Legal/Regulatory Compliance Flashcards
What are the Building Regulations?
- The Building Regulations are made under powers provided in the Building Act 1984, and apply in England and Wales.
- They exist to ensure the health and safety of people in and around all types of buildings.
- They also contain provisions for energy conservation, access to and the use of buildings.
What is deemed to constitute Building work under the Building Act 1984?
Building Work is defined in Regulation 3 of the Building Regulations.
The definition means that the following types of project amount to ‘Building Work’:-
- The erection or extension of a building.
- The installation or extension of a service or fitting which is controlled under the regulations.
- An alteration project involving work which will temporarily or permanently affect the ongoing compliance of the building, service or fitting with the requirements relating to structure, fire, or access to and use of buildings.
- The insertion of insulation into a cavity wall and the underpinning of the foundations of a building.
What are the Approved Documents?
- The approved documents provide guidance on how the Building Regulations can be satisfied.
- They have legal status under the Building Act 1984 and there are 14 Approved Documents in total.
Can you please name some of the Approved Documents?
- A — Structure.
- B — Fire Safety.
- C — Site preparation and resistance to contaminates and moisture.
- D — Toxic Substances.
- E — Resistance to the passage of sound.
- F — Ventilation.
- G — Sanitation, hot water safety and water efficiency.
- H — Drainage and waste disposal.
- J — Combustion appliances and fuel storage systems.
- K — Protection from falling, collision and impact.
- L — Conservation of fuel and power.
- M — Access to and use of buildings.
- O — Overheating.
- P — Electrical safety.
- Q – Security in dwellings
- R – Infrastructure for electronic communications
- S – Infrastructure for charging electric vehicles
- Materials and workmanship – Approved Document 7
Can you please outline the changes made to Approved Document L in 2022?
- New carbon emission target.
- Lowering of U-values for new and replaced elements.
Can you tell me the different types of asbestos survey?
- Management Survey
- Refurbishment & Demolition Survey
When would you undertake the different types of asbestos survey?
- Management Survey – Allows the duty holder to produce an asbestos register and an asbestos management plan (Reg 4 – duty to manage asbestos)
- Refurbishment & Demolition Survey – To be carried out prior to undertaking works that may disturb ACM’s (Reg 5 – identification of presence of asbestos).
If you were doing a survey, would you give advice as to what materials contain asbestos?
No - It isn’t possible to confirm if materials contain asbestos without testing.
What accreditations should you have to undertake asbestos surveys?
- UKAS (United Kingdom Accreditation Service).
- P402 qualification (for taking samples).
When were the different types of asbestos banned in the UK?
- 1985 – Amosite (brown) and Crocidolite (blue).
- 1999 – Chrysotile (white).
Do you know when the Building Act came into force?
1984
At 76 Clifton York where the client had an enforcement action regarding planning, what would happen if they did not obtain the retrospective planning permission?
Requirement to reverse changes made.
What are the timeframes regarding planning enforcement notices?
As of April 25, 2024, the time limit for taking enforcement action for planning breaches in England is 10 years. This applies to all breaches of planning control, including: Operational development, Changes of use to dwellinghouses, and Breaches of planning conditions.
The 10-year time limit applies to breaches committed on or after April 25, 2024. For breaches that occurred before this date, a four-year time limit applies if:
The breach involved building or other operations without planning permission, and substantial completion occurred before April 25, 2024
The breach involved changing the use of a building to a single dwellinghouse, and the change occurred before April 25, 2024
If an enforcement notice is served, there is a period of 4 to 6 weeks before it takes effect. During this time, the recipient can appeal to the Secretary of State. The appeal process can take 4 to 12 months. If no appeal is submitted, or if the appeal is dismissed, the recipient must comply with the requirements of the notice.
Do you know of any RICS guidance on dilapidations?
- Dilapidations England and Wales (7th Edition, September 2016 – Professional Standard).
- Consumer Guide - Dilapidations in England and Wales A clear, impartial guide.
Can you provide examples of documentation relevant to dilapidations claims?
- Lease(s)
- Scaled plans
- Licences or other consents for alterations, with plans and specifications
- Inventories
- Reinstatement notices
- Notices under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954
- Schedule of condition (with photographs)
- Current or historic planning consents
- Statement of the landlord’s intentions
What should be taken into consideration when assessing the standard of repair/condition and value of a property?
- The nature of the location when the lease was granted (if possible), as this information might be relevant to the assessment of the standard of repair and/or condition and
- The general standard of repair of properties in the locality and whether they are, for example, vacant, boarded up or refurbished, as this information might be relevant to the diminution in the value of the landlord’s reversion.
What is typically contained within a Schedule of Dilapidations?
- Details of documents relied upon
- An itemised numbered reference
- The relevant clause of the lease or other document
- The alleged breach
- The remedy required (when relevant) and
- The cost of the remedy (when relevant).
