Week 10 - Zoning 2 Flashcards
How do we know when zoning is unconstitutional?
If it is arbitrary and unreasonable then pursuant to the standard from Euclid a court will likely find it to be unconstitutional.
How do we know when zoning is unconstitutional? If it is ________ and ________ then pursuant to the standard from Euclid a court will likely find it to be unconstitutional.
arbitrary and unreasonable
What is it that a local government can do to try to keep their zoning from being arbitrary and unreasonable?
What procedural safeguard can the city institute?
Comprehensive Plan
If a _________ ________ in place houses over here, schools over here, parks next to that, businesses retail commercial office, and then factories. Problem uses far away from the residential.
comprehensive plan
If you are attempting to have your zoning ordinance upheld, you will have drafted a __________ ________ in conjunction with that __________ __________.
comprehensive plan
zoning ordinance
When people come to the _______ _____ ______ _________ seeking variances or special exceptions we can look back at our comprehensive plan as we make decisions.
board of zoning appeals
When people come to the board of zoning appeals seeking ________ or ______ ________ we can look back at our comprehensive plan as we make decisions.
variances
special exceptions
When people come to the board of zoning appeals seeking variances or special exceptions we can look back at our __________ __________ as we make decisions.
Comprehensive plan
Example: subdivision didn’t sell of its lots the way it thought it would and there is a big space at the front of the subdivision that is empty. Developer would like to do something with it. Perhaps the hustler club or some other adult entertainment establishment has been looking for just the right place. Would it be a good idea to put the adult entertainment at the beginning? I don’t know let’s look at the ___________ ________. Where are the other adult entertainment establishments? They are all within x number of feet from the closet residence and this is not so maybe this is not the best place for the adult entertainment.
Comprehensive plan
As ___________ and ______ _________are trying to figure out how to use zoning to maximize productivity and land values and to minimize nuisances there are a lot of things being taken into consideration.
municipalities
local governments
Prevent harms: by dividing the community into _____ ________ and putting the residential over here and the industrial over there, we are preventing that nuisance-based harm.
use districts
Different __________ in each district. Fancy part of town – McDonalds signs are short and classier. No signs that are taller than the height of the buildings. Zoning can regulate things like signage: height, brightness, placement, size, distance from the road, how you use things.
regulations
Legislative body either drafts or authorizes the ordinance. ________ _________ might write it but the city council, the local legislative body approves it and then the board of zoning appeals deal with administrative matters.
Planning Commission
legislative body either drafts or authorizes the ordinance. Planning commission might write it but the city council, the local legislative body approves it and then the ______ _____ ____ ______ deal with administrative matters.
Board of Zoning Appeals
__________ ________: Uses which are permitted as of right. Yes you can build your house here, the zoning ordinance says this is where houses get built.
Administrative Matters
Administrative matters: Uses which are permitted as of right. Yes you can build your house here, the _______ _________ says this is where houses get built.
Or do you want to use it in a way that is permitted only after special approval? Are you seeking a _______ or ______ ______?
zoning ordinance
variance or special exception
How many types of variances are there?
2
A type of business that wasn’t usually there. Business closer to the road than it is supposed to be. Numerical aspects of the business. Anything dealing with numbers.
What kind of variance is that?
Area Variance
Doing renovations on my house or building a new house from scratch. I have this idea of how I want the master bath to look and to make it spacious I want a jetted tub.
I have hired this architect, and they are not cheap, and I have paired all this money, and they show me my dream master suite and I have an awesome tub. Only problem if we can figure it the way that makes sense from a plumbing standpoint it is not 20 feet from the road like the zoning ordinance says it has to be because it is only 17.5. The neighbors might say it is too close to the road. I don’t want to build something that violates the law because they could penalize me through whatever mechanisms they have through their zoning code enforcement.
What is this an example of?
Area Variance
Doing renovations on my house or building a new house from scratch. I have this idea of how I want the master bath to look and to make it spacious I want a jetted tub.
I have hired this architect, and they are not cheap, and I have paid all this money, and they show me my dream master suite and I have an awesome tub. Only problem if we can figure it the way that makes sense from a plumbing standpoint it is not 20 feet from the road like the zoning ordinance says it has to be because it is only 17.5. The neighbors might say it is too close to the road. I don’t want to build something that violates the law because they could penalize me through whatever mechanisms they have through their zoning code enforcement.
Why am I actually not able to do that? Why can I not violate the law with my new construction if I am a normal person who a bank loan and am not independently wealthy?
Not going to be able to get the bank to give me money and they want to know that the permits have been pulled and the building permits cannot be pulled if I am in violation of the zoning law. My ability to pay this back hinges on my ability to move in. I have to pay to live somewhere and if this place never gets built, I may default.
Lot of reasons why if I am involving the bank the lender all of these things have to be approved and I am going to go to the Board of Zoning Appeals and ask for an area variance. Test you have to prove to get an area variance.
________ ________ cannot be pulled if I am in violation of the zoning law.
Building Permits
Subdivision – developer didn’t sell big, huge front lot and now urgent care there. Zoned residential when houses were built and not supposed to put an urgent care in residential and they went to the Board of Zoning Appeals seeking a variance to change the use of the property.
What does this refer to?
use variance
Subdivision – developer didn’t sell big, huge front lot and now urgent care there. Zoned residential when houses were built and not supposed to put an urgent care in residential and they went to the _______ ____ ______ _______ seeking a variance to change the use of the property.
Board of Zoning Appeals
When you go to the ______ ____ ______ _______ and say I want to put an urgent care on this property that is zoned residential– there is going to be a community hearing and all the people who live near there and are going to be impacted by the traffic flow and the noise will show up and be heard at the hearing. All the people were excited to be able to walk to the Dr. or there was an overwhelming compelling reason to allow it and it wouldn’t affect traffic control.
Board of Zoning Appeals
Lawful Non-conforming Uses
this is also known as what?
Valid non-conforming use
Grandfathered in is the same thing as what?
Valid Non-Conforming Use
To be grandfathered in it means you did something back when it was legal to do. It was not illegal to put up a shed. The rule has changed do you have to take down the shed?
most times no because you are a valid non-conforming use. the law changed but that doesn’t necessarily mean you have to change how you use the property.
Can we sell our valid nonconforming use?
YOU CAN
Can we sell our valid nonconforming use? You can. There is a rule now that says no sheds. The new use has to be _______ ___________ or _____ __________.
equally nonconforming
less nonconforming
The new use has to be ________ nonconforming or _______ nonconforming.
equally
less
Subdivision with urgent care – urgent care got built before a zoned community. And then later it gets zoned residential and the neighborhood springs up. Is that okay that they are existing as a business? Probably _______ ________ _______.
Valid nonconforming use
Dr’s get sick of seeing sick people and want to sell the land can they sell to the strip club NO because that is not _______ ___________.
equally non-conforming
Dr’s get sick of seeing sick people and want to sell the land can they sell to the strip club NO because that is not equally non-conforming.
If they want to sell to a dentist office or nail salon that is equally non-conforming.
Different types of activities – operating hours may be different noise may be different clientele may be different. You don’t want teenage son to be at the strip club and if they get to the urgent care that would be fine– may be different if less conforming use.
!!
!!
Zoning Basics – The Typical Ordinance
Divides the community into use districts, e.g.,
1. ?
2.
3.
4.
- Residential