BIOL313Z revision Flashcards
1) Functioning
In biological sense, healthy, uninjured, growing and ageing well
-is a healthy animal always happy?
2) Emotions
Minimise suffering, maximise positive experiences
-can you measure emotional experience?
3) Telos (being itself)
promote natural behaviour. Adaptive expenditure is acceptable
4) Coping
Use markers e.g. hormones to decide whether animals are coping well/poorly.
Person
has a biographical sense of self and can construct a narrative about it
Near person
evidence they may consciously remember past/anticipate future; but no language
utilitarianism morality
ethical decisions should bring about the greatest ‘good’ , taking into account all affected (i.e. all sentient individuals)
utilitarianism
-Applies to any sentient being, one who can experience/feel suffering
-All are equal when considering similar interests
challenges in implementing utilitarianism
-difference between suffering and reacting to stimuli
-idea that one individual is replaceable by another
Principles of replacement and neutral killing
- Good life (negative v positive experiences)
- Instantaneous, painless death
- Not harming others (socially, emotionally)
- Not a ‘person’ or ‘near person’
- do not kill mother of young animal or vice versa
-batch killing
-humane killing
contractarianism
-idea of social contracting - make an agreement as a society about certain practices
-morality: set of rules to govern the interactions of rationale agents, who self-interestedly contract to them
animal rights
-giving all animals the benefit of the doubt, don’t have to prove suffering
-morality= experiencing subjects of life have inherent value; killing=deprivation
-inherent value cannot be traded off (deontological as opposed to consequential)
egalitarianism
everyone is equal
prioritarianism
prioritise those that have less
animal rights: challenges of implementation
-debate over rights in companion animals
-limits scope for egalitarianism/prioritarianism
Brambell report
1) freedom from hunger/thirst
2)freedom from discomfort
3) Freedom from pain, injury and disease
4) Freedom to express normal behaviour
5) Freedom from fear and distress
Respect for Nature §
-“Biocentric egalitarianism”
-not only wrong to cut down forest because sentiment beings live in it, but also because the forest itself exists
Relational
things you do for your own animal but not for someone else’s
ill treatment of cattle
-Treated more as a joke at the time
-Lead to the foundation of the RSPCA
-Ox, cow, heifer, steer, sheep ,other cattle
- didn’t include bulls because of bull baiting
Animal Welfare Act 2006
-combines over 20 pieces of legislation
-Introduce new welfare offence:
-not sufficiently looking after animals rather
than just injuring them
-Applied alongside ASPA
Intergovernmental agreements
-Treaties, conventions
-Countries sign up or not
-Can be bilateral or multilateral
-Must enshrine the convention in National legislation
CITES
-Convention on international trade in endangered species
-aim: to ensure that international trade in specimens of wild animals and plants don’t threaten their survival
-Enshrined in Control of Endangered Species Regulation
EC Zoos Directive 1999
- Specifies regimes for licensing, inspection, record keeping and animal care
-Requires zoos to participate in conservation and education - Show benefit of keeping the animals
-Zoo licensing Act 1981 pre-dates directive
-Licensing authority: district council, zoo inspectors appointed by DEFRA
Regulation
-Stipulates what must be done
-No national interpretation
Council Regulation 1/2005/EC on the protection of animals during transport
-specifies
-specis to which it applies
-competencies of drivers
-distances and journey times
-who is in charge of loading
-absolute rules: no flexibility
statute law definition
Act of Parliament
statute law: how it occurs
-Told to the lords
-Meeting where it is discussed
-Committee stage: expert opinion, stakeholder consultation
-Report stage (3rd meeting) - amendments, vote
-if supported, goes to commons
-Second reading where its amended
-Royal ascent bill- act of parliament (law)
Statute law example UK
-Animal Welfare Act 2006
-Animal Welfare (Sentience Bill) 2022
-make provision for animal sentience
committee with functions relating to effect of
GOV policy on welfare of animals as sentient
beings
Key UK legislation
-1986 Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act
-Zoo licensing Act 1981 (Amendment)(England and Wales) Regulations 2002
-Welfare of Animals (Slaughter or Killing) Regulations 1995 (as amended)
-Veterinary Surgeons Act 1966
-Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981
-Animal health act
Limitations and Private alternatives
