Lecture 7 - Assessing and Remediating Text Comprehension Problems Flashcards
Reading is a complex process that involves what six things?
Perception
Phonemic Awareness
Phonological Awareness
Orthographic Knowledge
Semantic Knowledge
Comprehension
What does literacy have the ability to do?
3
Decode and encode
Say words printed on paper
Say what the words mean
What is Multimodal Literacy the comprehension and production of?
What does it require people to do?
A wide variety of communication modalities (print, images, video, and digital contexts)
To represent their knowledge in those modalities
What are five essential skills for reading proficiency?
Phonemic awareness
Phonics
Fluency (reading)
Vocabulary
Comprehension
Oral and written language have a ___________.
Reciprocal relationship
Reading and Writing are initially dependent on what two things?
Oral language
Extending oral language abilities
Younger children use oral language to ___________ and older children use reading to ___________.
Learn to read
Further learning
Conversational language is used to meet what needs?
3
Requesting/commanding
Accomplishing daily tasks
Sharing personal information
What is Academic Language used to do?
5
Analyze
Evaluate
Synthesize
Persuade
Explain
Does Academic Language use more vocabulary words that carry meaning than Conversational Language?
Yes
What does Academic Language use more of?
3
Technical terms
Abstract concepts
Events that are related (e.g., wars, civil rights)
What complex syntactic patterns are used more often in Academic Language?
(5)
Passive voice
Dependent clauses
Adverbial clauses (when, while, so, because, if-then, unless)
Adjectival clauses (The colonists, who felt they did not have representation, dumped tea into the Boston Harbor)
Noun clauses (Where the rebels were going was unknown)
What is Content Schema?
Mental model for facts presented in the text
Social structures of bees, ants
What is Text Schema?
2
Superordinate organization for the presentation of content information
Organization of descriptions, stories and explanations
What is Event Schemata?
Common routines (e.g., going to a party)
What do Comprehension and Production of discourse or texts require?
The ability to make a variety of inferences
What do we need understanding of in order to comprehend text?
(2)
Cause-effect between people, objects, and events
Intention
______ are needed to comprehend text.
Inferences
Poor comprehenders have difficulty making ______ to ___________.
Inferences
Answer questions
What is Anaphoric Referencing?
Pronoun or noun phrase that refers to previous text activity
“He asked her where she was going” – who is he, she?
What is Bridging/Relational Inference?
2
Deducing sequence and relationship of information across sentences
Integrating semantically/conceptually related information across sentences
(“Morgan heard her favorite TV show, sighed, and went back to work.” = TV not in the room.)
[Inferring the relationship of two objects or events that aren’t explicitly related. The connection between the two is essential for understanding the text]
What are Explanation-Based Inferences?
Inferring the antecedent or consequences of actions
MLK marched in Washington because he wanted the laws to change
What are Predictive Inferences?
Forecasts future events
Pigs will escape wolf. How people will react to storm
What is Goal Inferencing?
Infers the intentions of characters
Foxes want to eat ducks
What is Elaborative Inference?
Considers associations that cannot be explained causally
Houses will be less sturdy if built with straw.
What are six types of inferences?
Anaphoric Referencing
Bridging/Relational Inference
Explanation-Based Inferences
Goal Inferencing
Predictive Inferences
Elaborative Inference
What is contained in Cognitive Understanding?
4
Content schema
Text Schema
Event Schema
Inferences
What is contained in Narrative Content?
3
Landscape of action
Landscape of consciousness
Theory of Mind
What is Landscape of Action?
2
Temporally patterned sequences of actions that are reported in the 3rd person
Have minimal information about character’s psychological state
What is Landscape of Consciousness?
2
Story is told from perspectives of characters
Linguistic coding from Theory of Mind
What is Theory of Mind?
Being able to infer the full range of mental states that cause action
(beliefs, desires, intentions, imagination, emotions)
How do Narrative and Expository Texts differ?
