Endocrine Surgery JC039: A Thyroid Nodule: Benign Thyroid Nodules, Thyroid Cancer Flashcards
Thyroid nodule
Prevalence:
- Extraordinary common
- Depends on:
—> Iodine deficiency (some area endemic)
—> Ionising radiation exposure
—> Female gender
—> Advanced age
—> Method of detection (palpation lower rate of detection, USG / autopsy higher rate of detection)
Thyroid cancer
- Not so common, but ↑ incidence due to detection of small papillary carcinoma
- Mortality remains low
- Size <1-2 cm
Classification of Goitre
Classified according to etiologies, morphological changes, functional changes, pathological changes
- Simple goitre (endemic / sporadic)
- Diffuse
- *Nodular - Toxic goitre (hyperfunctioning)
- Diffuse toxic (Graves’)
- *Toxic nodular (Plummer’s aka Toxic MNG)
- *Toxic / Functioning adenoma - *Neoplastic goitre
- Benign
- Malignant - Thyroiditis (Inflammatory cause)
- Bacterial (acute suppurative)
- Viral (subacute)
- Lymphocytic / Hashimoto / Autoimmune (chronic)
*: commonly detected by USG / palpation
Simple / Non-toxic, Diffuse / Nodular goitre
Definition:
1. Any thyroid enlargement (most common giving rise to goitre)
2. Not a result of neoplasia / inflammation (i.e. thyroiditis)
3. No thyroid dysfunction (i.e. normal TFT)
4. Endemic (∵ iodine deficiency, area of >10% patient with clinically palpable goitre) / Sporadic
5. Morphological changes: Uninodular / Multinodular (MNG) / Dominant nodule in MNG
Clinical presentation of Thyroid nodule
- Neck swelling / mass
- Pain / discomfort / obstructive feeling
-
Local pressure symptoms
- Dysphagia
- Choking
- SOB etc. - Voice disturbance / hoarseness (usually ∵ trachea compression of trachea, uncommon due to nerve palsy —> usually only by malignant nodule)
- Thyroid dysfunction (Hyper / Hypothyroidism)
- Incidental:
- P/E
- Imaging: USG (of carotid artery), CXR (tracheal deviation, compression, soft tissue mass), CT/MRI, PET scan
Pathology of Thyroid nodule
- Nodular goitre (most common, 70%) (e.g. MNG)
- Colloid
- Haemorrhagic cystic (old / new blood)
- Complex
- Hyperplastic
- Adenomatous nodule
—> all are just descriptive terms of nodules - Benign Follicular Adenoma (15%)
- mainly non-toxic
- some maybe hyperfunctioning -
Well-differentiated thyroid carcinoma (10%)
- Follicular / Papillary
(Anaplastic = Undifferentiated) - Miscellaneous (5%)
- Other thyroid malignancies
- Thyroiditis (usually diffuse enlargement, but can present atypically as nodules)
Clinical risk factors for malignancy of thyroid nodules
- Extreme of age
- elderly / young (papillary carcinoma)
- female (nodular goitre) - Previous neck irradiation
- Geographic (radiation exposure, endemic goitre)
- Family history
- Medullary thyroid carcinoma (1/3 familial)
- Papillary / Follicular carcinoma no family association - Pressure symptoms
- indicate rapid growth - Solitary vs Multiple nodules
- Solitary: more likely cancer - Nodule characteristics (size, consistency, fixation)
- Presence of cervical LN
- occult thyroid cancer can present with cervical LN without palpable nodules in thyroid gland -
RLN palsy
- damage of RLN by malignant tumour
Investigations of Thyroid nodule
Routine
1. TFT
- ultrasensitive TSH +/- Free T4
2. USG evaluation
3. FNAC
Specific
4. Other blood tests
- ESR
- Thyroid Ab (TPO (Thyroid peroxidase antibodies), ATA (Anti-thyroid antibodies))
- Calcitonin (Medullary thyroid carcinoma)
- Genetic testing (TSH receptor mRNA RT-PCR)
- Imaging
- Radioscintigraphy (IV radioisotope (I123 / Tc99m) + gamma camera)
- CXR
- CT
- MRI
- PET - Endoscopy
- Direct laryngoscopy
- OGD
Surgical
7. Thyroidectomy: Diagnostic +/- Therapeutic
USG
- B-mode real-time scanner: 7.5 / 10 mHz probes
- Non-invasive, no radiation hazard, convenient and cheap
- High sensitivity (2-3 mm nodules) but low specificity (cannot confirm nature)
Role:
1. Extend P/E
2. Guide needle aspiration
3. For all patients with goitre / palpable nodule
4. Should NOT be performed as a screening test
