle then a range of combinations were exposed to them but they followed the original most closely. this support the view that young animals are born with an innate mechanism to imprint on a moving object present in the critical window of development, as predicted by Lorenz
122
weakness of Lorenz research - generalizability to humans
lack ability to generalize the finding onto humans due to Lorenz only studying non-human animals. e.g. gooselings and we are unable to conclude that they behave in the same way as humans the attachment formed in mammals appears to be very different from birds species with parents as they show more of a emotional reaction to their offspring. so with mammals attachment may be a two-way process and this may allow them to able to form attachments after a few hours. therefore, Lorenz research has been influential at expanding our understanding of birds attachments but the findings cant be generalized to humans attachments
123
weakness of Lorenz research - later research
later research casts doubts on some of the conclusions drawn from Lorenz research into imprinting. Guiton et al - found that chickens would imprint on a yellow washing up glove if it was first moving object they saw after birth and they would try and mate with this object in adulthood. however he disagreed with Lorenz that this relationship was irreversible since the chickens could learn to mate with other chickens instead. this suggest that imprinting may not be as permanent as initially thought
124
strength of Harlow's research - real-world value
important real-world application for example, can help social workers and clinical psychologist to understand that a lack of bonding experience may be a risk factor in child development allowing them to intervene to prevent poor outcomes we also now understand the importance of attachment figures for baby monkeys in zoos and breeding programs in the wild. this mean that the value of Harlow's research is not just theoretical but also practical.
125
weakness of Harlow's research - generalizability to humans
lack of ability to generalize findings and conclusions from monkeys to humans Rhesus monkeys are mammals meaning they will have a similarities in attachment to humans due to shared common attachment behavior. however the human brain and behavior is more complex than that of monkeys. also psychologists argue to the extent to which studies of animals should be generalize to humans due to these apparent differences
126
weakness of Harlow's research - ethics
(ethical issue doesn't = invalid) heavily criticized for the ethics of his research on rhesus monkeys as the monkeys suffered greatly in terms of emotional separation from their biological mothers at a young age due to the procedures of Harlow. especially if species of primates are considered to be sufficiently human-like to generalize the results beyond the sample used then it stands that the effects of psychological harm that they will endured are similar to human babies. however, there is question if whether the insight provided into attachment by Harlow justified his approach
127
Harlow's research - maternally deprived monkeys as adults
observed the difference between monkeys who grow up with a surrogate mother and those with a normal mother. - they were more timid - they didn't know how to interact with other monkeys and could be aggressive - difficulty in mating - females were inadequate mothers and some even killing their offspring
128
Harlow's research - the critical period for normal development
also found that there was a critical period a mother figure needed to be introduced to a young mother within 90 days for an attachment to be formed after this period attachment was impossible and the damage done by early deprivation becomes irreversible.
129
define monotropic
a term sometimes used to describe Bowlby's theory mono means one and tropic means learning towards this indicates that one particular attachment is different from all others and of central importance to a child's development
130
define critical period
the tome within which an attachment must form if it is to form at all Lorenz and Harlow noted that attachment in birds and monkey had critical periods Bowlby extended the idea to humans, proposing that human babies have a sensitive period after which it will be much more difficult to form an attachment
131
define internal working model
our mental representations of the world e.g. the representation we have of our relationship to our primary attachment figure. this model affect our future relationships because it carriers our perception of what relationship are like
132
name 5 key terms from Bowlby's theory of attachment
``` ( A Snap Chat Makes Images ) Adaptive Social releaser Critical period Monotropy Internal working model ```
133
Bowlby - Adaptive
attachments are adaptive which means they give humans an advantage, making them more likely to survive. if an infant has an attachment, they are kept safe, given food and kept warm by their caregiver
134
Bowlby - social releasers
infants possess inborn social releasers, which unlock an innate tendency in adults to care for them. social releasers are: physical - the typical 'baby face' features that make babies appear cute such as big eyes and a button nose behavior - crying, cooing and smiling to get attention both infants and mothers are hardwired to attach
135
Bowlby - critical period
between 3 and 6 months later acknowledge that infants could form an attachment after this period - up to 3 years of age however the successful formation of an attachment would be increasingly difficult after the initial period attachment didn't form during this time period would be damaged for life - socially, emotionally, intellectually and physically
136
Bowlby - monotropy
infants form one very special attachment with their primary caregiver, most frequently the mother if mother is not available, the infant can bond with another ever-present adult, known as a mother substitute. believed the more time spent with this primary attachment figure the better 2 principles - law of continuity = stated that the more constant and predictable a child's care, the better the quality of attachment - law of accumulated separation = stated that the effects of every separation from the mother adds up add and the safest dose is therefore a zero dose
137
Bowlby - internal working model
through a monotropic attachment an infant forms an internal working model that acts a template for future relationships a strong and healthy attachment with primary attachment figure led to them developing strong and healthy relationships later in life. however a negative relationship with primary attachment will led to negative social and romantic relationships. also affects the Childs later ability to be a parent themselves - children from functional families tend to have similar families themselves
138
weakness of Bowlby's theory of attachment - validity of monotropy challenged
the concept of monotropy lacks validity Schaffer and Emerson = found that although most babies do attach to 1 person at first, a significant minority formed multiple attachments at the same time. also, although the 1st attachment does appear to have a strong influence on later behavior this may simply mean stronger and not necessarily different in quality from the child's other attachments. for example, other attachments to family members also provide all the same key qualities e.g. emotional support. this mean that Bowlby may be incorrect that there is a unique quality and importance to the child's primary attachment.