4
Differ in purpose
Differ in schemata
Differ in text structure
Differ in types of processing
What are ways that Narrative and Expository Texts differ in purpose?
Entertain vs. information
What are ways that Narrative and Expository Texts differ in schemata?
Familiar vs. unfamiliar
What are ways that Narrative and Expository Texts differ in text structure?
Same basic vs. variable by genre
What are ways that Narrative and Expository Texts differ in types of processing?
Top-down vs. bottom-up
What does Story Macrostructure facilitate?
2
The ability to recognize gists or themes of passages.
Telling, retelling, or comprehending stories
What does Story Macrostructure help predict?
What will come next -> comprehend material
What limitations in Story Macrostructure do children with reading disabilities have?
(2)
Telling shorter, less complete, less organized stories
Remembering less detail
At what point in eduction are narratives the main focus?
Expository texts?
Early grades
Later grades
What are three types of Microstructures?
T-Units
C-Units
Clause
What are T units?
2
Main clause + all subordinate clauses
What are C-units?
3
An independent clause with its modifiers
One main clause with all subordinate clauses attached to it.
It cannot be further divided without its essential meaning disappearing
How do we determine C-Units?
Use Systematic Analysis of Language Transcripts (SALT)
What is a Clause?
Statement containing both a subject and a predicate
What is a Subject?
A noun phrase
What is a Predicate?
A verb phrase
What are two types of Macrostructures?
Comprehension-based measures
Productive measures
How can we implement Comprehension-Based Measures?
1+3
Questions about
- Setting
- Characters
- Events
How can we implement Productive Measures?
Have child generate a story
What kinds of Narrative Development that occur in Preschool?
(3)
Label simple descriptions of objects
Characters
Actions
What kinds of Narrative Development that occur in Early Elementary?
(5)
Goals
Intentions
Emotions
Theory of mind
Script for common characters (e.g., big bad wolf)
What kinds of Narrative Development that occur in Later Elementary?
(4)
More complex story
Overcoming obstacles
Awareness of time
Multiple meaning words
What kinds of Narrative Development that occur in Adolescents/Adults?
(3)
Connect 1st idea to 2nd idea
Multiple meanings
Themes
What does Content Schemata test?
Narrative development
How do we assess Content Schemata?
Have child tell story for wordless books, (Frog Goes to Dinner, Mercer Mayer)
What specifics do we assess in Content Schemata?
6
Characters
Actions
Sequence
Cause-effect
Plans of characters
Reactions of characters
Children with language delay/LLD will have _____ and ______ stories.
Shorter
Simpler
What are Explicit Questions?
Questions whose answers can be found directly in the text
Who are the characters Where did this story happen? What is an important part of the story What happened?
What are Implicit Questions?
Questions who answers are not directly in the text
(How does the person feel?
Why did the person do this What do you think the person would say? What should happen next?)
What is an example of an Informal Reading Inventory?
Qualitative Reading Inventory (QRI-V)
What does the Qualitative Reading Inventory (QRI-V) provide?
2
Narratives
Expository passages
What does the Qualitative Reading Inventory (QRI-V) ask children to do?
Listen to and answer both explicit and implicit questions
What are we assessing in the Qualitative Reading Inventory (QRI-V)?
Macrostructure in story retelling
e.g., setting, goal, events, resolutions, main ideas
What does the Test of Narrative Language (2004) assess?
2
Difficulties in narrative comprehension
Difficulties in narrative production
How does the Test of Narrative Language (2004) assess difficulty in narrative comprehension?
Remembering information from a story with drawings
How does the Test of Narrative Language (2004) assess Narrative Production?
Child produces a story given a picture, sequence, or no picture
How does RtI provide instruction to be successful comprehending text?
(3)
Tier 1 – Core program
Tier 2 – Focused supplemental services
Tier 3 – No progress with Tier 1 services. Child referred for full special education evaluation
How are SLPs involved in RtI?
