G.Roles, DDOL, power R.ships, dark side Flashcards
What was the family before industrialisation?
Unit of production - greater equality between genders
Why does Parsons argue that there is a DDOL in Rships?
Functionalist Roles of husband + wife = separate + distinct Best meets needs of S Husband = instrumental (financial needs) Wife = expressive (emotional needs) W = 'naturally' suited to these roles (biological difference) DDOL benefits individuals + S (New Right agree)
What did Bott find about GR/ DDOL?
Social network of friends = most influential factor in determining whether couple has joint/ serrate roles
Tight knit, regular contact, separate GR
Social network acted as social control
Ensures couples didn’t differ from traditional GR (by teasing)
Loose knit, less constraints, more likely to have shared conjugal roles
Using Bott’s ideas, what could be predicted?
As geographical + social mobility continues in contemporary S, social network will continue to weaken
Couples = have more reliance on each partners
Leading to ROLE INTEGRATION
3 criticisms of Bott’s work/ study?
- Only in 1 area, can’t generalise
- Likely to all be same social class
- Only 20 families, can’t generalise
What is a strength to Bott’s work/ study?
Based on empirical evidence :)
Describe Willmott + Young’s study
Structured telephone interviews
wc nuclear families, Bethnal Green
1950s: traditional separate conjugal roles
M: breadwinner, leisure time = with friends, played little part in home life
W = full-time housewives
1970s: MOP, family grad = more egalitarian
Roles of husband + wife = NOT identical but more similar (symmetrical family - social change)
ID 5 characteristics of symmetrical family
‘Emergence of the new man’
72% of husbands now ‘helped in the house’
What are the 3 characteristics of a symmetrical family that Willmott + Young ID?
- Nuclear instead of classically extended
- Home-centred (leisure time spent together)
- Based on going conjugal roles (share domestic work/ childcare)
What % of husbands does Willmott and Young now claim ‘help in the house’?
72%
Describe Willmott + Young’s concept of the ‘emergence of a new man’?
Result of greater equality within family
Increasing number of females as breadwinners (trad male) + men doing housework (trad female)
Men also more in touch with emotions + family life
Led to rise in SYMMETRICAL FAMILIES
What do Willmott + Young see as the cause of the increasing number os symmetrical families?
Major social changes which have occurred in the least century
SOCIAL POLICIES
Why do Silver + Schor argue that families are becoming more equal?
New technology + labour-saving devices COMMERCIALISATION OF HOUSEWORK Housework takes less time + = easier More men = likely to do it BUT despite the increase in ease, W still do majority of tasks
How can the standards of living have led to families becoming more equal?
= higher standards of living
Need 2 incomes to reach it
What are 3 criticisms of Willmott + Young’s work?
- Sample - generalise?
- Telephone interviews - empirical evidence?
- Even though men do more housework, = still gendered (W = cleaning, M = DIY, gardening
- Oakley - dual burden
Why does Oakley criticise Willmott + Young?
Carried out a study on housework
Argues that 72% of men claiming to do housework ISN’T evidence of symmetry within the family
W still do most of housework + childcare
Wives = acquired DUAL BURDEN
Family remains patriarchal - men benefit from women wages + unpaid domestic work
Describe Oakley’s study on housework
Interviewed 40 women from London
Aged 20-30, all had 1 child under age 5
FEMINIST METHODOLOGY
15% husbands = ‘high level’ participation in housework
25% husbands = ‘high level’ participation in childcare
Criticisms of Oakley’s study
- Small sample
- 1 area
- Culture bias?
- Only asked women
- ‘High level’ = subjective, how do you operationalise it?
Why do Dunscombe + Marsden (1995) argue that the family isn’t symmetrical?
Discuss impact of W’s emotional work
- manage own + others emotions
Usually seen as a labour of love
Dual burden + emotional work = TRIPLE SHIFT