139
strength - Bowlby - support for social releasers
clear evidence that cute baby behaviors are designed to elicit interactions from caregivers. psychologists observed babies trigger interactions with adults using social releasers. instructed the primary attachment to ignore their babies social releasers. this coursed the babies to become increasingly distressed and some eventually curled up and lay motionless. this illustrates the role of social releasers in emotional development and suggests that they are important in the process of attachment development
140
strength - Bowlby - support for internal working model
the idea of the internal working model predicts that patterns of attachment will be passed from one generation to the next. Hazan and shaver assess the internal working model with a questionnaire called the love quiz and they found a positive correlation between early attachment types and later adult relationships. this supports Bowlby's idea that internal working models exist and influence over later relationships
141
counterpoint - support for internal working model - Bowlby
although Hazer and shavers questionnaire may had some issue with validity, due to its reliance of participants being honest and remembering elements of their childhood correctly. especially since it was a self-repot questionnaire participants may have been affected by social desirability bias coursing them to change their answer to what they believed they should answer with.
142
learning theory - explanation of attachment
cupboard love approach - emphasizes the importance of the attachment figure as a provider of food suggest the infant will be come attached to who ever feeds them
143
explanation of attachment - classical conditioning
process of learning by associating 2 stimuli together to condition a response. food = unconditioned stimulus relief of hunger = unconditioned response caregiver = natural stimulus - leds to no conditioned response associate the caregiver who feeds them with food ^ through repeated pairings the caregiver becomes the conditioned stimulus and leds to a relief in hunger becoming a conditioned response and allowing an attachment to form
144
explanation of attachment - operant conditioning
skinner - studied operant conditioning and saw that non-human animals learned consequences through it when baby is hungry they they have a drive to reduce these unpleasant feelings by crying in order to receive comfort. positive reinforcement = infant crying when hungry as caregiver provides food (reward) thus behavior repeated negative reinforcement = reciprocal process in caregiver when infants stops crying.
145
explanation of attachment - attachment as a secondary drive
primary drive = hunger - innate and biological motivator primary reinforcer = food secondary reinforcer = caregiver secondary drive = attachment - infant will seek the person who feeds them
146
weakness of learning theory- counter-evidence from animal studies
lack of support from studies conducted on animals Lorenz goslings imprinted on the first moving object they saw regardless of whether this object was associated with food. also Harlow's research with monkeys showed no important to food in forming an attachment but highlighted the importance of comfort when the monkeys choose a toweling surrogate mother instead of the hard wire mother provided food. this shows that factors other than food are important in the development of attachments.
147
weakness of learning theory - counter-evidence from studies on humans
lack of support from studies on human babies Schaffer and Emerson found that babies tended to have an attachment with their mothers first regardless of whether is she fed them or not. also Isabella et al found that higher levels of interactional synchrony predicted the quality of the attachment. these factors aren't related to feeding this suggest that food is not the main factor in the formation of human attachments
148
strength of learning theory - some conditions may be involved
element of conditioning could be involved in some aspects of attachment unlikely that association with food plays a central role in attachment but it may still play a role in attachment. for example, babies may associate feeling warm and comfortable with the presence of a particular adult and this may influence the baby's choice of their main attachment figure. this means that learning theory may still ne useful in understanding the development of attachment.
149
counterpoint of learning theory as an explanation of attachment
however both classical and operant conditioning explanations see the baby playing a passive role in attachment development, simply responding to associations with comfort or reward. although research ahs found that babies play a very active role in the interactions that produce attachment and they go through an alert phase were they signal they are ready for spells of interaction. these signals led to mothers picking them up 2/3 of the time. this means that conditioning may not be an adequate explanation of any aspects of attachment.
150
Ainsworth's strange situation - aim
was to be able to observe key attachment behaviors as a means of assessing the quality of a baby's attachment to a caregiver.
151
Ainsworth's strange situation - procedures
controlled observation - designed to measure the security of attachments laboratory - controlled conditions = two-way mirror and camera observed behaviors = proximity seeking, exploration and secure base behavior, stranger anxiety, separation anxiety, response to reunion. 7 stages / episodes each lasting 3 minutes.
152
Ainsworth's strange situation = the 7 stages
1. mother and infant in room - exploration tested - infant left on floor to play 2. stranger enters room and talks to mother - stranger anxiety tested -plays with child 3. mother leaves room and stranger comforts baby - separation and stranger anxiety 4. stranger leaves room and mother returns - reunion behavior 5. mother leaves again - separation anxiety 6. stranger re-enters and offers comfort - stranger anxiety 7. mother return and stranger leaves = reunion behavior
153
Ainsworth's strange situation - findings
secure (type b) =66% insecure - avoidant (type a) = 22% insecure- resistant (type c) = 12%
154
secure attachment + characteristics
exploration = explores environment, return to mother at regular intervals = safe-base moderate separation anxiety = play is disrupted when they leave moderate stranger anxiety = move closer to mother when stranger is present joy on reunion - seek proximity and is easily comforted
155
insecure avoidant attachment + characteristics
exploration = explores the environment and doesn't return to mother low separation anxiety = not concerned low stranger anxiety = unconcerned and little preference reunion behavior = little reaction, ignore her, doesn't seek proximity or comfort
156
insecure resistant attachment + characteristics
exploration = doesn't explore environment high separation anxiety = distressed and violent high stranger anxiety = extremely distressed reunion behavior = not easily comforted, seeks and rejects comfort
157
strength of Ainsworth's study - good predictive validity
outcome predicts a number of aspects of the baby's later development large body of research has shown that babies and toddlers assessed as type B/ secure, tend to have better outcomes than others. better achievements in school and less involvement in bullying, also likely to have a better mental health as an adult. those babies asses as having an insecure-resistant attachment and whose not fitting into an attachment type tend to have worst outcomes. this suggests that the strange situation measures something real and meaningful in a baby's development
158
counterpoint to good predictive validity - Ainsworth's study
clearly measures something important that is associated with later development, however not all psychologists believe this something is attachment types. for example, some suggest that genetically influenced anxiety levels could account for this variation in attachment behavior in the strange situation and later development. this means that the strange situation may not actually measure validity
159
strength of Ainsworth's study - good reliability
good inter-rater reliability tested inter-rater reliability of the strange situation for a team of trained observers and found agreement on attachment types in 94% of cases. high levels of reliability may be because the procedures takes place under controlled conditions and because behaviors being observed are largely involve movement so can be easily identified. this means that we can be confident that attachment types as assessed by the strange situation does not depend on subjective judgement.
