James I: Religion and religious divisions Flashcards
describe the different religious groups of Britain in the 1600s:
- alongside a minority of Catholics, there were various Protestant groups with differing views on religious practices
- most people who identified with the Church of England were of a broad Protestant faith that had developed from Calvinism
what did Puritans believe?
believed the Church of England had not been sufficiently reformed
- wanted to make more radical changes to the English church which might upset the social order
- the ‘hotter sort of Protestantism’
what did Arminians believe?
Arminians were anxious to avoid ‘radical’ change and wanted to bring the State Church more in line with traditional Catholic practices
what reasons did English Protestants have a general hostility towards Catholics for?
- the Reformation
- the burning of Protestants when England briefly returned to Catholicism under the Catholic queen ‘Bloody’ Mary I (1555-58)
- war against Catholic Spain during Elizabeth’s reign
- they wanted toleration to worship in their own way which would undermine the uniformity of the country
- Catholics owed their allegiance to the Pope first and the monarch second and this meant that they recognised a higher authority than the king/queen in England
why were Catholics a threat?
- they wanted toleration to worship in their own way which would undermine the uniformity of the country
- Catholics owed their allegiance to the Pope first and the monarch second and this meant that they recognised a higher authority than the king/queen in England
how did Catholics react in this anti-Catholic climate?
Within this anti-Catholic climate, Catholics remained loyal to the English Crown as they had been since the Reformation
- by 1603, they were generally politically passive
what was James’ attitude to Catholics?
James was prepared to make a distinction between Catholics who were ‘quiet’ and those who were ‘factious’
- although it was counter to popular feelings of anti-Catholicism, it was a pragmatic way to avoid forcing moderate Catholics to challenge him directly
outline the Reformation:
- the British Isles divided along confessional lines following the Henrician Reformation in the 1530s
- resulted in religious diversity across the British Isles
(England, Wales and Scotland = Protestant, Ireland = Catholic) - the Church of England was governed by the monarchy
(Anglicanism)
who remained powerful after the Reformation?
the great powers of the continent, Spain and France remained Catholic and increasingly sought to combat the growth of Protestantism, known as the Counter-Reformation
what had Mary I done to Protestants during her five year reign? (reason to fear Catholics)
1553-58: during her five-year reign, Mary I had over 280 religious dissenters burned at the stake in the Marian persecutions
- deeply-seated fear of Catholics
what happened to Protestants in Paris in August 1572? (reason to fear catholics)
- August 1572: over 5,000 Protestants were killed in Paris in the St. Bartholomew’s Day massacre
outline the war between England and Spain in July 1588: (reason to fear Catholics)
- July 1588: the Spanish Armada, the most dominant Catholic power, set sail, planning to ferry an invasion force under the Duke of Parma to the coast of southeast England
- a combination of miscalculation, misfortune and an attack of English fire ships defeated the Armada
- aimed to restore Catholicism in England
- Spain remained at war with England until 1604 (Treaty of London)
what did English Catholics do in November 1605? (reason to fear Catholics)
1605: Catholic plotters, amongst whom was one Guido Fawkes, were caught during the course of preparations to blow up the Houses of Parliament
what were wider reasons to fear Catholics?
- the fear of Catholics during James I’s reign was real, but also disproportionate
- the main European powers were Catholic and were attached to the concept of absolutism
- Louis XIII of France and Phillip III of Spain
- the embryonic emergence of democracy at the start of the Stuart period in Britain meant Protestants became scared of absolutism
what was James’ beliefs surrounding the Divine Right of Kings?
As a strong believer in the Divine Right of Kings, James held the authority of the Church in high regard, and in return demanded obedience to himself as King and as the supreme authority in the Church
what was James’ own religious beliefs?
James was raised a Presbyterian (Scottish form of Calvinism) and was a loyal defender of Protestantism although he had misgivings about the radical nature of the Scottish Reformation
- Scottish kirk had no rigid hierarchy
- monarch would have less control - James doubted this
what was Presbyterianism?
- Presbyterianism was bitterly hostile to Catholicism and less hierarchical than the Church of England
- Whereas the Church of England was led by bishops appointed by the king, the Scottish Church was governed by elders and a democratically elected Synod
what was Calvinism?
- named after John Calvin (1509-64)
- the most influential figure of the Protestant Reformation apart from Martin Luther
- central belief in Calvinism was predestination and the need for elders who ran the Church to impose discipline on its members
- Calvinism became the dominant branch of Protestantism within the Church of England
why would Calvinism cause a problem for James?
- as the Calvinist Church and state were separate bodies, James may not have been able to use his divine prerogative as a way to exert control over the Church
- limited the scope for his power over the Scottish Kirk and gave more chance for rebellions
- Calvinism’s radical notion that you do not have to be entirely reliant upon the institution of the Church to be a good Christian (done by engaging with scripture) also an issue
what were James’ aims for religious policy?
