group decisions Flashcards
what are 4 disadvantages of group decision making?
- conformity
- authority
- polarisation
- groupthink
what are 2 advantages of group decision making?
- wisdom of the crowd
- improved reasoning
what did asch (1956) discover about conformity?
individuals conform to the group answer in the line length paradigm
how did authority cause the 1977 jet collision?
the engineer didnt challenge the captains
what did alkov et al (1992) discover about authority?
accidents increase when officers of a different rank occupy the cockpit - only 40% of junior co-pilots relay concerns to senior captains
what did myers & kaplan (1975) discover about polarisation?
we make different decision when we discuss with others
what did janis (1982) say about groupthink?
there are cohesive groups striving for unanimity and avoid conflict
what did kurvers et al (2016) discover about doctors and wisdom of the crowd?
groups of doctors with similar levels of diagnostic accuracy outperform the best doctor of the group
what did herzog & hertwig (2009) find about dialectical bootstrapping?
arguing with your own estimates increases accuracy of estimates
what did sasaki & pratt (2011) discover about collective rationality in ants?
ants chose better nests and avoided decoy nests as a group compared to individuals
what is improved reasoning?
groups do better than individuals alone, except for groups of 2
what did moshman & geil (1998) find about improved reasoning in the card turning task?
9% chose right when individuals but 75% chose right when chose as groups
what did laughlin et al (2006) find about improved reasoning in the letter and number equation?
groups did better than individuals