Approaches Flashcards
Give positives of Wundt’s work on introspection
Led to development of useful general laws (e.g HUnter 2003)
Was first to try and apply natural sciences to human behaviour - paving the way for the science of psychology
Give weaknesses of Wundt’s work on introspection
Introspection can be highly subjective - memory and perceptions not observable.
Introspection activities often take part in labs and fail to represent real life
Give positives of biological approach
Significant contributions in the treatment of mental health (Davis et al Schiz)
Extremely scientific e.g blood tests, CSF, Brain scans etc
Evidence to support e.g phineas gage
Give negatives of biological approach
Evidence to suggest that biology can’t be only influential factor (Twin Studies)
Methodological issues ( Teubar)
Much of supporting research is done on animals (evolutionary discontinuity)
Outline Teubar
Found younger soldiers with brain damage recovered more than older soldiers (60% U20, 20% over 26). Negative correlation found between age and recovery - suggesting cause and effect cannot be proven
Outline Davis et al
Relapse occured in 55% SZ pts whose AP’s replaced with placebo, compared to 19% on AP’s - supports biological explanation
Outline Hunter 2003
Used introspection on teenagers, random beeps throughout day and had to report mood. Led to general law that teenagers had higher depression scores - but could be helped by challenging tasks.