Class Power And Crime Flashcards
Functionalism
- laws are a reflection of society shared values
- not everyone is equally socatised
- modern society have a complex divion of labour - subculture
- b miller lower class have own subculture with clashes with main stream
Strain theory
- deviant behaviour happen when opportunity are blocked to achieve legitimate
- Merton American structure deny w/c of achieving legitimate money success
- find illegitimate ways of achieving this - innovation
Subculture theory
- like strain w/c lack legitimate mean to achieve
- w/c are culturally deprived - bottome of the social heirachy leads to status frustration
- subculture solution to status frustration by inverting values
Labelling theory
- reject official statistics are useful
- seek causes of why w/c are labelled eg stereotype / typification
- crime stats are a constructi9n we must investigate by studying power control agency
Crimogenic capitalism
- capitalism by very nature causes crime , ruling class exploit w/c at whatever human cost
- give rise to crime : poverty only means of survival ; only way to obtain goods advertised ; alienation non utilarian crime
- also cause white collar crime , dog eat dog system, win at all cost
Gordon
Crime is a rational response to capitalist system hence is found in all classes
Chambliss-
Laws to protect private property are corner stone of capitalism, example in British east colony
- intrested in tea and coffee but needed plantation workers
- colony economy not money , so British introduced tax payable by cash
- tax money only eared by working - thus law on,y serve the higher classes
Selective enforcement
- powerless groups such as w/c are criminalised the courts ignore crimes of the powerful
Ideological function of law and crime
- laws crime , criminal play ideological function
- passed occasionally to benifit worker and give capitalism a caring face
Pearce
- laws often benifit the ruling class , keep worker happy + give capitalism a caring face - maintain false class consciousness
- not rigousl6 enforced law against corp homocide 2007 only one successful prosecution in 8yr
- arrest selective, media display criminal as disturbed
Evaluation - Marx
- ignore crime and non class inequality
- too deterministic
- crim just it’s system acts against capitalist class
The new criminology- Taylor et al
- agree with Marxist - cap based on exploitation- state selects and enforces law - classless society
- how’re also critism non and Marxistveiw
- put forward critical criminology
Anti determinism
- Taylor etal Marxism is too determin
- take volturaristic veiw - crime is a meanin&ul action taken by the actor
- often has a political motive - redistribution of wealth
- crime not passive , strive for change
A full social theory of deviance
- a full compressive explanation of crime and deviance would change soci3ty for t(e better
- two main sources of: Marx idea of unequal distribution of wealth : idea from Interactionalist effects of a deviant label
A complete theory of deviance six aspects
- wider origins
- immediate orgins
- act itself
- immediate orgin of societal reaction
- wider orgins
- effects of labelling
Valuation of critical criminology
- gender blind
- romantises w/c crime
Sunderland white collar crime
- coin term white collar crime , challenge stereotype that just w/ccrim
- however doesn’t distinguish between the two types - occupational ;corporate
- many of t(e harms caused by corporate crime do not breaks criminal law.
Tomb pearse
- widen definition of white collar crime
- any illegal act or omission result of a deliberate or cuprable negligence by a legitimate business intended to benifit the business
Scale of corporate crime
White collar crime estimated to be 10 x more common than ordinary crime
Tomb
- corporate crime has physical , environmental and economic effects
It is wide spread pervasive and routine
Financial crim
- tax espvasion bribery money laundering illegal accounting
- victims : other companies taxpayer and government
Crimes against consumers
- false labelling sell unfit goods
- ## 2011 French gov recommend women with poly implants prothese remove filled dangerous silicon
Crime against employees
- sexual and racial discrimination violations of wage law health and safety law
Statecoprate crimes
Harms committed when business and state work together increasingly important private companies work with government
Private companies accuse nth of toucherbof detainee during the American occupation of Iraq
Carribine et al
- we entrust high status professionals: finances security + personal info this all can be abused
- kpmg - admitte£ to tax fraud paid $456 mas fine , Ernest young fraud - cost tax payer £300 mil per year
- professional also can be employed by criminal launder forgery inflate fees
Abuse of trust case Shipman
- murderd 15 patients over 23 yr old, believed to be more
- 1976 convicted of obtaining opiate pethidine - forgery and deception also obtained enough morphine to kill 360 people - only given a warning
- this violates trust , Sunderland suggest why this is greater issue
Media - invisible corporate crime
- give limited coverage
- describe corporate crime as sanitised use language embezzlement = accounting irregularities, defrauding = miss selling death = accidents
Lack of political will
- tough on crime is focused on street crime
De labelling
- corporate crime is filtered out from criminalisation seen as civil matter
- fines are handed out rather than jail time
- 2010 French authorities list of 3600 British who had secret bank accounts, only one prosecution
Under reporting
- victim is society at a large rather than one person so head to identify
- even if vict8m is not aware they may not regard it as a crime
- may feel powerless against big corporations
Strain theory and corporate crime
- box apply strain to company - when company can not achieve goal of legally max profit may employ illegal ones , when a company becomes more difficult to maintain may breach law
- Yeager and clinard - laws are violated by latge company increase when company finance deteriorate
Sunderland differentiation association theory
- learn crime from Attitudes - if culture justify crime to gain; corporate goals employee will be socialised int9 this
- deviant subculture
- techniques of neural isation - individuals deviate more easily if they produce justification to neutralise moral objection
Labelling theory
- cirocourel - m/c can negotiate out of label
- nelken - de- delabelling , business have power to avoid label , have lawyers and accountant
- may be a reluctance of inability of law enforcement to procecure
Marx - corporate crime
- cop rate crime is normal fiction of capitalism, goal is to max profits lead to harm
- box - mystification- ideology corporate belive it is less widespread. / harmful - capitalism control t(e state so chooses when to enforce / prosecute