NY BAR REVIEW - torts and tort damages 2019 Flashcards
what type of negligence jurisdiction are we?
pure comparative
action to recover damages forpersonal injury, injury to property, wrongful death, culpable conduct atttibutable to claimant or decedent, contributory neglig, assumption of risk, DOESNT bar what?
recovery
action to recover damages forpersonal injury, injury to property, wrongful death, culpable conduct atttibutable to claimant or decedent, contributory neglig, assumption of risk, diminishes what?
amount of damages otherwise recoverable in proportion which culpable conduct attributable to claimant or decedent bears to culpable conduct which caused the damages.
affirmative defense to be pleaded and proved by party asserting defense
action to recover damages forpersonal injury, injury to property, wrongful death, culpable conduct atttibutable to claimant or decedent, contributory neglig, assumption of risk
damages diminished in cases of
implied assumption of risk, but where pl voluntarily assumes known risk of injury, such express assumption will absolve def of duty owed to pl
participant in sports or recreational activity
voluntarily assumes and consents to risks inherent in and arise out of nature of sport generally and which flow from participation
violation of state statute that imposes specific duty
constitutes neg per se
violation of municipal ordinance or administrative rule
constitutes some evidence of neg
in certain cases, violation of state statute may impose what?
absolute liab
duty owed by owner / occupier of land to person entering premises - invitee, licensee, trespasser
reasonable care under the circumstances.
landowner MUST act as reasonable person in maintaining premises in reasonably safe condition in view of all circumstances, likelihood of injury to others, seriousness of injury, burden of avoiding risk
recreational use statute
no duty to keep sage for entry / use by others for hunting, fishing,boating, hiking, cross country skiing, sledding, snowmobile operation, other recreational activities , or give warning of any hazardous condition on property
landowner can be found liable for what?
willful / malicious failure to guard or warn ag dangerous condition or for injury suffered where permission to use property was granted for consideration
intra family immunity for non willful torts
defense is abrogated
actions bw parents and children actionable or not, to same extent that such are brought by non family members?
actionable
parent’s neg failure to supervise their child is or not actionable by child?
NOT
parent’s neg failure to supervise their child - 3rd party tortfeasors are or are not entitled to contribution from parents for liab resulting in part from neglig supervision of child?
NOT
when parent breached duty owed to 3rd parties by negligently permitting infant child to use dangerous instrument - actionable or not?
actionable. parent may be found liable to 3rd party injured as consequence of parent’s failure to proect 3rd party from foreseeable harm that results from child’s improvident use of dangerous instrument, which harm includes 3rd party’s tort liab.
3rd party cast in liab for injury to a child may seek what?
contribution from parent who has negligently entrusted child w dangerous instrument and whose neg contributed to child’s injury
neglig infliction of emotional distress
zone of danger rule. emotional distress upon witnessing injury of a member of pl’s immediate family
zone of danger
pl is in it if he is exposed to an unreasonable risk of injury due to def’s conduct.
pl in zone of danger
may recover damages for injuries suffered in consequence of shock or fright resulting from contemporaneous observation of serious physical injury or death of member of pl’s immediate family, where def’s same conduct was substl factor in causing injury to pl’s fam mmbr.
where def unreasonably endangered pl’s physical safety , def breached duty owed directly to pl, entitling pl to?
recover all damages sustained, including those suffered as consequence of witnessing suffering of immediate family mmbr also injured by def’s conduct
medical malpractice resulting in miscarriage or stillbirth is what?
violation of duty of care to expectant mother, entitling her to damages for emotional distress, even in absence of indep injury to her.
statutory std of care owed to construction workers / labor law
scaffolding law.
duty on contractors, owners, agents, to furnish or erect scaffolding, hoists, stays, ladders, other devices, so as to give proper protection to workers involved in erection, demolition, repairing, altering, painting, cleaning, pointing, of bldg or structure.
what type of liab is imposed under scaffolding law?
absolute
pl’s comparative fault in scaffolding law violation reduces or not the recovery?
NOT
exception for pl’s comparative fault in scaffolding law violation recovery
owners of 1 or 2 family dwellings who contract for but dont direct or control the work.
what type of liab on owners, contractors, agents, for scaffolding law violation where worker sustains elevation related injury, due to falling object of falling worker, where injury is consequence of absence or improper use of required safety device
strict
labor law requires contractors and owners and their agents, excluding owners of 1 and 2 family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control work to what?
comply w various requirements
the law requires all areas in which construction, excavation, demolition work being performed be so constructed, shored, guarded, and operated, so as to provide what?
reasonable and adequate protection to persons employed or lawfully frequenting such places. commissioner of labor is authorized to make rules to carry provisions into effect.
violation of the rules requiring all areas in which construction, excavation, demolition work being performed be so constructed, shored, guarded, and operated, so as to provide reasonable and adequate protection to persons employed or lawfully frequenting such places is evidence of what?
negligence
drap shop act
creates cause of action in favor of person injured in person, property, means of support, or otherwise, by an intoxicated person as ag any person who by unlawfully selling liquor or assisting in procuring liquor for such intoxicated person, caused or contributed to such intoxication
dram shop act requires what?
commercial sale of alcohol
what type of damages recovered from violation of dram shop act?
actual damages.
exemplary damages.
what is an unlawful sale in dram shop act terms?
to a minor.
to a visibly intoxicated person.
to a habitual drunkard.
alcohol beverage control act.
dram shop liab extends to whom re minor?
person, social host, knowingly causing intoxication in person under 21 by furnishing or assisting in procuring alcohol to minor
what is furnishing re general obligations law?
participation in deliberate plan to furnish alcohol to underage individuals
vehicle owner liab for death or injury to person or property resulting from neg use or operation of vehicle by person using or operating vehicle w express or implied permission of owner
vicarious liab
strong presumption of permissive use that can only be rebutted w what?
substl evidence sufficient to show driver of vehicle WASNT operating it w express or implied permission of owner
parents are or not vicariously liab for torts of minor children?
NOT