160
weakness of Ainsworth study - the test may be cultural-bound
may not be valid measure of attachment in different cultural context. strange situation developed in UK and USA and may be culture-bound to western cultures. one reason for this is because babies have different experience in different cultures that may affect their response to the strange situation. for example, Japanese babies displayed high levels of separation anxiety, so a disproportionate number of babies were classified as insecure-resistant. however psychologists suggest this anxiety response may not be because of high rates of insecure attachments but the usual nature of the experiment, as the Japanese are rarely separated from their mothers. this means that it is very difficult to know what the strange situation is measuring when outside western Europe and the USA
161
Van Ljzendoorn and Kroonenberg's research - aim
to investigate cross-cultural variations in attachment
162
Van Ljzendoorn and Kroonenberg's research - procedures
conducted a meta-analysis of 32 studies, 8 countries that had used Ainsworth's strange situation. total of 1,990 infants 8 countries = USA, great Britain, Germany, Japan, Sweden, China, Netherlands, Israel
163
Van Ljzendoorn and Kroonenberg's research - findings
secure attachment were the most common attachment types in all cultures examined. Japan(27%) and Israel(29%) had the highest level of insecure resistant attachments - collectivist cultures (china 25%) Germany showed higher levels of insecure- avoidant attachments (35%) variation with one country was 150% greater than between cultures - e.g. in USA one studies found 49% securely attached and another found 90%.
164
cultural variations = Italian studies
aim = to see if the proportion of Italian baby's attachment types matched previous studies. procedures = 76 babies, 12 months old, strange situation findings = 50% secure, 36 insecure- avoidant = lower rates of secure and higher avoidant found in other studies suggest this is because increasing numbers of mothers of very young children work long hours and use professional child-care. this suggest that patterns of attachment types are not static but vary in line cultural change
165
cultural variations = Korean study
compare attachment types in Korea to other studies procedure= strange situation, 87 babies findings = overall proportion of insecure and secure attachments were similar to other countries, however more were classified as resistant whereas only one was classified as avoidant similar to the distribution in Japan since Japan and Korea have similar child -rearing styles this may explain the similarity in attachment types.
166
Van ljzendoorn and Kroonenberg's research = conclusion
secure attachments are the norm in a wide range of cultures supporting Bowlby's idea that idea that attachment is innate and universal and this type is the universal norm. however this research also shows that cultural practices also influence attachment types
167
strength of Ljzendoorn and Kroonenberg's research = indigenous researchers
most of the studies were conducted by indigenous psychologists, who's are from the same cultural background as the participant. for example included research from the German researcher Grossmann et al when studying Germany - this kind of research allows for potential problems in cross-cultural research to be avoided. such as researcher misunderstanding the language used by participants or having issue instructing participants. - also avoid issues of bias and stereotype are a nation that a research may have. this mean there is an excellent change that researchers and participants communicated
168
counterpoint to indigenous researchers = Ljzendoorn and Kroonenberg
however this has not been true of all cross- cultural attachment research for example, Morelli and Tronick were outsiders from America when they studied child-rearing and patterns in attachment in the Efe of Zaire. their data might have been affected by difficulties in gathering dat for participants outside their own culture. this means that the data from countries might have been affected by bias and difficulty in cross-cultural communication
169
weakness of Ljzendoorn and Kroonenberg's research - confounding variables
``` limitation of cross - cultural research is the impact of confounding variables on findings studies conducted in different countries are not usually matched for methodology when they are compared in reviews or meta-analyses. sample characteristics such as poverty, social class and urban/rural make up can confound results as can the age of participants and confound results. for example the size of the rooms with attractive toys there - baby might appear to explore more in studies conducted in small rooms with attractive toys compared to large, bare rooms. less visible proximity seeking because of room size might make a child more likely to be classified as avoidant. this means that looking at attachment behaviour in different non-matched studies conducted in different countries may not tell us anything about cross - cultural patterns of attachment ```
170
weakness of Ljzendoorn and Kroonenberg's research - imposed etic
cross cultural psychology includes the ideas of emic and etic. imposed etic occurs when we impose an idea or technique that works in one cultural context to another. an example of this in attachment research is in the use of babies response to reunion with the caregiver in the strange situation. in Britain and the USA, lack of affection on reunion an avoidant attachment. but in Germany such behaviour would be more likely interpreted as independence rather than insecurity. Therefore that part of the strange situation may not work in Germany. this means that the behaviour measured by the strange situation may not have the same meanings in different cultural contexts and comparing them across cultures is meaningless
171
define maternal deprivation
the emotional and intellectual consequences of separation between a child and their mother or primary attachment. Bowlby proposed that continuous care from a mother essential for normal psychological development, and that prolonged separation from this adult causes serious damage to emotional and intellectual development.