3
Looking at Task Requirements
Documenting Strengths and Weaknesses of child
Differentiating Lesson Plans to share with teachers
What is the CONTENT portion of RtI’s Differentiated Content Instruction?
What the child should learn
What is the PROCESS portion of RtI’s Differentiated Content Instruction?
Varying activities and strategies used/presented
What is the PRODUCT portion of RtI’s Differentiated Content Instruction?
(4)
Using multiple formats for completing activity
Drawing
Written/oral report by hand/computer
Appropriate level of complexity
How do children develop Literate Vocabulary?
3
They hear it when read to by adults
Learning topic specific words
Learning Prefixes, Suffixes, and Root words
What is a child learning in Syntax Development?
4
Once upon a time…(relative clause “who” and “which”)
Literate conjunctions (because, but, except)
Descriptive vocabulary (“big eyes”, etc.)
Sentence structure
What is the goal of Accelerated Literacy?
To have students identify and use text patterns of authors
What is a child learning in Grammar Structure?
2
Explicit teaching of narratives increasing comprehension
Story maps
What are included in Story Maps?
2
Setting and Characters
Initiating event
What’s an example of a Story Grammar (with the beads)?
9
Main character (pompom)
Setting (star)
Kick-Off Event (shoe)
Feelings (heart)
Plan (hand)
Attempts (plain beads)
Obstacle (spool)
Direct Consequence (bow)
Resolution (heart)
Comprehension is ESSENTIAL if children are to be ___________.
Independent learners.
What are the two things SLPs do when working with text comprehension?
Assess
Teach
Microstructure involves both ______ and ______.
Vocabulary
Syntax
Macrostructure involves ______, and ______.
Content schema
Text grammar
Is the purpose of narratives or expository texts to entertain?
Narratives
Is the purpose of narratives or expository texts to inform?
Expository texts
Do narratives use familiar or unfamiliar schema content?
Familiar
Do expository texts use familiar or unfamiliar schema content?
Unfamiliar
Do narratives use consistent or variable content?
Consistent
Do narratives have the same basic organization?
Yes
Do expository texts use consistent or variable content?
Variable
Do expository texts have the same basic organization?
No - different genres have different structures
What three things do narratives focus on?
Character motivations
Character intentions
Character goals
What two things do expository texts focus on?
Factual information
Abstract ideas
What do narratives often require?
Multiple perspective taking
understanding points of view from different characters
What do expository texts expect of the reader?
To take the perspective of the author
What kind of inferences are needed to understand narratives?
Pragmatic
inferences from similar experiences
What kind of inferences are needed to understand expository texts?
Logical-deductive
based on information in the text
Are connective words critical in narratives?
What connective words are normally seen? (3)
No
//
And
Then
So
Are connective words critical in expository texts?
What connective words are normally seen? (6)
Yes
//
Because
Before
After
When
If-then
Therefore
Can narratives stand alone?
Yes
Can expository texts stand alone?
Why?
No
The reader is expected to integrate information across texts
How is comprehension normally assessed in narratives?
Informally in discussion
How is comprehension normally assessed in expository texts?
Formal, structured texts
What kind of processing is normally used to decipher narratives?
Top-down
What kind of processing is normally used to decipher expository texts?
Bottom-up
What are Descriptive expository texts?
The text tells you what something is
What are Sequence/Procedural expository texts?
The text tells you how to do something or make something
What are Cause/Effect expository texts?
The text gives you reasons for what something happens
What are Problem/Solution expository texts?
The text states a problem and offers solutions
What are Comparative/Contrast expository texts?
The text shows how two things are the same and/or different
What are Enumerative expository texts?
The text gives a list of things that are related to the topic
What are the six types of expository texts?
Descriptive
Sequence/Procedural
Cause/Effect
Problem/Solution
Comparative/Contrast
Enumerative