Chapter 14 Flashcards
3 key components of the best practices/open science
transparency
reproducibility
replicability
reproducibility
reproducing identical results from the same data
replicability
replicating results generated from older data by collecting new data through similar procedures
what does replication give to a study
credibility
3 types of replication
direct replication
conceptual replication
replication-plus-extension
direct replication
the original study is repeated as similarly as possible to determine whether the original effect is found in the new data
conceptual replication
the same research question and same conceptual variables but different operationalizations
in replication plus extension in what 2 ways can you replicate the original study
- add another level to an existing IV
- add another variable (makes it a factorial design)
what does a meta-analysis yield?
a quantitative summary of a scientific literature/ an average of the effects from all studies (published and unpublished( on the same variables
scientific literature
series of related studies conducted by different researchers who have tested similar variables
limitations to meta-analyses
null and opposite effects are rarely published so a meta analysis might overestimate the true effect size (file drawer problem)
solution to the file drawer problem of meta-analyses
actively seek unpublished data and use social media forums
origin of the replication crisis
only 39% of a random sample of 100 studies published in journals had been replicated
recommended rxns to the replication crisis
- ask why replication studies might fail
- ask what the best practices are to improve reproducibility
why might a study fail to replicate?
-if direct replication was used when it doesn’t make sense to use it
-if the researchers relied on only 1 replication study
-questionable research practices