Historiography Flashcards
1549 Rebellions were serious
Guy- closest thing to a class war
Wood- sharpness in social conflict
Beer- government was initially poorly prepared
Duffy- Somerset was slow to register the seriousness of the Western Rebellion
1549 Rebellions were not serious
Beer- remainder of the country remained quiet and orderly
Fletcher- the rebellion never had a real chance of forcing the government to make concessions in its religious policy
Causes of Kett’s Rebellion
Loades- angry men who felt laws and customs were being eroded
Fletcher- breakdown of trust between governing class and local government
Causes of Western Rebellion
A.F. Pollard- mostly social causes. Social movement
Beer- Religion was one of the major forces
Causes of Wyatt’s Rebellion
Fletcher and MacCulloch - restore Protestantism
Guy- motives were uncertain. Religion was an important issue
Tittler- didn’t want a Spanish king
Wyatt Rebellion was serious
Fletcher- Wyatt came closer than any other rebel to toppling a monarch from the throne.
Lee- dangerous threat to Mary’s position
Wyatt Rebellion wasn’t serious
Guy- failed due to Mary’s resolve, Wyatt’s delay and peoples fear
MacCulloch- no major difficulty to defeat rebellion
Tittler- Queen and Council made the right decisions
Causes of the Northern Rebellion
Kesselring- norfolk marriage plot
Haigh- overthrown Protestantism
MacCaffrey- failure of Norfolk/ Mary plot forced Westmorland and Northumberland into rebellion
Northern Rebellion was serious
Kesselring- serious due to marriage conspiracy
Northern Rebellion not serious
Haigh- rebels attempt was ‘botched’ (clumsy, careless). Also, Leicester raised army
Tillbrook- power of northern nobles was broken so there was less opposition
Essex Rebellion
Guy- fiasco of a rebellion
Williams- Essex’s supporters had lost touch political reality
Simpson- not serious and not provoked by government
Gajda- shambolic and confusing
Edward’s rule-negative
Pollard and Bindoff- weak and squandered his inheritance
Elton- easily swayed and exercised little influence
Edward’s rule- positive
Loades- faced great economic strains
Guy- England was not worse than other countries
Hoak- Edward deserves more recognition
Somerset- positive
Durant- intelligent and courageous
Jordan- ‘good Duke’
Pollard and Tawney- social idealist
Bernard- Privy Council supported him wholly
Somerset- negative
Hoak- forgot he wasn’t king
Bush- his problems were of his own creation. Obsessed with Scotland at the expense of other policies
Elton- he was high-handed (used power more forcefully than needed)
Guy- his economic policies were the worst
Religious changes under Somerset
Motives
Loach- for his own power
Hoak- not driven by Godly agenda. Wanted to strengthen his position
Religious changes under Somerset
Effects
Duffy- ‘sweeping changes’
MacCulloch- laid the foundations but only a minority actively supported them
Causes for overthrow of Somerset
Jones- factional fighting
Haigh- inability to handle rebellions of 1549
Northumberland- negative
Pollard and Fronde- ‘wicked Duke’
Jordan- didn’t have that much power
Guy- chaotic policies
Like Somerset, he became a quasi-king
Haigh- economic crisis as people stopped donating to Crown due to dislike of religious policies
Northumberland- positive
Jordan- loyal to Edward
Hoak- one of the most remarkably able governors of the 16th Century
Tittler- successful but cared little for religion
Bush- Somerset worse, N drew government back together
Religion under Northumberland
Motives
MacCulloch- Edward’s influence
Loades and MacCulloch- became more Protestant himself
Religion under Northumberland
Effects
Duffy- flood-tide of radicalism
Haigh- broke decisively with the past. Harsh crown policies led to a change in belief
Mary-positive
Guy- financial reforms were surprisingly successful. Military reforms laid the foundations for Elizabeth
Loades- fruitful (but after marriage her reign lost momentum)
Tittler- failures due to natural disasters, not her own mistakes. Her government was considerably effective
Mary- negative
Guy- never appear creative
Lee- Parliament tested her power
Prescott- easily swayed by emotions
Harris- marriage was the root of her failures
Pollard-sterile
Religion under Mary- positive
Duffy- terrible as the burnings were, they were working. The majority was glad to be Catholic again. Few Protestants
Pogson and Tittler- Catholicism was popular by 1558
Bindoff- unopposed revival
Loach- little genuine opposition to the Counter Reformation
Haigh- religion was one of the element’s of Mary’s appeal
Religion under Mary- negative
MacCulloch- Marian Church was inept and unimaginative
Loades- only grudging acceptance
Pollard- swimming against the tide of history as the dominant religion was Protestantism
Dickens- inevitably doomed
Lotherington-Protestantism benefitted from her reign