5. Guide but cannot confirm diagnosis
5 categories of USG findings:
Category 1: Benign
- cystic
Category 2: Very low suspicion
- spongiform
- partially cystic
Category 3: Low suspicion
- hyperechoic / isoechoic
Category 4: Intermediate suspicion —> FNAC may be needed
- hypoechoic
Category 5: High suspicion —> FNAC may be needed
- microcalcification
- irregular margin
- marked hypoechoic
- taller than wide (indicate infiltrative)
- extrathyroidal extension
FNAC
4 cytology results:
- Benign (negative): <1% chance malignancy
- Malignant (positive): >99% chance malignancy
- Non-diagnostic (unsatisfactory due to sampling technique / no thyroid cells collected): <3% chance malignancy
- Suspicious (indeterminate): 20% chance malignancy
Bethesda classification:
Category 1: Non-diagnostic —> Repeat FNA
Category 2: Benign —> Clinical follow up
Category 3: AUS (atypia of undetermined significance) / FLUS (follicular lesions of undetermined significance) (10% chance malignancy) —> Repeat FNA
Category 4: Follicular neoplasm —> Surgical lobectomy (to arrive at diagnosis + prevent spread via capsular / vessel)
Category 5: Suspicious of malignancy (60-75% chance malignancy) —> Surgical lobectomy + Total thyroidectomy
Category 6: Malignant —> Total thyroidectomy
Molecular assay application of FNAC
- BRAF, N/H/K-RAS, RET-PTC1/PTC3, PAX8/PPARc
- BRAF mutation: 40-64%
- panel of mutations: 63-80% accuracy
- specific but not sensitive: high PPV (rule-in test) (有false negative) - Gene expression classifier (167 genes)
- high sensitivity but not specific with high NPV (rule-out test) (有false positive) - Gene sequencing classifier
- higher specificity + improved PPV
Indication:
- For suspicious / indeterminate nodule (Category 3 / 4 in Bethesda)
Disadvantage:
- Expensive + limited availability
ATA guidelines in management of Thyroid nodule
USG evaluation (Sonographic pattern) + FNAC criteria
Suspected thyroid nodule
—> USG thyroid
—> 5 Sonographic patterns (High / Intermediate / Low / Very low suspicion / Benign)
—> Nodules >=1cm (<1 cm FNAC not required ∵ microcarcinoma is not aggressive and can be observed)
—> FNAC (except if benign —> FNAC not required)
—> Bethesda classification
—> Manage accordingly
—> Indeterminate / Malignant —> Surgery advised
Radioisotope scintigraphy
IV radioisotope (I123 / Tc99m) + gamma camera
Indications:
- Diagnosis of malignancy
- 10-20% cold nodules malignant (low specificity)
- hot / warm nodules rarely malignant - Functional assessment in Thyrotoxic patient
- Graves’
- Toxic adenoma
- Toxic nodular goitre
Disadvantages:
- Radiation exposure, expensive, low specificity + sensitivity
Other investigations
- CXR (tracheal compression / deviation, retrosternal goitre, mediastinal mass)
- CT / MRI
- anatomical relationship with surrounding mediastinal structures - PET scan
- Laryngoscopy
- hoarseness of voice (unilateral cord palsy ∵ RLN invasion by thyroid cancer)
Indications of operation for Benign thyroid nodules / Nodular goitre
- Pressure symptoms (size of goitre / nodule >4cm)
- Tracheal compression / deviation
- ↑ Goitre size
- Retrosternal extension (compressive symptoms)
- Suspected malignancy
- Cosmetic considerations / patient wish
Surgical treatment of Benign thyroid nodules
- Unilateral lobectomy (Hemithyroidectomy)
- for Uninodular goitre
- safe, minimal morbidities, can be diagnostic, curative
- reoperation on contralateral lobe without added difficulty
- ~10% chance hypothyroidism - Total thyroidectomy (Bilateral thyroidectomy)
- for MNG
- additional surgical risk (Hypoparathyroidism)
- no recurrence
- needs long-term thyroxine replacement
Alternative treatment of Benign thyroid nodules
Need probe
1. Radiofrequency ablation (RFA)
2. Percutaneous laser ablation (LA)
3. Microwave ablation (MWA)
No need probe
4. High-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU)
5. Ethanol injection after aspiration (for Cystic nodule)
Nodules will not disappear, only shrink —> max response in 6 months