Standards to maintain a certain animal welfare level need to be effective, enforceable and economically feasible
stress
Any intrinsic or extrinsic stimulus that alters physiological function
Stress response
The compensatory physiological mechanisms
Alternatives to blood sampling
-Heart rate
-Ventilation rate
-Body temperature
Stress-induced hyperthermia
Rapid, hormonally mediated cutaneous vasoconstriction and thermogenesis in response to stress, leading to an increase in core body temperature
Nociception
detection of a noxious stimulus
Peripheral mechanisms
The noxious stimulation of tissues
Central mechanisms
Unconscious nociceptive processing by the spinal cord and brain
Somatic
Skin, bone, muscles, tendons and other tissues
Visceral
The internal organs, e.g. the heart, lungs, alimentary canal and other reproductive organs
Neurogenic
Nerves, the spinal cord and brain because of abnormal processing of nervous activity
Acute
Immediately follows injury and disappears when the injury heals. Usually associated with quantifiable changes providing the body with protection from damage
Acute recurrence
Prolonged pain, such as cancer pain, has a definable cause and consists of repeated attacks of acute pain
Chronic
Prolonged, however, little agreement as to when recurring bouts of acute pain become chronic pain or how long pain lasts before being chronic. Quantifiable changes to the functioning of defensive body processes may not be seen
Chronic inflammatory pain
Occurs when healing persist beyond the expected time, due to infection or other inflammatory processes
Chronic neuropathic pain
may not have a well-defined onset and may not respond to treatments that are effective against acute or chronic inflammatory pain. It is sometimes defined as “intractable pain”
Non-noxious stimulus
-makes animal aware of the state of its body
-Stimulation travels along Aß nerve fibres
-Rarely produces pain unless sensitised by inflammation
Noxious stimulation
-Makes animal aware of stimuli that could do harm
-detected by Nociceptors free nerve ending of thin;
-Myelinated Aδ
-Unmyelinated C fibres
Peripheral detection: Two types of nociceptors
-High-threshold mechanoreceptors (HTM)
->mechanical deformation
-Polymodal nociceptors (PMN)
->inflammatory mediators
Sentience
The capacity to experience feelings and emotions
-both positive and negative
cognition
The process by which animals perceive, process and store information. An animals cognitive capacity has no bearing on their ability to suffer
Physiological responses
-Primarily mediated by autonomic system and hypothalamic pituitary-adrenal axis in mammals
-> Heart rate, vagal tone, blood pressure, respiration rate, sweating, neuroendocrine responses
Physiological responses in other vertebrates
-beak trimming and feather removal -> increased plasma corticosterone and heart rate
-Suncutaneous noxious chemical -> increased opercular beat rate and plasma corticol
Physiological responses in invertebrates
Higher brain serotonin and blood glucose levels in crayfish exposed to aversive [putatively painful] electrical fields, together with long term motivational changes
Movement away from noxious stimuli
-does not demonstrate pain as can be nociceptive reflex response
-e.g. high temperatures-> foot withdrawal in many species
Attentional shift
in humans, distraction can reduce amount of pain suffered
-Pain processing in the CNS requires application of conscious central attentional control
-Same has been shown in chickens, consistent with ability to focus awareness
The importance of triangulation
-No definite evidence of pain when criteria taken in isolation
-BUT together can show a level of behavioural complexity that would require some form of experience i.e, sentience
Four categories of behaviour
1) Normal
2) Natural
3) Unnatural
4) Abnormal
Stereotypy
“repetetive, unvarying and apparently functionless Behaviour”
stricter stereotypy definition
“repetetive behaviour induced by frustration, repeated attempts to cope and/or CNS (Brain) dysfunction”
Stereotypy birds
-Perch hopping
-Route tracing
-Self injury
-Feather plucking
Stereotypy giraffes/other ruminants
-object licking
-tongue rolling
-pacing
stereotypy primates
-rocking
-head toss
-swaying
-spinning
-self manipulation
-hair plucking
-regurgitation and reingestion
Stereotypy elephants
-swaying
-weaving
-head-bobbing
-trunk swinging
-foot lifting
stereotypy carnivores
-Pacing
-weaving
circling
-head toss
stereotypy reptiles/amphibians/fish
-stereotypic swimming
-surface breaking
-absence of normal behaviour
-decreased activity levels
polar bears pacing
-more enrichment = less pacing
-more bears in exhibit = less pacing
-view out of enclosure = less pacing