Class Flashcards
Evaluations - strengths
Official statistics show most crime is committed by w/c on other w/c individuals
Focus on social class allows concentration of resources on most deviant areas
Could help develop social policies to deal with the problem
Statistics
Study of prisoners in 2014: 43% had no educational qualifications Only 6% had degree 60% had been claiming benefits 36% had been unemployed
In 1994 only 8% of convicted criminal activity was from non manual backgrounds
Miller
Believed lower classes in America passed on a certain way of life/culture
Due to low paid, tedious jobs creates sense of ‘toughness and ‘excitement’
Often leads to deviant behaviour, fights, drinking and anti-social behaviour
Material and Cultural Explanations
Marx - material deprivation and lumpenproletariat w/c not in work/lowest paid jobs - alienation
Merton - strain theory
Cohen - subcultures and status frustration
Newburn and Reiner
Argue police discretion is important in influencing which law-breakers are likely to be arrested
They chose to focus on stereotype of criminals (w/c males)
W/c street crime consists of visible offences occupying most of police attention
M/c crime is more hidden
Class bias
Lower classes force class bias in the way their behaviour is criminalised. W/c are more likely to be convicted.
Chambliss - studied two youth gangs ‘the Saints’ from m/c and ‘Roughnecks’ w/c. ‘Saints’ got away with crimes such as drink driving and road accidents. ‘Roughnecks’ more likely to be involved in petty street crime. ‘Roughnecks’ given deviant labels. ‘Saints’ had ability to negotiate out of trouble.
Criminalisation of higher classes
Less easy to detect
Have more opportunity to commit white collar crime with low conviction rates - environmental and state crime - under policed crime
Shows how power is distributed in society
Tombs and Whyte - argue large corporations have economic, social and political power the leaders avoid prosecution even if causing harm eg fraud, 150 workers killed a year at work
Evaluation - weaknesses
Marxists would argue focus on w/c allows people to turn blind-eye to m/c crime
Bigger correlation between gender and crime
Several of explanations come close to victim blaming
Majority of w/c are law-abiding
State, corporation crime is more damaging to economy than street crime and it goes unnoticed
Farrington
Poor parental supervision Harsh disciplines Parental disharmony Rejection of children Low parental involvement with children Large family size Criminal parents/siblings present (your associated to delinquency)
All related to socio-economic factors and strong relationships found between delinquency and:
Low income
Large families
Residence in run down housing estates
Murray
Welfare policies
Keep deprived people outside labour force
Create welfare state dependency
Women knowingly becomes pregnant to secure welfare
Underclass responsible for majority of crime
Violence only form of expression for young men
Unemployment and Crime -
Rusche and Kircheimer - Marxists
‘Prisons help to control labour supply by jettisoning inmates when labour is scarce and filling up when labour is abundant’.
Reserve army labour
Unemployment and Crime
Economists refer to 2 theories:
Opportunity theory - periods of growth in the economy - crime rises - income rises - more goods in circulation - more opportunity for crime
Motivational theory - during recession the unemployed turn to crime as their legitimate income decreases - increased motivation
Cloward and Ohlin
Retained much of Merton’s theory on strain and unequal distribution
Position discontentment
Competition for higher status
Pressure for deviant behaviour
Emergence of delinquent subcultures