Cystic nodules: cannot use 1-4 (since only boil the cyst content)
Cannot replace surgery as a definitive treatment
Thyroid carcinoma: Histological types
Major histologic type:
1. Well differentiated (90%) (very good prognosis)
- Papillary (80-90%)
- Follicular (10-20%)
- Poorly differentiated (Insular) (5%) (rare, in elderly)
- Undifferentiated (Anaplastic) (5%)
- Medullary carcinoma (5%) (neuroendocrine tumour: arise from Parafollicular C cells)
- Others (1%)
- Lymphoma (can be treated without surgery if a definitive diagnosis can be made beforehand —> main treatment: chemotherapy)
- SCC
- Sarcoma
- Metastasis
Well-differentiated thyroid carcinoma (WDTC)
Management considerations:
1. Extent of thyroidectomy
- hemithyroidectomy vs total thyroidectomy
- Nature + Extent of LN / neck dissection
- prophylactic / therapeutic
- central / lateral compartments - Post-op adjuvant therapies
- Radioiodine I131 ablation
- External beam irradiation
- T4 suppressive therapy —> suppress TSH to ↓ tumour recurrence
Risk groups:
- stratified based on
—> AJCC pTNM staging (stage 1-4) (prognostic + management significance)
—> AMES (age, metastasis, extent, size of tumour)
—> determines extent of surgery (TT), need for adjuvant therapy
Low risk:
- 85-90% of patients
- 2-5% mortality
- 10% recurrence
High risk:
- 10-15%
- 40-50% mortality
- 45% recurrence
PTC Histological variants
Relatively good prognosis
1. Papillary microcarcinoma
2. Encapsulated variant
3. Follicular variant
4. Tall cell / columnar variant
More aggressive, more likely to metastasise on presentation, treated as high risk tumour irrespective of size / stage
4. Diffuse sclerosing
5. Oxyphilic cell (Hurthle cell) type
Low risk PTC
Definition:
- Stage 1, 2 (<55 yo + without distant metastasis)
- <2 cm (T1) / 4 cm (T2)
- no invasion
- no LN metastasis
- majority as Papillary microcarcinoma (PTMC): <1 cm
- survival: ~100%
2 choices of management:
1. Total thyroidectomy
- commonly for multifocal + bilateral disease
- allow RAI ablation + Thyroglobulin monitoring to detect recurrence
- low morbidity rate by experienced surgeons
- Hemithyroidectomy
- excellent survival + low recurrence
- avoid T4 replacement (only 10-20% chance of hypothyroidism)
- lower morbidity
—> Overtreatment vs Potential benefits
—> Patients’ vs Physicians’ preference
PTC: Cervical LN management
Management:
1. Central (level 6): same incision as thyroidectomy
- possibly prophylactic / routine —> can detect micrometastasis
- ↓ in disease recurrence / reoperations
- upstaging disease (if detect micrometastasis) + ↑ use of I131
- ↑ in morbidity: hypoparathyroidism
- Lateral (level 2-5): extend / separate incision
- usually therapeutic, rarely prophylactic
- for clinically involved nodes: USG +/- FNAC
- excision (Berry-picking)
- modified / functional / selective neck dissection (usually no need radical dissection, ∵ thyroid cancer slow growing)
Adjuvant therapy for PTC: Post-op I131
- Preceded by Total / Near-total thyroidectomy
-
Thyroxine withdrawal (for 4 weeks beforehand) vs Thyrogen (Synthetic TSH 1-2 days beforehand)
—> allow ↑ TSH production from pituitary
—> ↑ Iodine uptake by residual thyroid tissue / tumour cells
Indication:
1. High risk (stage 3/4 disease)
- gross persistent / residual disease
- nodal / distant metastasis
- Low risk (selected stage 1, 2)
- destroy occult microscopic foci
- facilitate disease surveillance
- 1.1 GBq (30mCi) vs 3.7 GBq (100mCi) (both as effective)
- require individual patient preference
- beware short + long-term adverse effects
Papillary thyroid microcarcinoma (PTMC)
Very common thyroid cancer
Definition:
WHO: <1cm + detected incidentally
AJCC pTNM staging: <1cm + detected incidentally + majority pT1a / stage 1 disease (can have exception e.g. metastasis)
Feature:
- Extremely low risk
- Excellent survival
- Less aggressive treatment (Hemithyroidectomy unless already LN / distant metastasis)
—> can even Observe only (very low risk of ↑ in size / nodal metastasis)