Chapter 11: Moral Development and Chpt 15: Death Flashcards
moral development
changes of peoples sense of justice and what is right and wrong, and in their behavior related to moral issues
Kohlbergs theory of moral development
…
internalization
developmental change from behavior that is externally controlled to behavior that is controlled by internal standards and principles
Kohlsbergs theory
-developed theory 20 years after interviewing children from their answers to 11 dilemmas, Kohlberg hypothesized THREE levels of moral thinking
LEVEL ONE (preconventional reasoning) (stage one and two)
(9 years or younger) no internalization of moral values
-moral reasoning controlled by external rewards and punishment
stage one (Heteronomous Morality)
obedience and punishment orientations (how can i avoid punishment?)
- moral thinking tied to punishment
- obey due to fear of punishment
Heinz example
SHOULD NOT steal because consequence of prison which means bad person
SHOULD steal because worth 400 and not how much druggist wanted. offered to pay and not stealing anything more
stage two (individualism, instrumental purpose, and exchange)
what is right involves equal exchange (if im nice, others will be nice”
heinz example
SHOULD steal because happier if saves wife even if in prison
SHOULD NOT because prison is awful
LEVEL TWO (conventional reasoning) (stage 3 and 4)
internalization is intermediate (adolescence)
-individuals abide by certain standards, but they are standards of others
stage three (mutual interpersonal expectations, relationships, and interpersonal conformity)
- interpersonal accord and conformity (good boy/girl attitude)
- value trust, caring and loyalty to others as basis for moral judgement
heinz example
SHOULD b/c wife expects it and wants to be good husband
SHOULD NOT b/c stealing bad and he is not criminal, tried everything without breaking law
stage 4 (Social Systems morality) law and order
- authority and social-order maintaining orientation
- moral judgement based on understanding of social order, law, justice, duty
heinz example
SHOULD NOT b/c against law
SHOULD but take punishment and pay druggist. cannot run around w/o regard for law, actions have consequences
LEVEL THREE (post-conventional reasoning) (stage 5 and 6)
- early adulthood-20 years
- morality completely internalized
Stage 5 (social contract or utility and individual rights)
- individuals reason that values, rights, and principles transcend the law. They question laws
- evaluate laws in terms of degree to which they protect human rights
heinz example
(human rights) SHOULD b/c everyone has right to live
SHOULD NOT b/c scientists has right to fair compensation, even if wife sick actions not right
Stage 6 (universal ethical principles)
- so rare it is removed from theory
- individuals developed moral judgements that are based on universal human rights
- if conflict between law and conscience, human will follow conscience even though it may involve personal risk (Ghandi, MLK, mother teresa)
heinz example
SHOULD b/c saving life is more value than rights of another person
SHOULD NOT b/c others may need medicines bad, and their lives equally significant
Proposed 7th Stage (transcendental morality or morality of cosmic orientation)
- individuals moves beyond considerations of justice and see themselves as a part of the universe (not just part of humanity)
- links religion and spirituality with moral reasoning
Kolhbery and theoretical stages
kohlberg had trouble providing empirical evidence for even a sixth stage, he emphasized that most of his conjecture towards a seventh stage was theoretical
what influences stages?
- peer interaction is critical
- perspective- taking opportunities
- discussion provides move advanced moral reasoning
criticisms of Kohlbergs theory
- too much emphasis on moral thought and not enough emphasis on moral behavior (do what they say?)
- more attention should be paid to the way moral development is assessed
- culturally biased
Families and moral development
kohlberg believed family processes were unimportant in children’s moral development (families nicer than peers)
-peer relations more important- opportunity for give and take or perspective taking
parental discipline and moral development
…
Love withdrawal
-discipline technique in which a parent withholds attention or love from the child
-causes high arousal; evokes ANXIETY in child
ex/ “I dont like YOU when you do that”
power assertion
discipline technique in which a parent attempts to gain control over the child or the childs resources
-causes high arousal; evokes considerable HOSTILITY in child
ex/ spanking, threatening, yelling
induction
discipline in which a parent uses REASONING and explains consequences of their actions
-causes moderate arousal; focuses on childs attention on the actions/consequences rather than personal shortcomings
ex/ “Dont hit your brother, he was only trying to help”