Contract Practice Flashcards
What is the difference between a warranty and a bond?
- Bonds are a means of protection against the non-performance of the contractor.
- Collateral warranties are agreements which are associated with another ‘primary’ contract. They provide for a duty of care to be extended by one of the contracting parties to a third party who is not party to the original contract. (Such as the Client and a Sub-Contractor)
Can the Client / Contractor terminate a contract if either party becomes insolvent?
Yes
What is change control?
A process that ensures potential changes to the deliverables of a project or the sequence of work in a project, are recorded, evaluated, authorised and managed
What is a variation?
Alterations or modifications to the design, quality or quantity of the contract works, to the site access or working conditions
Why might a Variation arise?
- change to spec etc
- discrepancy between contract documents
- discrepancy with statutory requirements
- errors and omissions
- deficiency in employer’s requirements
Can the contractor object to a variation?
In accordance with clause 13.1(a) of the Hong Kong Standard Building Contract yes.
- Site Access
- Use of the site
- Limitation of working space or working hours
How soon does a contractor have to comply with an instruction?
Forthwith
What can the Architect (PM) do if they don’t?
- He can issue a compliance notice
- If there is still no action by the contractor within 7 days, others can be employed to carry out that work and the additional cost charged to the contractor
What are the valuation rules in the HKSBC?
There are three rules for measurable work:
- Additional or substituted work which can be properly valued by measurement
- Works which are subject to provisional quantities or sums
- Works involved in the expenditure of provision sums
What is quantum meruit?
Translates to ‘the amount deserved’. It is used to refer to a claim for a reasonable sum, such as when a contractor seeks payment for work which has not been determined by a contract.
Who can instruct change?
Depending on the form of contract. Standard form of contract it is typically the Architect, in my experience this role has been transferred to the Project Manager on behalf of the Client.
How do you price change?
I will work with my QS team using the rates agreed in the SOR
What is an Extension of Time (EOT)?
Adjustment to the completion date and relieves the contractor’s liability to pay liquidated damages for the period of the extension (Listed Events)
What clause within the HKSBC is the EOT Clause?
Clause 25
Does an EOT always give rise to additional money to the Contractor?
No
Why does an EOT not always qualify for additional money?
As the delay cause could be at no fault to either party (Force Majeure - Covid-19)
What is loss and Expense (L&E)?
Reimburses the contractor for direct loss and/or expense incurred in carrying out additional work or from an employer’s breach of contract (Qualifying Events)
What clause within the HKSBC is the L&E Clause?
Clause 27
What would qualify the contractor to be entitled to a L&E in the HKSBC?
The contract stipulates a list of Qualifying Events which the contractor is able to make a claim in respect of
What are the procedures for claiming loss and expense under the HKSBC?
The Contractor shall in writing and within 28 days of becoming apparent of an event may give rise to claim or within 7 days of receiving a claim from a NSC issue formal notice.
The Contractor should also as soon as practicable / within 60 days of giving the first notice submit the following:
- Particulars giving rise to the claim
- the amount of the claim
- detailed build
- Copy of the records kept
If Contractor cannot provide this within the 60 day period a notice should be issued to the Architect (PM) to that effect and issue interim particulars
What are the procedures for claiming EOT under the HKSBC?
The contractor must first give a notice of delays in writing within 28 days of the commencement of likely delay that could cause delay to the completion date becoming apparent.
First Notice:
- state the lowlihood and estimated length of delay
- state material circumstance including the cause of delay
- State if they consider they may become entitled to an EOT and if so by which Listed Event.
Second Notice:
- As soon as practicable but within 28 days of the first notice, provide substantiation that “the listed” event is the cause of delay
- Particulars of the cause and effect and length of delay.
How do you fix a new completion date?
After receipt of the contractors second notice, within 60 days of receipt providing the listed event is valid.
What are the basic requirements of Contractors All Risk Insurance?
- Costs and Expenses in respect of propping up or opening up works etc.
- Extra costs for express freight / air freight
- overtime labour costs
- Damage to works / plant
- Stolen goods / inventory without being traceable
Can you list out the contents page of the HKSBC
- Articles of Agreement
- Attestation
- General Conditions
- Interpretation and Definitions
- Contractors Obligations
- Master Programme
- Architect Instructions
etc.
What documents form the Contract Documents?
- Articles of Agreement
- Form of Tender (with employers letter and acceptance)
- Special Conditions
- The Conditions
- Contract Drawings
- Specifications
- Schedule of Rates
Can the Architect (PM) dismiss an individual?
Yes, due to incompetence, misconduct or other similar reasons.
What is the key thing to remember when assessing loss and expense claims?
It should be the ACTUAL loss incurred by the contractor
What are the common heads of claim in loss and expense applications?
- Prolongation (extra site overheads i.e. preliminaries)
- Thickening of preliminaries (e.g. extra supervision required due to variations)
- Disruption (causing plant / labour to be underemployed – hard to prove) Increases in labour / material costs during the period of delay
- Head office overheads
- Loss of profit (commonly combined with head office overheads)
- Finance charges (i.e. interest)
- Acceleration costs
- Claim preparation costs
How are head office overheads and loss of profit often calculated?
By the use of a formula – Hudson, Emdem or Eichlaey