172
Bowlby's theory of maternal deprivation - separation vs deprivation
separation = the child not being in the presence of primary attachments figure. This is only a problem if the child becomes deprived of emotional care. (particularly is the child is with a substitute caregiver that can provide emotional care) extended separations can lead to can led to deprivation, which by definition causes harm
173
Bowlby's theory of maternal deprivation - the critical period
saw the first 2 and half years of life as a critical period for psychological development. if absence of suitable substitute care and deprived of the mother's emotional care for an extended duration during this critical period then psychological damage was inevitable. he also believed there was a continuing risk up to age 5
174
effects of maternal deprivation on intellectual development ( Bowlby)
led to abnormally low IQ (average IQ 96) has been demonstrated in studies of adoption William Goldfarb = found lower IQ in children who had remained in institutions as opposed to those who were fostered and thus had a higher standard of emotional care 68 IQ average - below the cut-off point used to define intellectual disability
175
effects of maternal deprivation on emotional development
Bowlby identified the affectionless psychopathy = inability to experience guilt or strong emotions towards others prevents the development of normal relationship and is associated with criminality - cannot appreciate the feelings of victims and so lack remorse for their actions
176
44 Juvenile thieves study = aim
to see if early separation from the primary caregiver was associated with behavioral disorders Bowlby defined a particular behaviour disorder as affectionless psychopathy to describe individuals who have no sense of shame of guilt
177
44 juvenile thieves study = method
examined children referred to a guidance clinic in London, aged 5-16 years old 44 of the children were criminals (guilty of thieves) and 44 were non-criminal participants were used as a control group. interviewed the children and their families to create a record of early life experiences
178
44 juvenile thieves study = results
identified 14 of the 44 thieves as affectionless psychopaths 86% of the 14 of the affectionless psychopaths had experienced early and prolonged deprivation only 17% of the other thieves had experienced such separation and 4% of the control group had experienced frequent early separations.
179
44 juvenile thieves study = conclusion
these findings suggest a link between early separations and later social maladjustment. the maternal deprivation hypothesis appear to lead to affectionless psychopathy and antisocial behaviour
180
limitation of maternal deprivation - flawed evidence
poor quality of the evidence it is based on Bowlby 44 thieves study is flawed because it was Bowlby himself who carried out both the family interviews and the assessments for affectionless psychopathy. This left him open to bias because he knew in advance which teenagers he expected to show signs of psychopathy. other sources of evidence are equally flawed. for example Bowlby's was also influenced by the findings of Goldfarb's research on development of deprived children in wartime orphanages. this study has a problem of confounding variables because the children in Goldfarb's study has experienced early trauma and institutional care as well as prolonged separation from their primary caregiver this means that Bowlby's original sources of evidence for maternal deprivation had serious flaws and would not be taken seriously as evidence nowadays
181
counterpoint to flawed evidence - maternal deprivation evaluation
a new line of research has provided some modest support for the idea that maternal deprivation can have long-term effects. Levy et al showed that separating baby rats from their mother for as little as a day had a permanent effect on their social development though not other aspects of development. this means that, although Bowlby relied on flawed evidence to support the theory of maternal deprivation, there are other sources of evidence for his ideas
182
limitation of maternal deprivation - deprivation and privation
confusion between different types of early experiences Rutter drew an important distinction between 2 types of early negative experiences. deprivation refers to the loss of the primary attachments figure after attachment has developed. on the other hand privation is the failure to form any attachment in the first place this may take place when children are brought up in institutional care. Rutter pointed out that the serve long-term damage Bowlby associated with deprivation is actually more likely to a result of privation. so the children studied by Goldfarb may actually have been prived rather than deprived. similarly, many of the children in the 44 thieves study had disrupted early lives and may never have formed strong attachments. this means that Bowlby may have overestimated the seriousness of the effects of deprivation in childhood development.
183
limitation of maternal deprivation - critical vs sensitive periods
For Bowlby, damage was inevitable if a child had not formed an attachment in the first 2 and half years of life. hence this is a critical period. however there is evidence to suggest that in many cases good quality aftercare can prevent most or all of this damage. for example psychologists reported the case of the Czech twins. the twins experienced very serve physical and emotional abuse from the age of 18 month until they were 7 years old. although they were severely damaged emotional by their experience they received excellent care and by their teens they had recovered fully. this means that lasting harm is nit inevitable even in cases of severe privation. the critical period is therefore better seen as a sensitive period
184
define institutionalisation
a term for the effects of living in an institutional setting.
185
Rutter et al - aim - Romanian orphans
aimed to investigate the extent to which good care could make up for poor early experiences in institutions
186
Rutter et al - procedures - Romanian orphan
followed a group of 165 Romanian orphans for many years as part of the English and Romanian adoptee study orphans adopted by UK families 111 of the children were adopted at age 2 and 54 of them at the age 4 physical and emotional development was measured at age 4, 6, 11, 15, 22-25 a group of 52 English adopted children were used a control group
187
Rutter et al - findings - Romanian orphans
at the point of adoption, the Romanian orphans showed delayed development on all element of social, cognitive and physical progress - physically smaller, weighed less on average and many were classified as mentally retarded. adopted before the age of 6 months caught up on these measures of development when compared to the British control group if adopted after 6 months the children continued to show significant deficits in term of social, cognitive and physical development - likely to experience difficulties making or maintaining peer relationships and often categories as having disinhibited attachment disorder.
188
Zeanah et al - aim - Romanian orphans
to investigate attachment type of children who had spent most of their life in institutional care.
189
Zeanah et al - procedures - Romanian orphans
sample = almost 100 children aged between 12 months and 31 months 90% of whom spent most of their lives in an orphanage control group of children who had never been institutionalised using strange situation methodology - assed the infants attachment types additionally the careers and parents were asked about several aspects of the infants' behaviour: clinging, attention seeking and appropriateness of behaviour towards adults (disinhibited attachment disorder)
190
Zeanah et al - findings - Romanian orphans
74% of the control group were securely attached to their caregivers 19% of infants from the experimental group were secure attachments 65% of the experimental group appeared to have a disinhibited attachment
191
Zeanah et al - conclusion - Romanian orphans
infants who spent their early years in institutional care, with the absence of a primary attachment figure to provide consistent and sensitive emotional caregiving, are less likely to develop a secure attachment and are far more likely to experience a disinhibited attachment.
