Detection of Malingering Flashcards
Facial Expressions and Lying
Least reliable clue. Pleasantness incorrectly associated w/ honesty
Feigned Smiles
More likely to be asymmetrical
Voice vs. Visual Clues
Attention to voice > visual clues for lie detection
General Point About Lying Clues
Only valid if subject is anxious/variation from baseline
7 Content Clues of Lying
- Shorter answers
- More grammatical errors
- More slips of the tongue
- More negative statements
- More irrelevant statements in response to Qs (but if part of narrative, more truthful)
- More overgeneralized/vague statements
- Distance b/w listener with passive voice and hedging statements
3 Vocal Clues of Lying
- Higher pitched tone
- More hesitant answers
- Seem more rehearsed
4 Physical Cues of Lying
- More self-manipulating gestures
- More discrepancy b/w verbal/nonverbal communication
- Blink eyes more often
- Pupils more dilated
6 Mistaken Clues Not Actually Associated w/ Lying
- Less eye contact
- Shifty eyes
- Smile less
- Shift posture more
- Speak more slowly
- Take longer to answer Q
% Healthy Population Sometimes Experience AH
10-15%
Non-Psychotic AH (5)
Childhood onset
Attribute to dead people or guardian angels
Very little negative content
No distress/disturbance/fear/troublesome
More in control
Non-Psychotic VH % of Pop
14-18%
Non-psychotic VH
Usually dead relative, women see 4x more than men
AH/VH Split in Schiz
66% AH, 33% VH (almost always along with AH)
Mania AH/VH Split
AH 47%, VH 23%
Organic Brain Syndromes VH Alone
33%
5 General Traits Faked Hallx
- More frightening/abusive
- More uncontrollable
- More unbearably distressing
- Less predictable
- Less context dependent
Gender Based AH Insults
Women: Promiscuity
Men: Homosexuality
Hallx Qs
Ask why pt is doing something, etc. NOT asking information (what time is it, etc?). Pts view voices as OMNISCIENT
4 Strategies that Reduce Genuine Schiz AH
- Specific activities (working out, watching TV, etc)
- Changes in posutres (lie down, walk)
- Seek out interpersonal contact
- Taking medication
3 Factors that Worsen AH
- Being alone
- Watching TV
- Listening to radio
Most Common VH
Usually normal sized people in color
Lilliputian VH
Small people, often in alcoholic/toxic/atropine/penduncular psychosis
Eyes Open/Closed
Don’t affect psychotic hallx. Drug-induced more likely eyes closed
Unformed Hallx - Flashes of Light/Color
Neurologic ds
Visual Hallx > 60y/o
Often eye path/cataracts
3 Malingered Cognitive Deficit Tests
TOMM
VIP (Validity Indicator Profile)
VSVT (Victoria Symptom Validity)
4 Malingered Sx Tests
SIRS
MMPI-2
MFAST
SIMS