- wanted to establish himself as Rex Pacificus (peacemaker King)
- pursuit of religious unity was guiding principle for religious policy -> paralleled the ‘reunion of Christendom’
- the creation of a middle way would allay extremes and enable moderates of all hues to co-exist peacefully within a broad national Church
- willing to be tolerant of religious diversity as long as they are loyal to the CoE
- ‘Christian union in religion…meet in the middest’
how did James attempt to restore religious unity to Christendom?
James regarded the fragmentation of Christianity (a consequence of the 16th century reformation) as a tragedy and he longed to restore religious unity to Christendom through marriage alliances
who did James attempt to create a marriage between?
- James spent much of the 1610s and 1620s negotiating a match between Charles and a daughter of the Spanish monarch Phillip III -> regarded as the archetypal Catholic sovereign
- James arranged for his daughter to marry Frederick V, the Elector Palatine, one of the main Protestant princes in the Holy Roman Empire (1613)
what do these marriage alliances suggest about James?
suggests that James doesn’t have an inherent disposition of Catholicism/Presbyterianism
- wants to establish concordance and harmony and doesn’t want a repeat of the Spanish Armada
How was James a moderate, but true, Protestant?
- the Puritans in England admired Presbyterianism as a more extreme version of protestantism than the Anglican Church and hoped for further concessions from James
- James, despite being raised in presbyterian Scotland, was not too keen on the radical nature of Presbyterianism
how did James continue Elizabeth’s legacy of a ‘middle way’ ?
James was willing to adopt the 1559 Act of Uniformity
- James appreciated the Anglican Church in part because of its hierarchical structure which was more stable than the Scottish Kirk
- James wanted to find harmony and unity across his three nations
how did James attempt to bring Catholics and Puritans towards the Church of England?
James sought to convince both Catholics and Puritans of the error of their ways and find a common home in the Church of England
why was religion everything in the 17th century?
- religion was a major political issue
- religious convictions were inseparable from politics
- religion bound up with power and politics
- religion remained the most radical and divisive issue of all with backlash against James’ religious reforms being the most significant
what example is there of religion being significant in politics?
- e.g. many MPs who objected to Charles I’s attempts to resolve his financial problems in the 1620s and 30s opposed him, but did not take up arms against him in the 1640s. In contrast, those MPs who opposed him on religious grounds did go to war against him
why were groups outside the nationally established Church a threat?
- those outside (religious nonconformists) might refuse to accept the authority of the national Church (heresy)
- made them a potential threat to the State and the King (treason)
how accepting was James of other Catholics?
James was willing to accept that the vast majority of a political Catholics were actually loyal
- wrote to the Earl of Northumberland and promised that: “I will neither persecute any (Catholics) that will be quiet”
- willing to be relatively tolerant for non-conformist groups outside the Protestant spectrum
how many people were Catholic in England?
Only 2-5% of the population in England were Catholic, mostly in remote northern or far west of England
how did English protestants have a fear of secret Catholics?
- might have been the case that there were millions of Catholics pretending to be Protestant but secretly waiting for the opportunity to overthrow the Anglican Church and violently restore Catholicism
- these people might destroy England from within
- also might be supported by Spain and or France
how did James’ pragmatism force him to fluctuate between toleration and severe treatment of Catholics?
James was forced by events and by pressure from Puritans in Parliament to deviate from his promise in 1603 to show tolerance to Catholics
what did James introduce in May 1603 and 1604 as anti-Catholic measures
- In May 1603 James ordered the collection of recusancy fines
- In 1604, Parliament encouraged legislation against Jesuits, a Catholic order of religious men
- In Feb 1604, he brought back recusancy (fines for not attending Church services) persecuting 5,560 Catholics
describe the Gunpowder Plot in November 1605:
- Catholics who viewed James’ actions as renewed persecution against their faith led to them conspiring to kill James and destroy the Houses of Parliament (exposed in Nov 1605)
- caused renewed anti-Catholic outcry
- The Plot confirmed the suspicions of most English people that all Catholics were potential traitors.
what did James introduce in 1606 as a result of the Gunpowder Plot?
As a result of the 1605 Gunpowder Plot, James introduced the 1606 Oath of Allegiance to force Catholic recusants to declare their allegiance to him and not to the Pope
did the Gunpowder Plot change James’ objective of a middle way?
- Not even the Gunpowder Plot deflected James from his overarching objective
- In James’ eyes, willingness to take the Oath of Allegiance provided the key test of Catholic moderation
- believed the recusancy laws should be primarily implemented against those Catholic ‘traitors’ who refused to take the oath