Chapter 14: Replication, Transparency, and Real - World Importance Flashcards
Direct Replication
- Researchers repeat an original study as closely as they can to see whether the effect is the same in the newly collected data
- It can never replicate the initial study in every detail
Replicable
- Results has been reproduced
- It makes sense that a finding should be replicated in order to be considered important
- Replication gives a study credibility and it is a crucial part of the scientific process
Conceptual Replication
Researchers explore the same research question but use different procedures
Replication plus Extension
Researchers replicate their original experiment add variables to test additional questions
Why Might Replication Studies Fail?
- Selctive publication
- Problems with original study/questionable research practice
- Sample size
- Harking
- P-hacking - Contextually sensitive effects
- Number of replication attempts
Harking
P - Hacking
Improvements to Scientific Practice
- Larger sample sizes
- Reportes all anayses and variable
- Open Science Collaboration
- Prergistration
Scientific Literature
- Nice review of the literature
- Consists of a series of related studies conducted by various researchers that have testes similar variables
- It is composed of several studies on a particular topic, often carried out by many different researchers
Meta Analysis
- Calculate the average effect size
- Create a mathematical summary of a scientific literature
File Drawer Problem
The ideal that a meta - analysis might be overestimating the true size of an effect because Null result and opposite results rarely published
Theory - Testing Mode
- External validity often matters less than internal validity
- hey are usually designing correlational or experimental research to investigate support for a theory
Generalization Mode
- When researchers want to generalize the findings from the sample in a previous study to a larger population
- They are careful to use probability samples, with appropriate diversity of gender, age, ethnicity and so on
- Frequency claims: always in generalization mode
- Association and causal claims: sometimes in generalization mode
Theory Testing Using WEIRD Participants
- Most research in psychology has been conducted on North American college students
- WEIRD = Westestern, educated, industrialized, rich and democratic
Ecological Validity
An aspect of external validity in which the focus on whether a laboratory study generalizes to real work settings