What information might you rely upon when quantifying the costs within a dilapidations claim?
- Invoices following completion of the remedial works
- The results of a competitive tender exercise
- Price book data
- Relevant and recent tender price information
- The advice of a quantity surveyor and
- The result of a consultation with and assistance from a contractor, which could be conducted on the basis of a full specification of works derived from the Schedule of Dilapidations
Who would serve a Schedule of Dilapidations?
- The landlord’s solicitor if formal service is required.
- Where formal service is not required, it can be acceptable for the landlord’s surveyor to issue the SoD on the landlord’s behalf.
What legislation related to interim dilapidations?
The Leasehold Property (Repairs) Act 1938 (the 1938 Act) sets out a number of important limitations on landlords’ remedies in this context. It applies to any lease that was granted for a term of seven years or more and three or more years of the term remain unexpired. It does not, however, apply to all remedies (only to forfeiture and damages).
What are the remedies available to landlords when pursuing an interim dilapidations claim?
- Damages
- Forfeiture
- Specific performance and
- Entry to carry out the work.
What must a landlord do when looking take forfeiture proceedings?
- Serve a 146 Notice upon the tenant, detailing the breaches, and must give a reasonable time for those breaches to be remedied.
- If the tenant does not remedy the breach(es) within a reasonable time, the landlord can commence forfeiture proceedings within the county court.
- Where the 1938 Act applies, the landlord must so notify the tenant in the section 146 notice and then, if the tenant serves a counter notice within 28 days of service of the notice, the landlord must obtain the permission of the court before commencing proceedings.
What is specific performance?
- The remedy whereby the court orders performance of a contractual obligation – in this context a repairing or similar obligation.
- May not be ordered by the court where damages would be an adequate remedy or where performance would be impossible or would cause hardship to the tenant.
- Rarely used and considered appropriate in exceptional circumstances such as where the works are urgent or there is no adequate alternative remedy (e.g. the right to enter and do work).
What is a Jervis v Harris clause?
- These relate to the remedy of entry to carry out work by the landlord, without consent of the tenant, after previously serving notice on the tenant to undertake the works within a specified period, which they have failed to do.
- The cost of works would be recovered from the tenant as a dept rather than as a damages claim.
- If the Jervis v Harris clause states that the landlord’s costs are recoverable as a debt, provisions of the Leasehold Property (Repairs) Act 1938 and section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 are anticipated not to apply.
- RICS advise extreme caution when exercising these clauses, as failing to adhere to the relevant clauses within a lease can result in counter-claims from a tenant for trespass and breach of quiet enjoyment.
What is a Scott Schedule?
When the Schedule of Dilapidations is expanded upon to include columns for the tenant’s comments and costs, this then becomes a Scott Schedule.
When is a terminal schedule of dilaps issued?
- Within the last 18 months to 3 years of a lease.
- Not more than 56 days after lease expiry.
- Served prior to or shortly after lease expiry.
What are the other types of dilaps schedule you could issue?
- Interim (any point during the lease term).
- Final (after lease expiry if updates made to terminal schedule).
When can you issue an interim dilaps?
At any point during the lease term.
Would you include costs within an interim dilaps schedule?
Only if damages and/or forfeiture are being pursued
What should consultants have in order to undertake a dilaps instruction?
Relevant experience and PII.
What is contained in a SoD?
- Reference to specific lease clauses
- Breaches
- Remedial works suggested
- Cost of works
What typical figures may be included within the summary page for a Terminal Schedule of Dilapidations?
- Professional fees in connection with preparation of the Schedule of Dilapidations
- Legal fees in connection with the service of the Schedule of Dilapidations
- Design and administration of the work envisaged by the Schedule of Dilapidations
- Costs associated with compliance with the CDM Regulations
- Any relevant statutory fees and
- An allowance for irrecoverable VAT
What impact does Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 have on dilaps?
- Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 limits the damages that are recoverable for breaches of the repairing covenant. This section is frequently expressed as having two ‘limbs’.
- Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 does not apply to breaches of what are termed as ‘non-repair’ type lease obligations, including for example obligations relating to decoration, removal and reinstatement. These are subject to different rules regarding the assessment of damages.
What are the two limbs to Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927?
- Limb 1 – Damages in relation to breaches of repair should not exceed the amount by which the value of the reversion in the premises is diminished owing to the breach of such covenant or agreement as aforesaid.
- Limb 2 – No damages can be recovered with regard to covenants to leave or put premises in repair at the termination of a lease, if it is shown that the premises, in whatever state of repair they might be, would at or shortly after the termination of the tenancy have been or be pulled down, or such structural alterations made therein as would render valueless.
Who would formally serve the SoD?
Landlord’s solicitor.