192
effects of institutionalisation = disinhibited attachment
equally friendly and affectionate towards familiar people and strangers no sign of stranger anxiety Rutter = an adaptation of living with multiple caregivers during the sensitive period for attachment formation in poor quality institutions, like those in Romania, a child might have 50 cares but doesn't spend enough time with any one of them to form a secure attachment
193
effects of institutionalisation = intellectual development
Rutter study = most children showed signs of intellectual disability when they arrived in Britain when adopted at 6 months they caught up with the control group at age 4 if adopted after 6 month of age they didn't recover
194
effects of institutionalisation = physical development
physically small | Gardner found that a lack of emotional care rather than poor nourishment was the cause of deprivation dwarfism
195
effects of institutionalisation = poor parenting
Quinton et al found that women raised in institutionalisation found it extremely difficult to act as parents compared to a control condition. in fact a number of children raised by ex-institutional women went into care for a period of time (Bowlby - internal working model and Harlow's - maternally deprived monkeys)
196
strength of Romanian Orphan studies - real world application
application to improve conditions for children growing up outside their family home. studying Romanian orphans have improved psychologists understanding of the effects of early institutional care and how to prevent the worst of these effects. this has led to improvements in the conditions experienced by looked after children. e.g. children's home now avoid having large numbers of caregivers with each child. instead children tend to have 1 or 2 key workers who play a central role in their emotional care. also institutional care is now seen as an undesirable option for looked after children. considerable effort is made to accommodate such children in foster care or to have them adopted instead. this means that children in institutional care have a chance to develop normal developments and disinhibited attachment is avoided.
197
strength of Romanian Orphans studies - fewer confounding variables
there were many orphan studies before the Romanian orphans were studied. many children studied in orphanages had experienced varying degrees of trauma and it is difficult to disentangle the effects of neglect, physical abuse and bereavement from those of institutional care. however the children from Romanian Orphanages had been mainly been handed over by loving parents who couldn't afford to keep them. this means that results were much less likely to be confounded by other negative early experiences. (higher internal validity)
198
counterpoint of fewer confounding variables - Romanian orphans studies
on the other hand, studying children from Romanian orphanages might have introduced different confounding variables. the quality of care in these institutions were remarkably poor, with children receiving very little intellectual stimulation or comfort. this means that the harmful effects seen in studies of Romanian orphans may represent the effect of poor institutional care rather than institutional care per se
199
weakness of Romanian Orphans studies - lack of adult data
current lack of data on adult development the latest data from the ERA study looked at the children in their early to mid 20's. this means that we do not currently have data to answer some of the most interesting research questions about the long term effects of institutional care. these research questions include the lifetime prevalence of mental health problems and participants success in forming and maintaining adult romantic and parental relationships. it will take a long time to gather this data because of the longitudinal design of the study. this means it will be some time before we know more completely what the long term effects are for the Romanian orphanages. it is possible that late adopted children may catch up.
200
internal working model - influence of early attachments
Bowlby - suggest the baby's first attachment to their primary attachment figure leads to a mental representation of this relationship. that acts as a template for future relationships (childhood + adult) secure attachment - seek out a functional relationship and behave functionally with them insecure avoidant = too uninvolved or emotionally close insecure resistant = controlling and argumentative
201
relationships in childhood
attachment type is associated with the quality of peer relationships in childhood secure = best quality childhood friendships insecure = difficulty forming friendships bullying behavior can be predicted by attachment type Wilson and smith = assessed attachment type and bulling involvement - questionnaire to 139 7-11 year old's in London secure - unlikely to be involved avoidant - most likely to be victims resistant - most likely to bullies
202
romantic relationships in adulthood - love quiz - aim
Hazan and shaver = love quiz designed to test the internal working model to assess if attachment type formed as an infant influence friendships and adult relationships.
203
love quiz - procedures
3 section - questionnaire published in a local newspaper 620 volunteer participants 1 section = assess the individuals most important relationship 2nd = ascertaining general experiences in love 3rd = self-selecting participants about their feelings in relation to some statements
204
love quiz - findings
56% respondent = securely attached 25% = avoidant 19% = resistant positive correlation between early attachments type and experiences in love secure - loving and lasting romantic relationships avoidant = feeling of dislike in relation to intimacy resistant = shorter relationships, 6 years compared to a secures attachment average of 10 or more years
205
love quiz - conclusion
indicated that specific attachment type behaviour are reflected in adult relationships because of an internal working model formed infancy to guide expectations
206
relationships in adulthood - parenting
bailey et al looked at attachment type of 100 mother and their infants with the relationships they had with their mothers vast proportion of the women had the same attachment type to their infant as to their own mother, supporting the concept of the internal working model influence parenting style. (Harlow support - monkeys with poor or no attachments had difficulties parenting)
207
influence of early attachments strength - research support
studies have linked attachment to later development and reviews of such evidence have concluded that early attachment consistently predicts later attachments, emotional wellbeing and attachment to own children. how strong the relationship is between early attachment type and the aspect of later development. so whilst insecure-avoidant attachments seems to convey fairly mild disadvantages for any aspects of development, disorganised attachment is strongly associated with later mental disorders. this means that secure attachment as a baby appears to convey advantages for future development while disorganised attachment appear to seriously disadvantage children.
208
counterpoint of research support - influence of early attachments
not all evidence supports the existence of close links between early attachments and later development. for example, a longitudinal study followed 43 individuals from 1 year of age. at age 16 attachment was assessed using the adult attachment interview and there was no evidence of continuity. this means that it is not clear to what extent the quality of early attachment really predicts later development. there may be other important factors.
