lecture 1 intro communite Flashcards
sheppard et al 2010 has cbc been succesful ghana hippo sanctory
yesd- built tabo against killing , 7-8 more develpoment other regions , ecotourism
grawak 1999 what has comunity traditionally been seen as?
ssmall area/numvber individuals= homogneos social strucutre= set shared understanding how recources should be used= desirable recource use and conservation outcomes
grawal, gibson 1999 what should focus when looking at community
-diffrernt interests and actors
-how influence decsion making
-internal and external instiutions that shapoe decsion making
-focus making instituions better rather community
garwal and gibson what is a institution
-formal and informal norms shape interactions human and nature
-mediate action
-show power relations actors
-help accomplish taks
garwal and gibson 199 solution CBC
-focus abilty community create & inforce rules
-need rights to remove representives
-settle disputes in community
-gov stop invation rights & intracommunity conflict
Garwal and Gibson 1999 alternative view coomunty
comm groups vary: Size, composition, norm, resource dependence= institutional aragment and proceeses decision making and enforcemnt= recorce managment outcome
garwal and gibson 199 how to improve cbc
-more checks and balances
-local groups more power & abilty negotiate gov
-improve decision making process
-give adequate funds implement decisions
kumar 2005 what is the concept of community in natural resource managementeant
-no agreed term com
- impossible to define
-assuption = misleading recource managment
titz et al 2018 what term com imply
people-centered, participatory, grass routes approach
tiltz et al 2018 why CBC come about
-top down approaches not working
neo-liberalsim not working
titz et al if no clear commnity what should we focus on
-people centered-
state litrature who and where working
examples of historic cbc
-protected forest ancient world
-hunting reserves
-sacred groves
why modern conservation start west
-redicovery romantic vision nature
-scientific exploration natural world
-concerns destruction nature
what differences uk and USA conservation
-uk= issue smal cramped polluted= romantic vision country side protect landscape
-usa - everexpanding frontier= overexploitation nature, need to manage nature better
whats utilitarian perspective conserving nature
-concern about inefficany waste
-science based managment
-instrumental value nature
-anthropogenic focus
-promote extractive value
when yellow stone national park created
1872
idea national park
wildness area free from people , top down created by the state
how did national park exclude indigonous people
-physical- eviction people
-economic- prevent extractive use
-political- no role managment gov
conservation key event 1940
-concern wildlife be slaughtered when colonies handed back to locals
-creastion game reserve hunting
example game reserve
Tsavo
What was main decision 1962 first world conference national parks
legal protection parks against all human exploitation
what occurd 1960 conservation
-hit mainstram
-1961 creation wwf
what key trend conservation 1980
rise community based conservation. e.g community forest nepal, community based managment park africa
what ethical reason CBC
-well being
-right recources
-
pragmatic reason CBC
-communism proves states not manage resources
-state lacked the capacity manage
recognition importance of custimory institutions
-limit idea wilderness
-idea natives manage better
what are different levels CBC participation
-passive beneficiary without power projects imposed
-active decision maker
(continuum)
what different objectives CBC
-gov promoting political reason
- devolopment agency promote improve food security reduce poverty
-conserve biodiversity
why was CBF in nepal
-states nationalised forest = degradation overexploitation
lacked ownership exploit much possible needed to change this stop overexploitation