4.1✅ Flashcards
what are the 2 types of policy development?
1) informal policy making
2) formal policy making
what is the informal policy?
• non-official ideas to prevent crime
• eg:
- schools (no touch policy)
- family (rules/sanctions)
what is a formal policy?
• policies from official bodies/official ideas to prevent crime
• eg:
- prison sentence
- fine
- community orders
what is the neurochemicals (diet) policies?
• low serotonin= aggression (crime)
• neurochemicals influences brain chemistry can be altered by diet (eg foods with serotonin- salmon/tuna)
what did Virkkunen do?
(1987)
Found violent offenders had lower levels of serotonin
Eg: artificial colouring (tartrazine-hyperactivity), vitamin B3 (treats SZ & violent behaviour)
what is the balance of good health plate?
Prisons (UK) uses balance of good health plate
- reduced sugar led to 48% decreases of anti social behaviour
what did Gesch (2002) do?
• 231 volunteers
• vitamin and faulty acids supplements (affecting neurochemicals)
• or a placebo (sugar tablets)
• average aggression incidents dropped by 35% for supplements group and 6.7% for the placebo group
• this shows that diet can have an impact of reducing aggression- crime
what is the 3 drug treatments?
1) chemical castration
2) antabuse
3) methadone
what is chemical castration?
• treating sex offenders with drugs
• SSRI’s to treat OCD and control of sexual families
• anti- androgen drugs which reduces testosterone, stubestrol makes the user impotent (lowers sex drives)
• mandatory in Poland, Russia, voluntary in Germany, France, Sweden
• in Scandinavia has reduced reoffending from 40% to >5%
what is Antabuse?
• treatment for chronic alcoholism by producing an acute sensitivity to ethanol
• this reduces alcoholic crime
• risk is insufficient impulse control
• taking this increases sickness
• causes discomfort/pain
what is methadone?
• substitute for heroin to reduce to reduce the withdrawal symptoms
what is eugenics?
• removing characteristics from a population
• introduced by Gatan
• eg: Holocaust
• aim to improve the genetics quality of human populations
what do eugenics policies include?
Genetic screenings, birth control, sterilisation, and forced abortions
what does sterilisation mean?
Someone who is being stopped for being able to reproduce
what is an example of sterilisation?
Nazi sterilisation caused 400,000 sterilised Jews
what is the law of sterilisation?
(1927)
• US Supreme Court made compulsory sterilisation for anyone who is deemed to be unfit
what biological determinism?
This is reinforced by genetic explanations of crime, that criminals have no free will/choice over their actions
- this justifies eugenics because the criminal population is reduced with people with these crimes eg: if criminals came out of prison they will still commit crime because of genes
why is eugenic policies good?
• pressure to control and reduce crime could be used as justification for policies
• effective if there is a criminal gene- MAOA/XYY- then eugenics would prevent future criminality
why is eugenic policies bad?
• unethical- violation of human rights and morally wrong to sterilise groups of people
• decriminalisation- of certain groups/certain characteristics, marginalised group, negative impact on individuals and wider society (easily abused)
• not all criminals have a criminal gene- there are other contributing factors for committing crime
• eugenics would not be effective in these cases- other strategies are less extremes and would be more effective
• some criminals can be reformed/rehabilitated which eugenics neglects
- criminals have free will/control over their behaviours
• sterilisation would prevent future criminals but not the individual committing crimes
why do we have the death penalty?
• driven by the biologically determined arguments
• justice for victims/families
• cost effective- frees up space in prisons
• prevents reoffending
• acts as a deterrent for other criminals
what is death penalty information centre (2022)?
• the south of USA had consistency highest murder rate and accounts for 80% of execution
• this shows that the death penalty does not act as a deterrent
what is the laws in death penalty?
• Uk is for murder only abolished in 1965 temporarily as the murder rate did not rise, abolition was made permanent in 1969 except for treason (1999)
• 2020, china is the top executioner. 483 executions in 18 countries (excluding China). Lowest number recorded in a decade. 2022-3 death penalty increased. Lowest number recorded in a decade (2020)
what are the benefits of the death penalty?
• deterrence (individual)
- murders will think twice before killing for fear of losing their own life
• retribution
- eye for an eye
- restored a balance
- brings closure to the family
• Japan had lowest crime rates
• more humane than a life sentence
• public opinion in favour for certain crimes
what are the limitations of death penalty?
• deterrence
- state in US that do not have the death penalty
- most do not expect to be caught
• wrongfully convicted people murdered
• human rights violation
• CJS should lead us to higher principles
- extends chain of violence
- pay back/ revenge
• 195 since 1973 released from death row due to innocence
• no opportunity for rehabilitation to reform
• disproportionately used against certain characteristics
- discrimination
what is psychoanalysis?
• talking therapy
• aims to access the offenders unconscious conflicts and repressed thoughts so they can be resolved
• based on the psychodynamic approach by Freud
• 1-2hours at a time 5 days a week long sessions from years
how could you access someone’s unconscious?
1) free association
- encouraging the patient to talk about anything that comes to their mind
2) hypnosis
3) dream analysis
- unconscious thoughts slip through in your dreams
what is the Rorschach test?
Inkblot test:
• recorded and then analyzed using psychological interpretation
• examine a person’s personality characteristics and emotional functioning
• accesses the unconscious