209
definition of abnormality - statistical infrequency
occurs when an individual has a less common characteristic or behaviour used when dealing with a characteristic that can be measured (majority scores cluster) example - IQ and intellectual disability disorder average IQ is around 100 - normal distribution most people around 85 and 115 only 2% of people score below 70 - liable to receive a diagnosis of intellectual disability disorders
210
strength of using statistical infrequency as a definition of abnormality - real world application
used in clinical practice, both as part of formal diagnosis and as a way to assess the severity of an individual's symptoms. for example a diagnosis of intellectual disability disorders requires an IQ of below 70. an example of statistical infrequency used in an assessment tool is the Beck depression inventory. a score of 30+ is widely interpreted as indicating severe depression. this show that the value of the statistical infrequency criterion is useful in diagnosis and assessment processes.
211
weakness of using statistical infrequency as definition of abnormality- unusual characteristic can be positive
infrequent characteristics can be positive as well as negative. for every person with an IQ below 70 there is another with an IQ above 130. yet we would not think of someone as abnormal for having a high IQ. similarly, we would not think of someone with a very low depression score on the BDI as abnormal. these examples show that being usual or at one end of the psychological spectrum does not necessarily make someone abnormal. this means that, although statistical infrequency can form part of assessment and diagnosis procedures, it is never sufficient as a sole basis for defining abnormality
212
definition of abnormality - deviation from social norms
concerns behaviour that is different from the accepted standards of behaviour in a community or society (explicit and implicit) norms are specific to the culture we live in, e.g. homosexuality is viewed as abnormal is viewed as abnormal and illegal in some cultures examples = antisocial personality disorder (impulsive, aggressive, irresponsible) - don't conform to social standards
213
strength of deviation of social norms as a definition of abnormality - real world application
deviation of social norms is used in clinical practice. for example, the key characteristics of antisocial personality disorders is the failure to conform to culturally normal ethical behavior. e.g. recklessness, aggression, violating the right of others and deceitfulness. these signs of the disorder are all deviations from social norms such norms also plays a part in diagnosis of schizotypal personality disorder, where the term strange is used to characterise the thinking, behaviour and appearance of people with the disorder. this shows that the deviation from social norms criterion has value in psychiatry.
214
weakness of deviation of social norms as a definition of abnormality - cultural and situational relativism
variability between social norms in different cultures and even different situations a person from one cultural group may label someone from another group as abnormal using their standards rather than the person's standards for example, the experience of hearing voices is the norm in some cultures but would be seen as a sign of abnormality in the UK. also, even one cultural context social norms differ from one situation to another. Aggression and deceitful behaviour in the context of family life is more socially inacceptable than in the context of corporate deal-making. this means that it is difficult to judge deviation from social norms across different situations and cultures.
215
definition of abnormality - failure to function adequately
occurs when someone is unable to cope with ordinary demands of day to day living example - depression = may struggle to get out of bed and go to work, find it difficult to communicate with family - inability to cope with the demands of everyday life.
216
failure to function adequately - strength - represents a threshold for help
the criterion is that it represents a sensible threshold for when people need professional help. most of us have symptoms of mental disorder to some degree at some time. in fact, according to the mental health charity mind, around 25% of people in the UK will experience a mental health problem in any given year. however, many people press on in the face of fairly severe symptoms. it tends to be at the point that we cease to function adequately that people seek professional help and are noticed and referred for help by others this criterion means that treatment and services can be targeted to those who need them most
217
failure to function adequately - weakness - discrimination and social control.
easy to label non-standard lifestyle choices as abnormal. in practice it is hard to say when someone is really failing to function and when they have simply chosen to deviate from social norms. for example, not having a job or permanent address might seem like failing to function and for some people it would be. however people with alternative lifestyles chose to live off grid. similarly those who favour high risk leisure activities or unusual spiritual practices could be classed, unreasonably, as irrational and perhaps a danger to self. this means that people who make unusual choices are at risk of being labelled abnormal and their freedom of choice may be restricted.
218
definitions of abnormality - deviation from ideal mental health
occurs when someone does not meet a set of criteria for good mental health. - no symptoms or distress - rational and can perceive ourselves accurately - self actualisation - can cope with stress - realistic views of the world - good self esteem - independent to other people - can successfully work, love and enjoy our leisure
219
strength - deviation from ideal mental health - comprehensive definition
concept of ideal mental health includes a range of criteria for distinguishing mental health from illness. in fact it covers most of the reasons why we might seek help with mental health. this in turn means that an individual's mental health can be discussed meaningfully with a range of professionals who might take different theoretical views e.g. medically trained psychiatrist might focus on symptoms whereas a humanistic counsellor might be more interested in self-actualisation. this means that ideal mental health provides a checklist against which we can assess ourselves and others and discuss psychological issues with a range of professionals.
220
weakness - deviation from ideal mental health - may be culture - bound
different elements are not equally applicable across a range of cultures the criteria for ideal mental health are firmly located in the context of USA and western Europe. in particular the concept of self-actualisation would probably be dismissed as self-indulgent in much of the world. even within western Europe there is quite a bit of variation in the value placed on personal independence e.g. high in Germany and low in Italy furthermore what defines success in our working, social and love lives is very different in different cultures this means that it is difficult to apply the concept of ideal mental health from one culture to another.
221
cognitive characteristics of phobias
selective attention to the phobia stimulus - struggle to concentrate on something else then their phobia. irrational beliefs - hold unfounded thoughts in relation to phobic stimuli, that cant be easily explained and don't have any basis in reality. cognitive beliefs - the perception of a phobia may be inaccurate or unrealistic
222
behavioral characteristics of phobias
panic - response when in presence of the phobia stimulus - crying, screaming or running away avoidance - conscious effect to prevent contact with phobia stimulus endurance - remain in the presence of the phobia stimulus to keep an eye on it.
223
emotional characteristics of phobias
anxiety fear emotional response is unreasonable - greater than the usual and disproportionate.
