Charles I: Personal Rule -> extent of opposition to the Personal Rule in Scotland, Ireland and England Flashcards
What evidence of opposition in finance was there by 1637?
- Impositions and fiscal feudalism was bound to cause general unease, especially among the gentry
- reaction to the Hampden Case (1637)
What evidence is there of opposition in religion by 1637?
- (Re-) imposition of the Book of Sports (1633) led to objections from Puritans (and others)
- Laud’s Arminian reforms and the repositioning of the alter (St Gregory’s Case, 1633)
- The Puritan gentry turned against the King after the case of Burton, Prynne and Bastwick (1637)
What evidence is there of opposition in administration by 1637?
- Arbitrary powers of the Court of Star Chamber (presided over by Laud)
- Wentworth’s efficiency of ‘Thorough’ alienated many in Ireland
Why was opposition growing to the personal rule by 1637?
Combined together, finance, religion and administration led to a fear of creeping absolutism
- any criticism of the King could be punished severely in prerogative courts
What are some reasons why England has a history of tension with Sctoland?
- The Protestant Reformation had gone much further in Scotland than England - the Kirk was radically Calvinist (Presbyterian)
- Many Scots did not like the English - viewed as invaders and ‘oppressors’
- Charles only crowned King of Scotland in 1633 when he visited Edinburgh for the first time
What was the state of the Scottish army?
Many Scottish landlords maintained private armies
How were Scottish armies experienced?
They had been mobilised for the Protestant cause in the Thirty Years’ War
What was the reputation of the Scottish army?
Reputation for being tough warriors and good fighters, potentially dangerous for Charles
How was the English military unprepared since the 1490s?
Since the 1490s, England had become an essentially demilitarised nation - gentry abandoned waging war in favour of commercial pursuits
Where was the focus of English militarism?
At sea, not on land
What was the reputation of the English army?
Any local ‘mustering’ or training had been largely very amateurish and ineffective as the gentry ignored impositions regarding training of local militias
When was the Act of Revocation passed?
1625
What was the Act of Revocation?
A prerogative act passed by King Charles that reclaimed royal and church property that had been given away since 1540
What land did the Act of Revocation take?
Land from the Scottish elite (revoking all gifts by the Crown and the Kirk since 1540) to try to acquire their tithes in order to provide funding for the Scottish church
How did the Scottish react to the Act of Revocation?
- united sections of the Scottish nobility against Charles because it was done without reference to the Scottish Privy Council
- annoyed the clergy because the financial benefits they received were not equivalent for the increased control which the Act gave the Crown over the Church
Why did Charles want to impose religious conformity in Scotland?
Following his visit to Edinburgh in 1633, he was appalled by the Presbyterian’s lack of ceremony and he unscripted prayers
What did Charles impose in July 1637?
A new Book of Common prayer by Proclamation and did not consult the Scottish Privy Council, parliament or the Kirk
What angered some Scottish bishops in July 1637?
When they read the new Laudian prayer book in the pulpit
- when it was read for the first time in St Giles Cathedral in Edinburgh, an organised protest became a full blown riot
How did Charles respond to bishops trying to persuade him to modify the prayer book?
Charles rebuked this and issued a new set of ecclesiastical canons in 1635 which required the Scottish clergy to swear to enforce the new liturgy before it was even published
How did the lowland Scots accept some reform to the Church of Scotland?
They accepted the reintroduction of bishops
Why did Charles reintroduce bishops into the Church of Scotland?
To entrench hierarchy in the Church which would enhance royal power
How did Scotland view the promotion of Arminianism?
A threat to the ‘true’ religion and the work of ‘Popery’ and the devil
What happenedin the riot at St Giles Cathedral on 23 July 1637?
- Dean Hannah tried to read the service from the new liturgy
- Jenny Geddes threw her stool at the Dean
Who was the cause of the Scottish Revolution and why?
Charles as he cut himself off from influential Scottish opinion and ignored the growing discontent
What alienated the Scots?
Charles’ imposition of religious uniformity, especially with the role of bishops because Scotland was a predominantly Presbyterian population who regarded bishops with suspicion
What was the Political reaction to the Book of Common Prayer in Scotland?
- An emergency body known as ‘The Tables’ was formed to organise opposition
- Feb 1638: They drew up the National Covenant at Greyfriars Kirk in Edinburgh
- Nov 1638: the General Assembly of the Kirk abolished Scotland’s bishops completely, depriving the King of his ability to influence the Scottish Kirk
Why was the prayer book rebellion in 1637 a turning point for Charles’ gov?
- Charles encountered opposition in all three kingdoms
- the defiance of the Scots set in motion a train of events that led to defeat in the Bishops’ Wars and ultimately, the outbreak of civil war
When was the National Covenant formulated?
In February 1638
What was the National Covenant?
- Written mainly by Presbyterian radicals Archibald Johnston of Wariston and Alexander Henderson
- it was a manifesto to unite those against Charles’ religious policy and to maintain Presbyterianism as the main Scottish religion
What did the National Covenant contain?
- The Confession of Faith of 1580 (affirmation of Calvinist faith)
- The ‘Negative Confession’ of 1581 (condemnation of Catholicism and the Papacy which had become the test for public office)
- Condemnation of the 1635 ecclesiastical canons and the 1637 Prayer Book