Childhood Flashcards
What does Wagg (1992) argue about childhood?
= no one universal experience of childhood
= social construct (created + defined by S)
What can be used as evidence to support Wagg’s view of childhood?
Cross cultural studies
Pilcher/ Malinowski
Why does the west generally view children as fundamentally different to adults? (4)
- Physically + psychologically immature
- In need of protection
- In need of socialisation (learn to become an adult)
- Not yet competent to run their own lives
What does Pilcher argue about the western view of childhood?
Childhood = separate, distinct life stage
What are the 4 ways that Pilcher argues that childhood is separate?
- Laws (different + ones to protect)
- Different products + services
- Different lifestyle/ activities (CH = golden age)
- Seen as innocent + vulnerable
Describe Punch’s (2001) work on CH?
How is this different to the Western view?
Research on children in Bolivia
SHE found at age 5, children = expected to have work responsibilities in home + community
West, children = in school at age 5
Describe Malinowski’s (1957) work on CH?
How is this different to the Western view?
Research on Trobriand Islanders
Found they have tolerant view of child’s sexuality
Adults have ‘amused interest’ in child becoming sexually aware
= tolerant of them exploring their sexuality
West, children = viewed as innocent (until 16)
What 2 things do most sociologists agree upon in terms of CH?
- = fairly recent notion
2. Changed significantly over time, social construct (further support for Wagg)
What was Aries (1960) view on childhood?
Children in the Middle Ages = ‘mini adults’
What does Aries call the 20th century?
‘Century of the child’
What was CH like in the 10-13 century according to Aries?
Adults and children have the same: rights, jobs + clothes
What changes to CH occurred in the late 13th century according to Aries?
Schools became focused on educating young
Prev aslo educated adults
How does Aries describe CH during the 17th century?
Clothes = separate
Children becoming visually separate
What was introduced in the 18th century?
Why was this significant for Aries?
Handbooks on child rearing became available
Beginning of child-centered family life
What changes does Aries see in the 20th century for children? (2)
- Childhood is seen as a very special time
2. ‘The century of the child’
What does Aries call the 20th century?
What has this led to?
‘The century of the child’
CH = seen as very special time
Led to modern ‘cult of CH’
S = obsessed with CH
What are the 2 strengths of Aries’ work?
- Evidence that CH = socially constructed
- Supported by Shorter (1975)
- when IMR = high parents placed less value on them; wouldn’t live past age 1
How would Shorter (1975) support Aries?
Argues when IMR = high, parents placed less value on them (wouldn’t live past age 1)