224
behavioural characteristics of depression
activity levels - reduced levels of energy or psychomotor agitation, struggle to relax disruption in sleep and eating behaviour aggression and self harm
225
emotional characteristics of depression
lowered mood anger lowered self-esteem
226
cognitive characteristics of depression
poor concentration attending to and dwelling on the negative absolutist thinking
227
define two process model
an explanation for the onset and persistence of disorders that create anxiety, such as phobias the two processes are classical conditioning for onset and operant conditioning for persistence.
228
behavioural approach to explaining phobias
two processes model - classical and operational conditioning
229
little albert - classical conditioning and acquisition of phobias
Watson and Rayner little Albert - 9 month old baby started with no anxieties - show white rat and tried to play with it even ever rat was present made a loud, frightening noise UCS - noise UCR - fear NS - rat CS - rat CR - fear conditioning generalised to similar furry objects e.g. non-white rabbit, fur coat, Santa clause beard
230
maintained by operant conditioning
classical conditioning tends to decline over time but phobias are long lasting. Mowrer explains this as the result of operant conditioning behaviour is reinforced or punished negative reinforcement - avoid negative situation - result in a desirable consequence of not being scared - repeat the behaviour
231
strength of the two process model for explaining phobias - real world application
real world application to exposure therapies the distinctive element of the two process model is the idea that phobias are maintained by avoidance of phobic stimulus. this is important in explaining why people with phobias benefit from being exposed to the phobic stimulus. once the avoidance behaviour is prevented it ceases to be reinforced by the experience of anxiety reduction and avoidance therefore declines. in behavioural terms the phobia is the avoidance behaviour so when this avoidance is prevented the phobia is cured. this shows that value of the two -process approach because it identifies a means of treating phobias.
232
weakness of the two process model at explaining phobias - cognitive aspect of phobias
doesn't account for the cognitive aspects of phobias behavioural explanation, including the two-process model, are geared towards explaining behaviour. in the case of phobias the key behaviour avoidance of the phobic stimulus. however, we know that phobias are not simply avoidance responses, they also have a significant cognitive component. for example people hold irrational beliefs about the phobic stimulus. the two process model explains avoidance behaviour but does not offer an adequate explanation for phobic cognitions. this means that the two process model does not completely explain the symptoms of phobias
233
strength of two process model (phobias) - phobias and traumatic experiences
evidence for the link between bad experiences and phobias little albert illustrates how a frightening experience involving a stimulus can lead to a phobia of that stimulus. more evidence comes from a study that found that 73% of people with a fear of dental treatment had experienced a traumatic experience, mostly involving dentistry. this can be compared to a control group of people with low dental anxiety where only 21% had experienced a traumatic event. this conforms that the association between stimulus and an unconditioned response does lead to the development of the phobia.
234
counterpoint to phobias and traumatic experience - two process model evaluation
not all phobias appear following a bad experience. in fact some common phobias such as snakes phobias occur in populations where very few people have any experience of snakes let alone traumatic experiences. also considering the other direction not all frightening experiences led to phobias. this means that the association between phobias and frightening experiences is not as strong as we would expect if behavioural theories provided a complete explanation.
235
systematic desensitisation
gradually reduce phobic anxiety through the principle of classical conditioning. learn to relax in the presence of the phobic stimulus - learn new response/ counterconditioning 3 processes: 1.the anxiety hierarchy - client and therapist rank a list of situations related to the phobic stimulus that provoke anxiety in order of least to most frightening. 2. relaxation - breathing exercises or mental imagery techniques or mediation or medication 3. exposure - exposed to the stimulus while in a relaxed state. serval sessions, starting at the bottom of the list.
236
strength of systematic desensitisation - evidence of effectiveness
Gilroy et al followed 42 people who had SD for spider phobias in 3, 45 minute sessions. at both 3 and 33 month the SD group were less fearful than control group treated by relaxation without exposure. in recent review psychologists have concluded that SD is effective for specific phobias, social phobias and agoraphobias this means that SD is likely to be helpful for people with phobias
237
strength of systematic desensitisation - people with learning disabilities
some people requiring treatment for phobias also have a learning disability. however the main alternatives to SD are not suitable. people with learning disabilities often struggle with cognitive therapies that require a high level of rational thought. people with learning disabilities may also feel confused and distressed by the traumatic experience of flooding. this means that SD is often the most appropriate treatment for people with learning difficulties who have phobias
238
flooding
exposing people with a phobia to their phobic stimulus but without a gradual build-up in an anxiety hierarchy. - long sessions how it works - process of extinction = extinguish the conditioned stimulus by not encountering the unconditioned stimulus resulting in the conditioned stimulus to be avoided achieve relaxation in the presence of the phobic stimulus ethical safeguards = informed consent
239
strength of flooding - cost effective
highly cost effective flooding is clinically effective and can be easily implicated with the NHS as a clinical treatment due to it being cost effective and not expensive. this is because flooding can be used in one session as opposed to 10 session in treatments like SD when achieving the same results. even allowing for longer session this makes flooding more cost effective. this means that more people can be treated at the same cost with flooding than with SD or other therapists.
240
weakness of flooding - traumatic
highly unpleasant experience confronting one's phobic stimulus is an extreme form provokes tremendous anxiety. it was found that participants and therapists rated flooding as significantly more stressful than SD. this raises the ethical issue for psychologists of knowing causing stress to their clients, although this is not a serious issue provided they obtain informed consent. more seriously the traumatic nature of flooding means that attrition rates are higher than for SD this suggests that overall therapists may avoid using this treatment
241
genetic explanation
genes are involved in individual vulnerability to OCD Lewis - observed that 37% of his OCD patients had parent with OCD, and 21% had siblings with OCD. - genetic vulnerability diathesis-stress model = some environmental stress necessary to trigger the condition
242
genetic explanation - candidate genes and polygenetic
230 genes involved in the condition and different genetic variations contributions to different types of OCD. COMT gene = dopamine neurotransmitter, higher levels dopamine = associated with motor functions, pleasure and impulsive behaviour SERT gene = linked to serotonin and affects the transport of this neurotransmitter, lower levels serotonin = role in sleep, emotions, social behaviour and also believed to have a role in preventing repetition of tasks.
243
strength of the genetic explanation for OCD - research support
strong evidence base multiple source of evidence from a variety of sources that strongly suggest that some people are vulnerable to OCD as a result of their genetic vulnerable to OCD as a result of their genetic make up. one source of evidence is twin studies have founded that 68% of identical twins (MZ) shared OCD as opposed to 31% of non-identical ( DZ) twins. another source of evidence for a genetic influence on OCD is family studies. research has found that a person with a family member diagnosed with OCD is around 4x as likely to develop it as someone without. these research studies suggest that there must be some genetic influence on the development of OCD
244
weakness of the genetic explanation of OCD - environmental risk factors
strong evidence for the idea that genetic variation can make a person more or less vulnerable to OCD. However, OCD does not appear to be entirely genetic in origin and it seems that environmental risk factors can also trigger or increase the risk of developing OCD. in one study it was found that over half the OCD clients in their sample had experienced a traumatic event in their past. OCD was also more severe in those with one or more traumas this means that genetic vulnerability only provides a particle explanation for OCD.
245
neural explanation for OCD
OCD is likely to affect the levels of key neurotransmitters as well as structure of the brain. role of serotonin = help regulate mood, normal transmissions of mood relevant information doesn't take place and people may experience low moods and a reducing in the functioning of the serotonin system decision making = impaired decision making, abnormal functions in the frontal lobe that is responsible for logical thinking and making decisions. Parahippocampal gyrus associated with processing unpleasant emotions, functions abnormally.
246
neural explanation - worry circuit
orbitifrontal cortex sends signal to the thalamus about potential worry usual minor worries are suppressed by the caudate nucleus - OCD damaged CN worry not suppressed and the thalamus is altered and confirms the worry to the OFC. an over active thalamus would in a increased motivation to clean or check for safety. if the thalamus was overactive the OFC would also become overactive creating the worry circuit
247
strength of the neural explanation - research support
antidepressants that work purely on serotonin are effective at reducing OCD symptoms and this suggests that serotonin may be involved in OCD. also, OCD symptoms form part of conditions that are known to be biological in origin, such as Parkinson's disease, which cause muscle tremors and paralysis. if a biological disorder produces OCD symptoms, then we may assume the biological processes underlie OCD. this suggest that biological factors may also be responsible for OCD
248
weakness of the neural explanation for OCD - no unique neural system
serotonin-OCD link may not be unique to OCD many people with OCD also experience clinical depression, means they are facing co-morbidity. this depression probably involves disruption to the action of serotonin. this leaves us with a logical problem when it comes to serotonin as a possible basis for OCD. it could simply be that serotonin activity is disrupted in many people with
249
what do drug therapists aim to do
decrease levels of neurotransmitters in the brain to increase or decrease their activity low serotonin in OCD - drug therapists work in various of ways to increase serotonin.
250
SSRIs - selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor
medical treatment for OCD - type of antidepressant serotonin system - affected take daily for 3 to 4 months to impact symptoms fluoxetine
251
Serotonin and neurons
serotonin released from presynaptic neuron travels across the synapse neurotransmitter chemically conveys signals from the presynaptic neuron to the postsynaptic neuron serotonin is broken down and reused - inhibitory = decrease firing potential
252
what SSRIs do
prevent reabsorption and breakdown of serotonin (neurotransmitters) - block reuptake increase levels of serotonin in the synapse thus serotonin continues to simulate the postsynaptic neuron
253
combining SSRIs with other treatments
SSRI used along side CBT to treat OCD drugs reduce emotional symptoms e.g. feeling anxious or depressed allowing patients to engage in CBT more effectively
254
strength of drug therapies - evidence of effectiveness
clear evidence that to show that SSRIs reduce symptoms severity and improve the quality of life of people with OCD. for example, studies comparing SSRI's and placebos in the treatment of OCD found that in all 17 studies SSRIs showed significantly better outcomes than the placebo condition typical symptoms were reduced by around 70% for people taking SSRIs and the remaining 30% of symptoms could be help with therapies and other drug treatments this means that drugs appear to be helpful for most people with OCD
255
counterpoint of the effectiveness of drug therapies - evidence
some evidence to suggest that even if drug treatments are helpful for most people with OCD they may not be the most effective treatment available. when a study carried out a systematic review of outcome studies, it concluded that both cognitive and behavioural therapies were more effective than SSRIs in the treatment of OCD. this means that drugs may not be the optimum treatment for OCD.
256
strength of drug therapies - cost effective and non-disruptive
a strength of drug therapies in general is that they are cheap compared to psychological treatments because many thousands of tablets or liquid doses can be manufactured in the same time it takes to conduct one psychological therapy session. using drugs to treat OCD is therefore good value for public health systems like the NHS, and represent a good use of limited funds. as compared to psychological therapies, SSRIs are also non-disruptive to peoples lives. as drug therapies mean that you simply have to take a pill to decrease symptoms whereas psychological therapists involve spending time in attending therapy sessions. this means that drugs are popular as a treatment for doctors and OCD patients.
257
weakness of drug therapies - serious side effects
although drugs such as SSRIs help most people, a small majority don't benefit for people. some people also experience side effects such as indigestion, blurred vision and loss of sex drive. these side-effects are usually temporary, however they can be quite destressing for people and for a minority they are long lasting. for example 1 in 10 people experience erection problems and weight gain, 1 in 100 become aggression and experience heart-related problems. this means that some people have a reduced quality of life as a result of taking drugs and may stop taking them altogether, meaning the drugs cease to be effective.